Can spending millions on art ever be a good investment?

Three Studies of Lucian Freud, Francis Bacon Three Studies of Lucian Freud is the most expensive artwork sold at auction

Related Stories

Consider the idea of spending $142m (£89m, 106m euros) on a work of art and then being told you have bagged a bargain.

A number of art critics have said that the price paid for Three Studies of Lucian Freud (1969), by Francis Bacon, is money well spent.

While the anonymous new owner decides how to insure and where to hang the triptych, stretched householders may wonder how a purchase like this could ever be a good deal.

And should they decide to invest in art themselves - at a less spectacular level - then there are warnings that the value of such items can go down as well as up.

Crisis? What crisis?

Start Quote

Some people say it is vulgar to talk about art and money at the same time”

End Quote Estelle Lovatt Art critic

The Bacon masterpiece became the most expensive artwork ever sold at auction when it went under the hammer after six minutes of frantic bidding.

Calculations by The Economist suggest that Van Gogh's 1890 work Portrait du Docteur Gachet actually cost more at auction if inflation is taken into account. The $82.5m paid for that painting in 1990 is the equivalent of $148.6m at today's prices, the magazine says.

Meanwhile, in 2011, the Qatari royal family paid more than $250m for a Cezanne in a private sale, The Economist adds.

All the same, $142m is an eye-watering amount of money, even though there are three paintings in the set, and especially as we are only slowly emerging from a global financial crisis.

Pink Star The Pink Star was sold for $83m at auction in Geneva

A total of £782m was spent during the Christie's auction of post-war and contemporary art that night.

On the same day as the Bacon sale, a diamond known as the Pink Star sold for $83m (£52m, 62m euros) at auction in Geneva - the highest auction price for a gemstone.

"At the moment people wonder how come art is securing such funds," says art critic Estelle Lovatt.

"When you consider interest rates at the banks at the moment, your money works much better and the result looks much prettier on the wall or on a plinth.

"It has been an incredible year [for art sales], especially given the financial situation.

"Some people say it is vulgar to talk about art and money at the same time - cash is the C-word in the art world. But it is a great investment."

Or is it?

Top v bottom

Just a few hours after record-breaking sums were being bid in New York and Geneva, a watercolour work called Portrait of a Lady was sold for £238 at an auction in Edinburgh.

Another watercolour entitled Flower Arrangement went under the hammer for £275, and the top sale of the day was a mahogany bookcase that fetched £18,750.

Auctions such as this are taking place across the country most days of the week, buoyed in part by the popularity of daytime TV auction shows such as Antiques Roadshow and internet auction sites.

The Scream by Edvard Munch The Scream by Edvard Munch could have been yours for £74m

Yet, it is a two-pace market, according to Richard Madley, a fellow of the National Association of Valuers and Auctioneers (NAVA).

"It is akin to the London housing market compared to the rest of the UK, where prices go up and up in the capital," he says.

"A work by Bacon is like an eight-bedroom house in Belgravia, while the chest of drawers is the two-bedroom cottage in the North East which remains affordable," he says.

While the global super-rich keep spending record-breaking amounts at the top end of the market, prices of domestic, lower-value antiques have tumbled, he says.

For example, last year, $119.9m (£74m) was paid for Edvard Munch's The Scream, whereas in the last 10 years the typical price of a traditional dinner service or a Victorian wardrobe has halved.

The reason is that masterpieces will usually retain their appeal, while lower level furniture and art are at the mercy of fashion.

"Antiques are not cool. Young people in their 30s and 40s do not want what their parents hung on the wall; they do not want a big Victorian extending dining table; they want glass and chrome," Mr Madley says.

Chinese lesson

Anyone considering taking the risk of investing could look for a lesson in the market for works from China and Japan, according to auctioneer Mr Madley.

Auction tips

Auctioneer's gavel
  • Visit an auction to watch before taking part
  • Look at the guide prices in the catalogue
  • Go to a preview to see what is being sold
  • Do not forget the extra cost of the buyer's premium - the auctioneer's fee

Bidding for Japanese porcelain hit its height in the 1990s but prices have fallen since.

