Water bills: Where does my money go?

File photo of a Thames Water bill

Related Stories

As a mission, it sounded easy - to find out where the money from my humble water bill goes.

It turned out to be an eye-opening tale of global finance and deeply contentious figures.

My company is Thames Water, the UK's largest water and sewerage provider, with 14 million customers.

First I got on a train to Milton Keynes, home of the Open University, to meet Michael Pryke, from its social sciences faculty, who has studied the finances of Thames Water.

He explained that after privatisation in 1989, English and Welsh water companies were floated on the stock exchange and, as public companies, were expected to be accountable and transparent.

Since then, some have been bought by private groups of international investors seeking high returns.

'Human revenue stream'

Mr Pryke showed me a diagram of Thames Water's "wedding-cake" corporate structure. There were eight levels, including the water provider that sends me my bill.

One of the eight companies is registered in the Cayman Islands. The owners are the Kemble Water consortium, led by an arm of the Australian investment bank Macquarie, which manages a range of investors, including Chinese and Abu Dhabi sovereign wealth funds.

He explained how Thames Water raised money for investment, issuing bonds or securities. These are sold to investors who get their money back with interest, at some future date. The big surprise was these investors were not investing in pipes and sewers, but in customers' ability to pay their bills far into the future.

As Mr Pryke put it, "they're turning you into a walking, talking financial asset - a human revenue stream". Some of these bonds run until 2062, when I will be long gone.

Thames Water

Running tap
  • Serves London, Berkshire, Buckinghamshire, Gloucestershire, Kent, Oxfordshire, Surrey and Wiltshire
  • Is privately owned and has 14 million customers
  • Average customer bill for 2013-14 is £354
  • Recent figures show a 19% surge in pre-tax profits to £134m from April to the end of September 2013
  • Delayed paying corporation tax due to investments in its infrastructure amounting to £1bn a year between 2010 and 2015

He also explained that the process of securitisation involves various financial companies who earn fees at each stage.

He recited a list: "You've got financial advisors, you've got legal specialists, you've got credit facility providers, you've got finance lessors, you've got hedge counterparties, all of them paid out of household bills."

Next stop was Parliament, where I met Conservative MP Charlie Elphicke, a former tax lawyer, who showed me an unpublished report he has prepared on the water industry.

He was concerned about levels of dividends paid to shareholders. He said for the past three years, Thames Water had paid out more in dividends than it actually made in profits, borrowing to make up the shortfall.

He described this as "taking out the cash reserves they have, paying that out to shareholders and going down the bank to borrow more money".

By now I really wanted to talk to Thames Water. They wouldn't do an interview but told me Mr Elphicke was incorrect - though they did not produce specific figures for the past three years. Instead they quoted an average over eight years, saying the company "has paid out 82% of post-tax profits as dividends since 2006".

The structure of some water companies is largely composed of debt - the kind generated by securitisation.

'Focus on cash'

In his report Mr Elphicke looked at the "gearing" of Thames Water, that is, its ratio of debt compared to the capital in the business. His figures suggested 93% of the business was debt.

Again Thames Water said Mr Elphicke was wrong - because he had used an inappropriate measure of its debt (total creditors rather than net debt) and said the real figure was 76%. That was still pretty stunning to me.

Find out more

  • Listen to File on 4 on BBC Radio 4 at 20:00 GMT on Tuesday 14 January. Or catch it later on the BBC iPlayer.

Several other water companies have similar structures to Thames and similar levels of debt. Does it matter if a company is so "highly geared"?

Robert Miller-Bakewell, a leading water analyst, told me "there's no doubt" such companies are managed in a different manner.

"The whole focus is on cash and that may move attention away from issues like customer service and capital investment," he added.

Start Quote

I think there are an awful lot of clever wheezes going on in the water sector at the moment ”

End Quote Sir Ian Byatt Former water regulator

And then there's corporation tax. I learned that companies can defer paying it if they make big investments, but also if they're paying interest on debts. According to Mr Elphicke, my water company has paid no corporation tax for three years.

Thames Water does not dispute this. Indeed it has said it may not pay any, for up to a decade, because of the scale of its investments.

Most water companies have asked the regulator for lower price rises for the next five years, at or less than the rate of inflation. However, Thames Water wants to raise bills by 11% to help pay for a super-sewer to address sewage pollution in the Thames.

