Russian bailout masks Ukraine's economic mess

Ukraine protesters Political protests have obscured Ukraine's deep economic problems

Related Stories

There is no shortage of grim data that could illustrate Ukraine's troubled economic condition.

But perhaps the most damaging statistic is to do with gas prices.

Ukrainian consumers pay approximately 20% of the wholesale price of gas, leaving the state with a huge bill and destabilising the state-run energy monopoly Naftogaz Ukrainyi.

Poor deal

Successive governments have been unwilling to upset voters by raising the price of gas, which has contributed to the government's strained financial position.

To make matters worse Ukraine has struggled to negotiate favourable deals with its main gas supplier - Russia.

Back in 2009 the government signed a 10-year deal with Russia that has been described as "disastrous" as it saw Ukraine pay much more than European nations for gas.

Russia's leader Vladimir Putin and Ukrainian former leader Yulia Tymoshenko In 2009 Ukraine signed a unfavourable gas deal with Russia

Although Ukraine has negotiated a discount since then, gas imports have caused other economic problems.

To help pay for the gas, Ukraine's central bank has been propping up the Ukrainian currency the hryvnia.

Reports say the central bank has recently spent around $800m defending the currency, which has helped deplete the nation's foreign currency reserves.

The expense of propping up the currency and subsidising gas has made international investors reluctant to lend money to Ukraine.

To borrow money on the international markets, Ukraine was facing interest payments of more than 8%, which is extremely high for a national government.

Financial crunch

But Ukraine needed fresh funding.

Next year it has to refinance around $7bn worth of foreign debt and almost $3bn of that was owed to the International Monetary Fund.

That pressure meant Ukraine's President Viktor Yanukovich badly needed the $15bn of financing from Russia.

And in the short term the financing from Russia will prevent the nation heading for default.

Gas pipes Ukraine Ukraine's energy market needs reform

But it will not fix Ukraine's deeper economic problems.

Lilit Gevorgyan Senior Economist at IHS Global Insight says Ukraine has suffered from a "toxic combination" of poor economic policy making and a slump in demand for its exports of steel and capital goods, like industrial machinery.

As mentioned above the nation's currency is kept artificially high to help pay for imports, including gas, as well as keeping foreign debt servicing low.

But that has made Ukraine's exports much less competitive on the international markets. Ukraine is a big exporter of steel and machinery but those exports have slumped, partly because of the strong currency, but also weak demand from customers in Europe.

Ms Gevorgyan says that since Orange Revolution of 2004 governments have failed to take tough decisions that would stabilise the economy.

And that stabilisation is sorely needed as the economy has been in recession for more than a year.

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Business stories

RSS

Business Live

  1.  
    09:59: Land Registry
    Sold sign

    The Land Registry suggests that house price inflation (for England & Wales) is slowing down too. Prices still rose in the year to November, it says, by 7.1%. But that was the slowest rate of increase since June, corroborating the Nationwide's earlier report of a slowdown.

     
  2.  
    09:36: Wage rises

    When will wages rise? It's been one of the most persistent questions of the past year. And earlier this month it was reported that wage rises finally overtook inflation for the first time in around six years. But, the Trades Union Congress (TUC) thinks we shouldn't get too excited by that. According to a report in the Guardian, the TUC is warning that real wages - that's wages versus inflation - will take another decade to recover to the level they were at before the financial crisis kicked in, in 2008.

     
  3.  
    09:19: Italian recession over

    Italy's economy minister Pier Carlo Padoan has said the slowdown in the Italian economy has ended. He told daily Corriere della Sera: "After three years of recession ... employment is starting to grow again," Mr Padoan said the increase in employment would boost consumer and business confidence and kick start growth in the third-largest economy in the euro zone. He added government would approve a package of measures in January to boost investment.

     
  4.  
    09:01: Market update

    London's FTSE 100 Index is 0.5% lower this morning at 6596.78 as share indexes across Europe fall back on a new drop in oil prices. Brent crude is currently trading at $56.90 per barrel. That's its lowest level since May 2009. Next is up nearly 4% to 6775.00p on the back of its trading update earlier today.

     
  5.  
    08:44: Next
    Next store

    Despite churning out all that cash to shareholders by way of special dividends, the company is still happy to have "net debt" of £550m, which is more than a year ago. Intriguing. Why not pay off that debt instead?

     
  6.  
    08:27: Next

    Shareholders in Next have every reason to be feeling smug this morning. The company is generating so much spare cash that it is going to pay a fourth special dividend this year. That will be another 50p per share, bringing the total payout this year from special dividends and share buy-backs to more than £400m. A reminder of why you might like to consider investing for dividends, rather than share price growth. But it all begs the obvious question: how come other retailers can't compete with Next?

     
  7.  
    08:11: Greek crisis BBC Radio 4

    Greece's debt to GDP ratio is now just around 2% to 3%, according to Ms Pryce. That's down from 15% in 2009, which she points out is a huge achievement for the country and its people, who have suffered an enormous amount of pain over the last six years. It's also a better debt to GDP ratio than the UK, she points out. Whether Greece exits the bailout in two months' time is debateable, Ms Pryce says. Greece's budget wasn't austere enough to achieve the deficit reduction the Troika wanted to see, which is why Mr Samaras didn't get the deal on the bailout he wanted. The Troika is highly likely to demand further €2bn worth of austerity, Ms Pryce adds.

