Dubai Air Show: Plenty of planes, but is there enough airspace?

Al Fursan, the aerobatics demonstration team of the UAE Air Force perform during the Dubai Air show No fly zones have made the airspace even more crowded in the Middle East

New airports, hundreds of billions of dollars worth of new aircraft: some of the big-spending Gulf states and their airlines seem to have limitless resources and ambition.

But the countries have so far been unable to resolve a problem that now threatens their aviation growth.

All those new aircraft ordered at the Dubai Air Show will need space to fly. Trouble is, the airspace above the Gulf is already worryingly congested.

The authorities and the airlines know there is a problem. It's just not clear if anything can be done about it.

"Delays are becoming common place. And delays will only grow as operations grow," warns Hussein Dabbas, regional director of the International Air Transport Association.

"If we don't stop the proliferation of delays, the system will slowly disintegrate - bringing down the efficiency of airlines with it."

Start Quote

There's no doubt that congestion is the biggest challenge facing the aviation industry in the Middle East”

End Quote John Swift Former manager, Dubai International Airport

The number of aircraft movements through United Arab Emirates' airspace last year was more than 741,000, according to official figures. It is forecast to reach about 895,500 by 2015, and 1.13 million by 2020.

Air travel to and from Qatar, Bahrain, Oman, and elsewhere, is also forecast to rise rapidly.

The problem is that air traffic management in these countries was planned in isolation. The fragmented airspace and lack of co-ordination has historical and geopolitical roots.

The result is a patchwork of boundaries and airspace corridors, and limited co-operation.

"There's no natural single regional body that can grab the issue and deal with it," says John Swift, a former manager of air traffic control at Dubai International Airport.

No-fly zones

Several commissions and working groups have looked into the traffic management problems. "Lots of organisations and airlines want to do something, but progress is slow," he says.

"There's no doubt that congestion is the biggest challenge facing the aviation industry in the Middle East," says Mr Swift, now the Middle East director at NATS, which runs the UK's air traffic services.

Part of the problem is that civil aircraft are off limits to large swathes of airspace used by the military.

In the strategically important UAE, for example, 50% of the airspace is controlled by the defence department, leaving civil aircraft a narrow corridor through which to fly.

Planes parked on tarmac at Dubai airport The success and rapid expansion of Gulf-based airlines has resulted in new infrastructure being built in the region

In Europe, countries have a flexible approach to airspace. Civil and military aircraft use airspace according to need, Mr Swift says. "Both sides are able to carry out their business and national defence operations without problem.

"Aviation officials from the Middle East who visit NATS in the UK are often surprised to see civil and military controllers sitting side by side," he says. "But it is an approach that the region could certainly benefit from."

Mr Swift, who advised UAE authorities on airspace issues for the construction of Dubai's new airport, says technology is not an issue. Many Gulf countries have state-of-the-art air traffic management systems.

The UAE's Sheikh Zayed Air Navigation Centre was opened in 2009, and is one of the most sophisticated in the world.

So, unlocking more military airspace for civil use is not a technical problem, Mr Swift says. It is more a question of will and determination.

Losing faith

All the parties seem to agree that co-operation and co-ordination is key. But that has so far proved easier said than done.

The UAE has a general civil aviation regulator, but the Emirates also have individual authorities. They meet regularly, including with the military. Scale up this bureaucracy to a regional level, and you have a maze of competing interests.

The frustration among those who run airports and airlines is evident.

Needless concerns over sovereignty, nationalism and politics "are getting in the way of logic", said Dubai Airports' chief executive Paul Griffiths in a recent widely reported speech. Huge investment on the ground was now threatened by a failure to address airspace issues, he warned.

It is particularly important for the UAE, where aviation forms such a substantial part of the economy. In Dubai, aviation is almost 25% of GDP and a huge employer.

Dubai Airport is next year expected to overtake Heathrow as the biggest in the world. The new $32bn (£19.8bn) Al Maktoum International will be even bigger.

Dubai Al Maktoum airport Dubai's Al Maktoum International Airport lies half an hour's drive outside the city

The UAE is not just a tourist destination. Abu Dhabi, Dubai, along with near-neighbour Qatar, are vital connection hubs for people criss-crossing the globe.

Reports of missed flights caused by delays on the ground and circling overhead are growing.

Transit-travellers have plenty of alternatives, such as Singapore. Turkey is investing heavily to ensure Istanbul exploits its geographical position.

"If people start losing faith in the business model, that will be a serious problem," Mr Swift says. "Eventually, people will have to start thinking about about protecting their investment. An aircraft on the ground does not make money."

'Difficult choices'

Mr Swift describes airspace as an "invisible infrastructure" that should be treated and managed like an economic asset. "If any asset is underperforming, it undermines the business model. Present the problem in financial terms, and it might spur action."

Last month, Airbus ProSky, the air traffic management division of planemaker Airbus, completed an official report on how better to manage UAE airspace.

It made 53 recommendations.

