Is Ireland's economic hangover really over?

Woman walks past street art in Dublin Every week, some 1,000 people leave Ireland to find work overseas

Related Stories

"There was a brashness and preoccupation with wealth that rested uncomfortably with the Irish psyche," says businessman and corporate turnaround expert Sir Gerry Robinson of his country's boom years.

The Donegal-born former chief executive of Granada TV and drinks giant Allied Domecq feels that the economic crisis from which Ireland now finds itself emerging might have been anticipated by many people.

"Some of the more fundamental things that mattered in life were being eroded," he says.

"We were driven by the quick buck.

"And now there's a sense that something was missing. I guess there's a kind of Catholic mentality - an understanding that they would have to pay for all this."

And pay for it the Irish certainly have.

Since the 2008 crisis, unemployment has risen to 15%, GDP has crashed by a fifth and debts have soared.

Sir Gerry Robinson Businessman Sir Gerry Robinson says Ireland's boom years saw a brash preoccupation with wealth

The Republic of Ireland is one of the most indebted countries in the developed world, with a quarter of mortgages at least three months' in arrears.

Start Quote

I'm on the same wage as I was seven years ago”

End Quote Mandy Freeman Theatre nurse

Mandy Freeman is a specialist theatre nurse in a major Dublin hospital. Her public sector take-home pay has been cut by a fifth but her huge mortgage has not and now she has to pay for her two daughters' university costs.

'It's been very difficult'

She describes herself as one of Ireland's new 'working poor'.

"I do feel I've been robbed of the years where I worked up the ladder and now I'm on the same wage as I was seven years ago," she says.

Ireland's GDP may now be rising and unemployment may be falling, as are government borrowing costs, but Mandy is one of many who say they have not yet felt the warm glow of this recovering economy.

"It's been very difficult for people on mortgages and young families, people in the education sphere and the health area," says the Irish prime minister, Taoiseach Enda Kenny.

That Ireland is growing at all is something of an economic miracle, and Mr Kenny himself describes what happened to the country in 2008 as "catastrophic".

Mandy Freeman Nurse Mandy Freeman says her wages have been cut by 20%
Low business taxes

Irish banks loaned billions of euros to anyone and everyone on the premise that property prices could only go up.

Start Quote

It is upsetting to feel that I have to leave the country and leave behind my own family”

End Quote Robert Byrne Student, University College Dublin

When the wholesale money markets folded, Ireland's economy collapsed.

Since then nearly €20bn (£16.7bn) of spending cuts and tax rises have been introduced and foreign investment has continued to flow inwards.

This is because Ireland was and remains one of the most open, business-friendly economies in the world - with a young well-educated workforce.

Foreign firms "find the supply of labour a good place to be - they find Dublin, Cork and Limerick good places for industry to be based," says Frances Ruane of the economic think tank ESRI.

Importantly, taxes on profits for all companies, domestic or global, stand at only 12.5%.

It has helped to attract the world's biggest names in technology - Facebook, Google, Twitter and AOL all have major operations around Dublin.

'It seems very strange'

And crucially for the nation's sense of sovereignty and self-belief, next month Ireland is set to exit the €85bn international bailout programme it entered three years ago.

Google's European headquarters in Dublin, Ireland Ireland's low tax rates have encouraged inward investment

But for most people who don't work in the tech sector, like Mandy Freeman, if they've kept their jobs they have had an economic migraine for the past five years - with big cuts in take-home pay.

Start Quote

Maybe there is a kind of inbuilt expectation that even when things are going quite well, it's not going to last”

End Quote Fintan O'Toole Irish Times

"We used to go to the cinema once a month as a family and try and go out for a meal, but they aren't really options any more. It's just too expensive," she says.

For many others, emigration has been the safety valve, which has kept Irish unemployment from reaching Spain's heady heights.

Whereas historically it was the uneducated who left, now 1,000 well-educated young people are taking their talents overseas every week.