     
  8.  
    07:59: House prices
    Estate agent's window

    "The slowdown in housing market activity is surprising given further steady gains in employment, a pickup in wage growth (albeit from low levels) and the continued low level of mortgage rates," says the Nationwide's chief economist Robert Gardner. "If the economic backdrop continues to improve as we and most forecasters expect, activity in the housing market is likely to regain momentum in the months ahead," he adds. The average UK house now costs £188,559, by the way.

     
  9.  
    07:53: Next
    Next store

    Next has kicked off the traditional flurry of post-Christmas trading statements. Total sales for the whole year to 24 December were up 7.7%. And the clothes retailer expects pre-tax profits for the year to the end of January to be £775m, which would be a 12% rise on last year.

     
  10.  
    07:48: Greek crisis BBC Radio 4

    Greek economist Vicky Pryce tells the Today programme she is "amazed" European politicians let Greek prime minister Antonis Samaras go away from bailout negotiations empty handed last month. He had wanted Greece to exit the bailout agreed with the international Monetary Fund (IMF), European Union (EU) and European Central Bank (ECB) - otherwise known as the Troika - at the end of this year. Instead the bailout has been extended to the end of February. "It is extraordinary that they didn't see the implications that this would have on the political climate in Greece and that it would bring about the possibility of a complete eurozone crisis as a result," she says.

     
  11.  
    07:31: Black Britain BBC Radio 4

    The Today programme's guest editor, Lenny Henry, has been exploring the lives and experiences of some of Britain's most successful black people. The first person we meet is Andrew Ramroop, who became the first black business owner on London's Savile Row, when in 1988 he bought the tailoring business he had worked at since his arrival in the UK in 1970, from Maurice Sedwell. He describes how at first he was kept away from working directly with customers because of his skin colour.

     
  12.  
    07:26: House prices

    The Nationwide says annual house price growth has now slowed for four months in a row. And it means prices have risen slightly less in 2014 than they did in 2013. Quite a surprise given the way prices were shooting up earlier in the year.

     
  13.  
    07:15: House prices
    For Sale signs

    The growth of average house prices across the UK still appears to be slowing down, says the Nationwide building society. Its latest monthly report says prices in the year to December rose by 7.2%, but that was less than the 8.5% rise in the year to November.

     
  14.  
    07:04: The "deficit"

    The CBI says that cutting the deficit should be the government's priority in 2015. But is that the annual Budget deficit or the national debt? The past year has seen a very long queue of people, especially journalists and politicians, who airily talk about "the deficit" while clearly confusing the two.

     
  15.  
    06:55: Russia crisis
    Russian Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev

    Russian prime minister Dmitry Medvedev has signed an order boosting the capital of the country's second-biggest bank VTB by 100 billion roubles ($1.7bn). The funds will be transferred from the National Wealth Fund as a part of wider plans to support Russia's banking sector, which is suffering from Western sanctions imposed on Moscow over its role in the Ukraine crisis.

     
  16.  
    06:42: More jobs

    As many as half a million more jobs may be created in the UK this coming year, predicts the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD). Hurrah! But in its 2015 forecast it says this probably won't translate into real wage increases. Boo!

     
  17.  
    06:26: Greece BBC Radio 4

    Laura Lambie of Investec tells the Today programme: "There is no doubt that there will be [stock market] uncertainty until the election in late January or early February [in Greece]." But she doesn't seem to think this will create the same level of panic as in previous crises. Claims that the left wing, anti-bailout, Syriza party will win an overall majority in the election are about as overdone as they were three years ago she adds. Ms Lambie says uncertainty will continue this year because there are several European general elections, not least of which is our own in the UK. Spain and Portugal also elect new governments this year.

     
  18.  
    06:13: Dividend investing
    Financial trader views financial information including the FTSE 100 index.

    The real attraction of stock market investing? Dividends, and the power of reinvesting them. BBC personal finance reporter Brian Milligan explains it in How to make money despite the FTSE's 15-year losing streak .

     
  19.  
    06:04: City Link Radio 5 live

    City Link's former owner Better Capital hopes to recoup 50% of its investment in the parcel delivery firm - that's £20m in case you were wondering. Ian Senior, an independent postal economist, tells Wake Up To Money: "It looks as if the pain will be avoided by Mr Moulton… the one thing to look at is does City link have assets that other firms might want to take over." But he adds that those firms will need to move quickly because most of those assets are human and will be looking for work in the New Year.

     
  20.  
    06:03: Ian Pollock Business reporter, BBC News

    We are here again, before we head for the end-of-year duvet and remerge in 2015. If you have any views on what the next year will bring us, let us know on bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or via twitter @bbcbusiness.

     
  21.  
    06:03: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning folks. We have some house price data out later this morning as well as trading updates from posh cooker maker Aga, and Next. And Lenny Henry is guest editing the Today programme from 06:00 and has interviewed French economist Thomas Piketty, so plenty to come.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.