Ahmed Al Jallaf, chairman of the UAE National Airspace Advisory Committee, says the recommendations meant that the authorities had some "difficult choices" to make.

"Times will become more challenging as we start working on the implementation of the [Airbus ProSky] study," he says.

However, none of the recommendations have been made public. Many people can only guess at the future strategy.

Yet, even if the UAE gets its airspace in order, other states for whom aviation is not a core economic interest may not follow suit.

In Europe, so-called Functional Airspace Blocks are organised along the most appropriate operational needs, regardless of country boundaries. Europe is moving towards an eventual Single European Sky.

For many people, a similar model is the only answer for the Gulf. But it is years away at best, and few people would disagree that the region needs this now.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    UK UNEMPLOYMENT 09:33: Breaking News

    The number of people out of work in the UK fell by 77,000 between December and February to 2.24 million, according to official figures. The unemployment rate fall to 6.9%. At 1.7%, the rate of growth of earnings is now running about the inflation rate of 1.6%.

    STARBUCKS 09:14:
    File photo dated 13/08/2013 of Starbucks takeaway cups at a Starbucks in central London,

    Starbucks is moving its European head office from Amsterdam to London. It says half of its European cafes are in the UK, so it makes sense. Last year the firm paid corporation tax in the UK for the first time since 2009 following pressure from politicians and campaigners.

    Via Twitter Douglas Fraser Business and economy editor, Scotland

    tweets: "Metso of Finland rejects Weir Group merger proposal. Weir reassures with commitment to Finnish base, but no certainty it'll revise offer"

    CHINA GROWTH Via Blog Linda Yueh Chief business correspondent
    Graduates in Beijing

    blogs: "By the gauge of incomes and not the headline GDP figure, the economy is doing better, not worse, than last year. Rural incomes are growing more quickly than urban incomes, which reduces the rural-urban income gap and improves the consumption prospects of half of the Chinese population."

    TESCO 08:54: Radio 5 live
    Tesco shop and trolleys 16/04/2014

    "They (Tesco) are trying to be all things to all women and men... it's realising that model is not working any more," says Andrew Saunders, Deputy Editor of Management Today on 5 live. The supermarket business is polarising and "the bit in the middle is going away," Andrew says. It needs to get closer to Aldi and Lidl.

    MARKET UPDATE 08:42:

    The benchmark FTSE 100 index in London rose 0.7%, with Tesco up 3.9% as traders said Tesco's fall in profits was not as steep as some had feared. Hargreaves Lansdown was up 2.5% after an upbeat trading update. Germany's Dax index rose 1% and France's Cac 40 rose 1%.

    Via Twitter Victoria Fritz Business reporter, BBC News

    tweets: "UK figs at 9.30 could show pay increases finally outstripping inflation for the 1st time since the crisis. Exp. 1.8%av pay v 1.7%inf."

    TESCO Via Email Louse Cooper, analyst from CooperCity

    "Looking at the charges and write downs, international expansion has cost Tesco dear. There is an European asset impairment charge of £734m and a write down of £530m for the Chinese business (now deemed "discontinued")."


    Just a reminder, in a little over an hour's time the Office for National Statistics reports labour market data. It includes the latest unemployment and average earnings data. This is what happened last month.

    TESCO 08:22: BBC Radio 4

    More from Tesco chief executive, Philip Clarke, on the Today Programme. How will he fix it? "We can reach every postcode," he says. Customers can get their hands on their shopping at stores, through deliveries and by collecting their order. "I am sure Tesco will be a leader again." Tesco shares are up 4.3% in early trading.

    TESCO 08:18: BBC Radio 4

    Tesco chief executive, Philip Clarke, is on the Today Programme. Why are sales down? "Consumers are feeling the long-run impact of lower income," he says. He will change the supermarket and get customers back to the middle market, challenging cheaper rivals like Aldi and Lidl, he said. "Discounters will never allow you to be cheaper than them but you can get closer to them," he said.

    TESCO Richard Hunter, from the stockbrokers Hargreaves Lansdown

    tweets: "Over the last 10 years, the Tesco share price has risen 32p. Every little helps."

    gaviscon double action

    Amid the excitement about Tesco, Reckitt Benckiser, which makes Gaviscon heartburn medicine, releases first-quarter sales. Revenue excluding currency swings rose 3% to £2.37bn. The company is on track to meet its target for 2014 of increasing sales 4-5%, it said.

    TESCO Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: "Clarke tells me "Aldi and Lidl are formidable...we need to be much, much closer to them, or at the same price. But we have to be different.""

    HOME BUILDING 07:49:
    File photo dated 05/01/14 of houses

    Homebuilder Persimmon is giving the market an update on its progress. The firm says forward sales for 2014, which includes homes not yet completed, is 38% ahead of last year, with an average selling price of £200,400, which is about 3% higher.

    Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: Tesco's Clarke: "Now have 1,750 Click and Collect locations, including 6 Tube stations"

    CREDIT SUISSE 07:34:
    Credit Suisse, Zurich

    Swiss banking giant, Credit Suisse, says first quarter profits fell by more than a third. It made $979m in the quarter. Group revenue fell by 8%. The bank blamed less activity in its bond-trading division.

    TESCO 07:29: Radio 5 live

    Reacting to Tesco's profits on Radio 5 live James Bevan from CCLA Investment Management says: "The tanker is slowly beginning to turn." Asked about Tesco's international business he says: "It's important that they are expanding in clothing in the United States." And he reminds us that "the value of its property book is well in excess of its market value".

    TESCO 07:18: BBC Radio 4

    BBC Business Editor Kamal Ahmed has been examining Tesco's earnings report for the Today Programme. He said, "supermarkets have been built on the idea they will sell more and more and more" and large ones including Tesco are suffering "the shock of the discounters". He notes that Tesco are now expanding beyond food. "They do have the bank and are about to offer current accounts, and restaurants."

    TESCO 07:00: Breaking News

    Tesco annual profits have fallen by 6% to £3.3bn and like-for-like sales, which strip out the effect on new store openings, have fallen by 1.4%. Tesco also also announced a £734m loss of value in its European business which has been hit by the Eurozone crisis.

    RAIL 06:53: BBC Radio 4

    Sim Harris, managing editor of Railnews is talking about figures from the Office for Rail Regulation on the Today Programme. Total government support for railways in the UK was £4bn for the 2012-13 financial year. It's a bit of a myth the railways system is fully privatised, said Mr Harris. "A little bit of railways are in the private sector, while most is in the public sector," he says. Network Rail, which owns the track, is publicly owned.

    TESCO 06:41: BBC Radio 4

    Plenty of advice for Tesco this morning. On the Today Programme Laura Lambie at Investec Wealth & Investment says: "People are shopping with their feet". Customers are buying cheap food at Aldi or treating themselves at Waitrose or Marks & Spencer with less money spent between, she says. Tesco "must try to get their strategy right".

    TESCO 06:33: BBC Radio 4

    "The real problem for Tesco is it hasn't moved with the times," says Bruno Monteyne, a senior analyst at Sanford C. Bernstein on the Today Programme. "If you really want some great prices you can go elsewhere," he says. The company is facing "what we call a value-quality duopoly," says Mr Monteyne. Either people want cheap food or high-quality food "a bit of everything isn't good enough," says Mr Monteyne.

    CHINA GROWTH 06:22: Radio 5 live
    China flag

    China's economy expanded by 7.4% in the first quarter of the year, better growth than many were expecting. But it is a slowdown from 7.7% growth in the final quarter of last year. On Radio 5 live, Oliver Barron, head of the Beijing office at the investment bank NSBO says the growth is "a little bit lacklustre". Policy makers are starting to worry "a little bit".

    Mainland China 100 Yuan notes

    The US has told China its currency must be allowed to rise if it, and the global economy, are to see stable growth. Unlike the euro and the dollar, the value of the yuan is not set by the market but is kept within certain limits of other world currencies. The US Treasury's twice-yearly report to policymakers says the yuan is "significantly undervalued".

    TESCO 06:13: Radio 5 live

    On Wake Up to Money John Coll, an analyst at Kantar Worldpanel, puts Tesco's problems into some perspective. He remind us that they have more than double the market share of their nearest competitor. He says the are trying hard to be "dynamic and innovative".

    JET FUEL 06:08: BBC World News
    Handout photo dated 15/07/13 issued by British Airways of a British Airways Airbus A380 flying over the cliffs at Dover

    Willie Walsh, chief executive of British Airways' parent company IAG, has been talking to the BBC about his company's project to buy jet fuel made from waste. The GreenSky fuel plant, in Thurrock, Essex, will supply about 2% of the fuel needed by the company. He denied the project was mere "greenwashing" and said it will have a real environmental impact. "This is turning waste that would have been producing methane into fuel," he said.

    TESCO 06:03: Radio 5 live

    Expect to hear a lot today about the "Watford model" from Tesco's chief executive, Philip Clarke according to retail analyst Phil Dorrell on Wake Up to Money. Watford has a giant Tesco mega-store. It is a "step-change" but is a costly model, according to Mr Dorrell. He warns that chief executive Philip Clarke has just 16-18 months to improve Tesco's performance.

    TESCO 06:00: Radio 5 live

    Some stinging words on Wake Up to Money for Tesco's management from Phil Dorrell who runs a consultancy called Retail Remedy. "The senior team is stumbling around looking for a code to get market share to where it should be," says. "Innovating is not going to get them out of the current troubles," he says. They need "a clear strategy of where they are going" and how they will "improve the vast majority of their stores," Philip says.

    06:00: Howard Mustoe, Business Reporter

    Good morning! Get in touch via twitter @BBCBusiness and via email

    06:00: Ben Morris Business Reporter

    Tesco reports annual results at 07:00 and analysts are talking about a 10% fall in profits. Check-in with the Business live page for the details. And good morning!



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.