Yet, as disposable income rises in China, the new middle class and wealthy are buying back the heritage that left the country in decades past. Chinese ceramics, bronzes, jade and metalwork are proving particularly popular.

In one case, Mr Madley says, a Chinese pottery bowl that had a reserve price of £200 sold for £37,000. A lot such as this is known as a sleeper, which is awoken by frantic bidding.

Anyone thinking of buying at auction for the first time should ask for help before the bidding starts, Mr Madley suggests, and they do not need to worry that scratching their nose could be mistaken as a bid and cost them thousands of pounds.

"Auctioneers look for serious bidding signals, and bidders now are often given a piece of paper with their number on when they register," he says.

Other tips include:

  • Have a look around on preview days, talk to the auctioneer, and pick up a catalogue
  • Look at the guide price. The minimum amount that the seller will accept is confidential, but cannot exceed the lower estimate
  • Watch an auction first, before taking part
  • Remember the extra charge, known as a buyer's premium. It can vary from 5% to 25% of the bid price. Ask about the cost beforehand

The most important advice when buying art, according to Mr Madley, was a tip he was given as a young man by one of his bosses.

"Buy art with your eyes and not your ears. It must give you pleasure to look at it, don't buy it because someone tells you it will be worth more in a few years' time," he says.

Still, ask anyone who was at the auction of the Bacon triptych last week, and they will say that as the bidding hit stratospheric levels, they could believe neither their eyes nor their ears.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    CO-OP GROUP 10:37:
    A branch of the Co-operative Bank on April 11, 2014 in London, England

    "I've said I will lead the organisation through a period where we need to steady things, which includes governance reform," said Mr Pennycook. Journalists are asking whether he will stay if reform isn't forthcoming. The group's lower shareholding in the bank won't dilute the ethical stance of the lender because that is "enshrined" in its company rules, he said. He won't "name names" when it comes to the bank's failures as there is an official report in the pipeline, he said.

     
  2.  
    CO-OP GROUP 10:21:
    A pedestrian passes a Co-operative retail store in east London, April 10, 2014.

    More from Mr Pennycook on the Co-op's results. They will open 100 new convenience stores this year, he said. It is an area Co-op does well, he said. They will sell their farms and pharmacy businesses and expect a "conclusion" on that process towards the end of the year. Being "all things to all people" means they have been "too thinly spread."

     
  3.  
    CO-OP GROUP 10:13:

    Co-op Group interim chief executive Richard Pennycook is speaking on a conference call. He says the company will cut about 60% of the stores Somerfield brought with it when it bought it in 2008. They are too large and don't "work for" the firm, he said.

     
  4.  
    TAYLOR WIMPEY 10:04:
    03/07/2008 new Taylor Wimpey home

    Homebuilder Taylor Wimpey's chief executive Pete Redfern says the firm "made a particularly strong start to the year." It expects to improve operating margin, a profitability measure, by 2-3 percentage points in 2014, it said. Sales for the year will be "slightly ahead" of 2013.

     
  5.  
    CO-OP GROUP 09:47: Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    "The Co-op Group chief executive has laid it on the line - this business needs to reform or it will face dire consequences. His words about "management failings" and these results being "disastrous" and the "worst in our 150 year history" are a clear message to anyone who thought that the business could carry on in the same way."

     
  6.  
    HIGH-FREQUENCY TRADING 09:42:
    Trader

    The Financial Times reports that New York's attorney general has sent subpoenas to six high-frequency trading firms. A subpoena is an official request for a person to testify, or an organisation to provide information. In this case it's a development of the investigation into high-frequency trading. Such firms are suspected of having an unfair trading advantage.

     
  7.  
    LIFE EXPECTANCY 09:28: BBC Radio 4

    People about to retire and deciding what to do with their pension will be given guidance as to when they're likely to die, under a proposal being floated by the pensions minister, Steve Webb. Most people underestimate their life expectancy by around 3 years. So says Tom McPhail of Hargreaves Lansdowne, on Today.