Most are leaving because they cannot get the right kind of work in a feeble domestic economy.

Robert Byrne, aged 21, is a psychology undergraduate from University College Dublin (UCD), Ireland's largest university. He wants to work in a hospital but the crisis has seen the public sector shrink, so he is bound for Australia or New Zealand.

"It seems very strange because I grew up in an environment when everyone thought the Irish economy was the best thing ever.

"But unfortunately in the last five years we've seen that it was not sustainable.

"It is upsetting to feel that I have to actually leave the country and leave behind my own family," he says.

In a BBC-arranged debate among UCD students, well over half said they intended to emigrate. Yet asked if they were optimistic about their futures, 90% raised their hands.

'You respond by going'

Watch Joe Lynam's Newsnight film in full

Perhaps that is the dichotomy of the Irish psyche; resilient, optimistic, yet fatalistic in its world view.

"Maybe there is a kind of inbuilt expectation that even when things are going quite well, it's not going to last," says Fintan O'Toole, of the Irish Times.

"The Irish have never really had a huge amount of faith in their country, or the British empire which ruled them before that.

"So how do you respond to hard times? You respond by going, by getting out of the place and by trying to survive on an individual basis rather than by changing society itself."

One thing that could keep spirits up and emigration down is a thriving economy, and you get the sense that with a fair wind - economic resurgence in Britain and the eurozone - Ireland could be set to recover rapidly.

After a 15-year party and a five-year hangover, perhaps the Irish might not need as much aspirin in the coming years.

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    Zambian copper Via Twitter BBC World News

    tweets: Don't worry she was earthed - the BBC's Lucy Burton reporting from a copper mine in Zambia today for @bbcworldservice (Listen here from 17:30)

    12:01: Skymark jump

    Shares in Skymark Airlines jumped 26% following a report that the Japanese carrier was in talks with Japan Airlines. Nikkei business daily's online edition said the firm was negotiating code-sharing with Japan Airlines on some routes.

    11:44: Public sector borrowing

    According to the ONS, income and capital gains tax receipts rose 1% to £10.5bn in October. Meanwhile, another bundle of receipts including corporation tax receipts rose to £7.5bn in the month - but an increase of just £100m compared to the same month a year ago. The Treasury had been hoping for a bit more of a bump this year, particularly from the oil and gas industry.

    Bank account raids Via Email

    HM Revenue & Customs says: "Plans to recover tax and tax credit debts directly from the bank accounts of people and businesses who refuse to pay what they owe will include strong safeguards to protect vulnerable taxpayers... A consultation on the plans published in May included a significant number of guarantees to provide certainty to taxpayers, such as only applying the powers to established debts and only targeting debtors who have repeatedly ignored attempts to make contact."

    11:15: China rates

    The People's Bank of China said it will lower its one-year benchmark lending rate by 0.4 percentage points to 5.6%, its first cut in two years. The Australian dollar surged to the day's high and London-listed shares in mining companies jumped by 3-4%.

    10:59: Public sector borrowing

    But what about the whole lot all together? In October, public sector net debt excluding public sector banks was £1,449.2 billion, or £1.45tn as we say, and 79.5% of GDP, an increase of £97.1bn compared with a year earlier. That's £3bn lower than the previous month and that's because Lloyds Bank has been reclassified a private sector body after the government started to sell out its stake in the bank earlier this year.

    10:46: Hornby earnings
    Hornby share graph

    Shares in toymaker Hornby are up 1.4% today to 73p on the back of its better than expected half year earnings. Earlier, it said it had halved its losses to £520,000 compared with a year earlier. Hornby also said sales were much improved: up 8% to £24.2m in the period.

    10:32: Public sector borrowing

    This financial year's borrowing target is £95.5bn, so with six months of the year left and the government already having borrowed £64.1bn, it still looks less likely the Treasury will hit its target. The question economists and MPs alike will begin to ask now will be, just how much will the government miss its target by?