Some argue if the company had spent less on dividends it would have money in the bank to spend on the new tunnel.

Former water regulator Sir Ian Byatt, who oversaw the industry from privatisation until 2000, is opposed to the building of the Tideway Tunnel - he thinks there are cheaper options - but he too is outspoken in his view of Thames and its dividends policy.

"I'm very worried about the scale of dividends," he said.

"I believe that Thames in the last six years have paid out extremely large dividends and those dividends, I believe, should have been available for future investment, but because they've disappeared and because the structure is opaque and the authorities opaque - how do you get them back again?

"I think there are an awful lot of clever wheezes going on in the water sector at the moment and I'd like to see it much simpler and much more transparent and the companies required to explain where the money is going because I am also a bill-payer and I like to know where the money is going."

It has not been a reassuring journey for me. It has raised serious questions about transparency and fairness in our water industry. But next time I click the mouse to pay my water bill, I will have a better idea where the money is going.

File on 4 was broadcast on BBC Radio 4 at 20:00 GMT on Tuesday, 14 January. Catch it on the BBC iPlayer.

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    08:54: Euronext failure

    European trading platform Euronext says a technical incident is affecting its data on cash and derivatives indexes and opening quotes are consequently being delayed. "We are currently addressing the root cause of this incident," it says in a statement. "Trading and order entry are allowed and market data dissemination is correct".

    08:45: Fait accompli?

    A publishing glitch on Microsoft's blog appears to have accidentally revealed that the tech giant is buying up an email start-up called Acompli. An empty post was published on the site, but the URL was the giveaway - it contained the words "microsoft-acquires-acompli".

    Via Twitter Jonah Hull, senior correspondent, Al Jazeera English
    Jonah Hull

    tweets: "#OPEC breakfast. This is what you get when the oil price falls below $80."

    08:30: Vinyl record

    More than one million vinyl records have been sold in the UK so far this year - the first time the milestone has been achieved since 1996, reports the BBC's Dave Lee. The Official Chart Company says it will soon launch a weekly vinyl chart.

    08:22: Markets update

    Here's how the main European markets are looking in early trading:

    • In London, the FTSE 100 is down 0.1% at 6,721
    • In Frankfurt, the Dax is up 0.25% at 9,940
    • In Paris, the Cac is down 0.2% at 4,373
    Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: "Poundland shares up 3%. Company now valued at £800m."

    08:12: East Coast sale BBC Radio 4

    "This was the best of the three bids," Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin tells the Today programme. He adds the Stagecoach/Virgin consortium known as ICR, is offering an increase in the premium that will be paid to the government. Asked if the consortium will paying more than the other bidders he replies "Oh yes". But he says services will also be improved - 23 more rail services will operate from Kings Cross. "We have seen a magnificent transformation on the railways in this country since privatisation."

    08:05: Stagecoach shares

    Shares in Stagecoach are up more than 8% following the announcement that it won the East Coast rail franchise. Meanwhile, rivals FirstGroup are down 5.6%.

    07:50: Poundland profits

    Discount retailer Poundland has reported a near 12% rise in pre-tax profits for the six months to the end of September - to £9.3m. The retail chain, which debuted on the London Stock Exchange in March, said its target was to open 60 new stores in the UK and Ireland next year. It added it was on track to open 10 stores in Spain by the end of 2016, with three already open.

    07:46: East Coast sale
    Mick Cash

    The RMT trade union has come out all guns blazing. "It is a national disgrace and an act of utter betrayal that the government has confirmed that it is bulldozing ahead with the re-privatisation of the East Coast Main Line despite all the figures showing that the current public sector operator is handing over a billion pounds back to the British people while delivering huge improvements in service and customer satisfaction," says general secretary Mick Cash.

    07:28: Mulberry finally bags new creative director
    A woman walks past a video display in the shop window of a Mulberry store in central London

    Luxury handbag maker Mulberry has finally completed its search for a new creative director. It comes 18 months after Emma Hill, the woman who helped make Mulberry a household name, departed following a row with the firm's then chief executive Bruno Guillon over "creative differences". Mr Guillon left in March after Mulberry issued three profit warnings. The new creative director is Johnny Coca, currently head of design direction at Céline. He joins Mulberry in July 2015.