     
  8.  
    CO-OP GROUP 09:18: BBC News Channel
    Kamal Ahmed, Business Editor

    BBC Business Editor Kamal Ahmed says that stinging comments from Co-op Group boss, Richard Pennycook shows he is trying to get momentum behind the reform agenda. Kamal says the results have a small amount of better news - debts have come down slightly and funds will be generated by the sale of pharmacies and farms.

     
  9.  
    CO-OP GROUP 09:13:
    File photo dated 16/07/13 of a Co-operative food store

    Most of Co-op Group's loss related to the bank. It booked a loss of £1.44bn up to the date it lost control of the bank, and then took another charge of £625m when it handed over 70% of the bank's shares to bond investors. The company also wrote down the value of Somerfield by £226m.

     
  10.  
    CO-OP GROUP 09:03: Breaking News

    The Co-operative group has announced a loss of £2.5bn for the year to 4 January. "The scale of this disaster will rightly shock our members, our customers and our colleagues," says chief executive, Richard Pennycook.

     
  11.  
    PETROBRAS PROBE 08:53:
    Petrobras HQ, Rio

    Brazilian police named 46 suspects including an executive at oil company Petrobras in an alleged $4.5bn money laundering and drug operation, according to AFP. Authorities are investigating a gang for illegal currency trading, diamond trafficking and bribing government officials along with money laundering and drug allegations. Two of the suspects are on the run, said AFP, citing local media.

     
  12.  
    MARKET UPDATE 08:42:

    Shares in London have drifted lower in early trading. The FTSE 100 is down 0.2%, with Diageo the biggest loser after it reported a fall in sales in the third quarter. Shares in RSA Insurance have jumped almost 3% after announcing the sale of businesses in the Baltic states. In Frankfurt the Dax is down 0.2% and the Cac 40, is little changed.

     
  13.  
    BEER 08:29: Radio 5 live

    Colin Valentine of Campaign for Real Ale is on 5 live telling us beer is just as good for us as wine. There is some science behind his claim, he says. Alas, it is only healthy in moderation, according to Mr Valentine. "When people talk about beer bellies it's not just the beer we are talking about," he said.

     
  14.  
    SPIRITS TUMBLE 08:21:
    Diageo Claive Vidiz Collection

    It's a rough morning for shares in the makers of some of the world's best-known spirits. Diageo, the owner of Johnnie Walker, is down 3.8% and Remy Cointreau is down 6.2%. Remy warned that annual operating profits could be down as much as 40%. Diageo reported that sales in the three months to the end of March fell 1.3%.

     
  15.  
    NEW CAR SALES 08:02:
    New cars, Sheerness Kent

    Demand for new cars in the European Union increased for the seventh month in a row in March, according to the European Automobile Manufacturers Association. It says car registrations rose 10.6% last month. The UK was the strongest of the major markets with a 17.7% rise, Italy was the weakest with a 5% increase.

     
  16.  
    HEADLINES
     
  17.  
    FRANCE DEFICIT 07:48:

    France will slightly slow the pace of its deficit reduction, according to the French Finance Minister, Michael Sapin. In an interview on RTL radio he said that the move had been discussed with European partners. Last week new French Prime Minister Manuel Valls vowed to cut both taxes and spending in a bid to make the French economy more competitive.

     
  18.  
    GOOGLE 07:37: BBC Radio 4
    Google logo

    Google's core business is getting a little "dodgy" according Larry Magid, technology analyst for the website C-Net on Today. They are not getting the revenue on phones that they are on the web, he says. "Some of the crazy ideas have got to get a little less crazy and more profitable," he says, referring to new businesses like robotics and drones.

     
  19.  
    DIAGEO 07:26:
    whisky

    The maker of Johnnie Walker whisky Diageo said sales in the three months to the end of March dipped 1.3%, led by a 19% drop in Asia because of political instability in Thailand and weaker China demand. India, where the firm is trying to buy United Spirits, delivered sales growth of at least 10% it said.

     
  20.  
    REMY COINTREAU 07:18:
    glass of scotch

    A cut in ostentatious spending by Chinese officials will hit profit for Remy Cointreau, the French distiller said. Full-year operating profit will fall as much as 40%, as sales in cognac fell 32% in the fourth quarter. The maker of Remy Martin cognac, Cointreau liqueur and Mount Gay Rum said sales for the three months to the end of March fell 16% to 186 million euros (£153m)

     
  21.  
    MULBERRY 07:14:
    Mulberry bags

    Handbag maker, Mulberry is introducing a "more affordable product" as it attempts to reinvigorate sales. It has also warned that pre-tax profit for the year to 31 March will be "marginally" below current expectations. The firm is looking for a new chief executive after the departure of Bruno Guillon last month.

     
  22.  
    CURRY 07:07:
    lamb curry

    A third of lamb curries tested by the Foods Standards Agency were found to contain cheaper meat. While no horsemeat was found in the watchdog's 145 samples, 25 were found to be just beef with no lamb.

     
  23.  
    CHINA WOMEN 07:02: BBC Radio 4

    In China there is an official phrase "left over women". It refers to single, urban women over the age of 27. On Today Leta Hong Fincher from Tsinghua University, says that Chinese state media has been insulting these women with the phrase and pressuring them into finding a husband and settling down.

     
  24.  
    HORSE RACING 06:48: BBC Radio 4
    Future Champion Novices" Steeple Chase

    40% of the population will watch some kind of horse racing during the year, claims Simon Bazalgette, chief executive of the Jockey Club on the Today Programme. That's why sponsors from the Middle East and big companies are keen to get involved in the sport, he says.

     
  25.  
    CO-OP GROUP 06:35: BBC Radio 4

    "Turkeys" and "angry birds" is how Michael Mol, professor of strategic management at Warwick Business School refers to senior managers at Co-operative Group on Today. He is "very worried" about their ability to take the right decisions. He thinks Co-op Group will have to find money to invest in the struggling Co-op Bank, despite only now owning 30% of the lender.

     
  26.  
    EASTER EGGS 06:25: Radio 5 live

    Are the walls of chocolate Easter eggs getting thinner? Yes, says Lee McCoy, editor of Chocolate Reviews, on 5 live. More shocking, there may be a shortage of the Easter treats. It seems Tesco have run out of a number of lines, especially eggs made by Cadbury and Nestle, as well as some Lindt and Mars eggs, the Daily Telegraph reports.

     
  27.  
    FOOTBALL 06:13: Radio 5 live
    Danny Mills, Robbie Savage, 2004

    More from Danny Mills. He's invested in a pasty company through private equity, but would he invest in football? Five-year contracts for staff (footballers) and the highest sporting wages in the world mean it's a game for "billionaires" he said. "You can't blame the footballers," he said, as anyone would take the money offered. Picture above shows Danny in his playing days, exchanging views with fellow BBC pundit Robbie Savage.

     
  28.  
    PASTIES 06:06: Radio 5 live
    Pasties

    Former England and Leeds footballer Danny Mills is part of an investment group that has bought West Cornwall Pasty Company from administrators. He tells 5 live: "There's a gap where banks just aren't lending," he said. The original company's strategy was "too aggressive" and expanded too quickly, which led to its demise. He blamed the pasty tax for the rising price of pasties.

     
  29.  
    CO-OP GROUP 06:01: Radio 5 live

    Michael Mol, professor of strategic management at Warwick Business School is on 5 live talking about Co-operative Group, which releases earnings today. "You have two different issues: the bank issue with huge losses," he said and "the group facing losses from the Somerfield acquisition". More losses could be on the way if they don't reform their governance structure, he said. They also have too many lay members who "don't know how to run a business," he said.

     
  30.  
    GOOGLE 06:00:
    Google building

    Google is likely to be under scrutiny today after it released results late on Wednesday that some considered disappointing. Google still made $3.45bn (£2.05bn) in its first quarter. But some are expressing concern about a surge in costs. That reflects Google's move into new businesses, including robotics and drones.

     
  31.  
    06:00: Howard Mustoe, Business Reporter

    Hello from me. Keep in touch via @BBCBusiness and bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk.

     
  32.  
    06:00: Ben Morris Business Reporter

    Good morning! Watch out for results from Co-operative Group due at 09:00. You can expect Google to be in focus today as well, releasing results which some investors consider disappointing.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.