    07:24: East Coast sale

    ICR, as the consortium is being dubbed, is not an even partnership between Stagecoach and Virgin. The former holds 90% of the capital.

    07:16: East Coast sale

    Inter City Railways says: "The company will shortly begin talks with Network Rail and the Office of Rail Regulation to agree its plans to run new direct services from London to Sunderland, Middlesbrough and Huddersfield".

    07:12: East Coast sale

    "Over the next eight years Inter City Railways will pay the government around £3.3bn to operate the franchise."

    07:10: East Coast sale

    Inter City Railways, as the Stagecoach/Virgin consortium is named, says the deal will bring 23 new services from London to key destinations, and 3,100 extra seats for the morning peak times by 2020.

    07:00: East Coast sale

    A consortium made up of Stagecoach and Virgin has won the franchise to run the East Coast main line.

    East Coast
    06:54: Rémy Cointreau
    Rémy Cointreau

    Cognac maker Rémy Cointreau reports a 15% drop in operating half-year profit, to €102m. The French group says it "remained adversely affected by evolving consumption patterns in China," by which it means that officials are having fewer Cognac-fuelled soirées.

    06:50: Falling oil prices BBC Radio 4

    Speaking of balancing budgets, a number of analysts think Opec won't be able to reach an agreement on cutting oil production (which is needed to stop the supply surplus that is driving the oil price down) precisely because of a number of members have already done so - Iran has cut production by 1 million barrels a day as a result of international sanctions. Moreover, some members, such as Venezuela and Nigeria, simply can't afford to do so.

    06:40: Tibetan tapestry

    The latest entry in our Live Page series of artwork sold for exorbitant amounts is this 600-year-old Tibetan silk tapestry. It fetched $45m at an auction in Hong Kong - a record for art from the region. The good news is that the buyer will put the colourful thangka - which depicts the meditational deity Raktayamari, and was created during the Ming dynasty between 1402 and 1424 - on public display at a museum in Shanghai.

    06:24: Falling oil prices

    Here's an image that the delegates at Opec will be familiar with. It outlines the price per barrel of Brent crude oil that some states need to see in order to balance their budgets.

    06:24: Falling oil price BBC Radio 4

    The main item on the agenda at the Opec meeting is the falling oil price, and what to do about it. BBC economics correspondent Andrew Walker says lower demand has pushed the price down, caused by a slowdown in industrial production in the eurozone and China. But US oil production - thanks to fracking - is also at its highest since 1986 and that is putting pressure on the price of Brent crude as well.

    06:20: What is Opec?

    The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (Opec) is holding talks in Vienna later today, on how to address the 30% fall in crude oil prices since June. Our colleagues have put together a 60-second explainer that will tell you what the meeting is all about.

    06:10: Thomas Cook Radio 5 live

    Anne Richards, chief investment officer at Aberdeen Asset Management, tells Wake Up to Money that Harriet Green's shock departure from Thomas Cook yesterday doesn't feel "pre-ordained", and as a large shareholder, her company will be asking for an explanation. Thomas Cook's share price slumped 17% following the news.

    06:02: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning. We should also be getting details of who the East Coast Mainline is being sold to this morning too. According to the Mirror newspaper, the government has decided upon a French consortium which includes Kelios - ultimately owned by French state rail operator SNCF. Will bring you that announcement when it happens. As always get in touch via email at bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or on Twitter @bbcbusiness.

    06:00: Joe Miller Business Reporter

    Good morning. A cross-party report is understood to have recommended giving the Scottish Parliament new powers to set income tax and control some welfare payments. The report was commissioned after David Cameron, Ed Miliband and Nick Clegg promised shortly before the independence referendum that Holyrood would be given new powers, if people voted to stay in the UK. Stay tuned for more details.



  • photo of patient zero, two year-old Emile OuamounoPatient zero

    Tracking first Ebola victim and and how virus spread

  • A young Chinese girl looks at an image of BarbieBarbie's battle

    Can the doll make it in China at the second attempt?

  • Prosperi in the 1994 MdSLost in the desert

    How I drank urine and bat blood to survive in the Sahara

  • Afghan interpetersBlacklisted

    The Afghan interpreters left by the US to the mercy of the Taliban

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.