    10:15: Public sector borrowing
    Graph showing public sector borrow

    The above chart tells you all you need to know about the current state of government borrowing. The blue dot is where the government wants to get to. The red dot above it is last year's borrowing. And the blue line trending up above all of those is the actual path of government borrowing at the moment. Safe to say the Treasury is hoping for a big dip in the graph in January.

    10:04: Public sector borrowing

    Borrowing increased at a slightly slower rate in October compared with the a month earlier, the Office For National Statistics has said. Public borrowing rose between April and October by £3.7bn. That compares with £5.4bn in April to September - which was a full 10% higher than a year earlier at that point. So borrowing has narrowed slightly.

    09:48: Engineering BBC Radio 4

    Sir James added: "We do need to keep certain people here, who come to our universities. They come to our universities because they like Britain, they want to study engineering and science and develop new technology in Britain, and I think we should encourage to stay here. So I would change our immigration laws to allow the right sort of people to stay here - people we desperately need."

    Public sector borrowing Breaking News

    The government borrowed £7.7bn in October, official figures show. That's a decrease of £0.2bn compared with the same month a year earlier.

    09:28: Engineering BBC Radio 4

    More from Sir James Dyson. He's not a fan of the European Union (EU). He thinks the EU is "dominated by Germany". "In our particular field we have very large German companies who dominate standard setting and any reduction committees and so we get the old guard and old technology supported and not new technology. So I don't like a Europe dominated by Germany. I don't see that we need to be dominated and bullied by the Germans."

    Twitter talk Via Twitter Rory Cellan-Jones Technology correspondent

    tweets: About to talk to Twitter and Square founder @jack about his plan to storm the UK cash register market

    09:03: Engineering BBC Radio 4

    Sir James Dyson has been talking to the Today programme about his company's plans to invest in the UK. He wants to boost engineering in the UK, he says. He says the majority of engineering researchers at British universities come from overseas. "We must encourage them to stay here and work for companies like Dyson and create wealth and technology here in Britain," he adds.

    08:50: Bank account raids
    Chancellor George Osborne r

    George Osborne will announce a series of climbdowns over controversial plans to allow the taxman to seize money directly from people's bank accounts, according to the Daily Mail. It reports the Chancellor will agree to introduce new safeguards designed to prevent misuse of the powers, expected to be applied to around 17,000 "persistent" non-payers a year. People will have to have a face-to-face visit from a tax official before money can be clawed back as well, it says.

    08:35: Market update

    In London, the FTSE 100 Index is up 0.17% to 6690.03, where the number-two riser is Rolls-Royce with their new engine order. Germany's Dax is up 0.36% to 9518.41 and the Cac in Paris rose 0.25% to 4244.97.

    08:21: Public borrowing BBC Radio 4

    So why low wage growth? Part of the problem is that the jobs being created in the economy are "relatively low paying" says Mr Tombs. He thinks it would be very hard for the government to pay for a rise in the personal tax allowance to £12,500 as the Prime Minister promised in his Conservative party conference speech in the next parliament without there being significantly bigger cuts in government department budgets.

    08:05: Public borrowing BBC Radio 4

    More from Mr Tombs: He says the Chancellor's borrowing target for this financial year is "completely out of reach". Borrowing would have to come down by a third in order, over the next six months, for the government to meet its target. "The real problem has been income tax receipts," he says. "They've been extremely weak and that's partly because we have seen very weak growth in average earnings across the economy But also the rise in the personal tax allowance has cost rather more than was expected."

    07:50: Public borrowing BBC Radio 4

    "We are expecting a small improvement [this month] in borrowing compared to the previous year. October is a particularly important month for corporation tax receipts and they have actually been growing at quite a healthy rates so far this year. Perhaps £7.5bn [in borrowing] compared to £7.8bn last year," Samuel Tombs, senior economist at Capital Economics tells the Today programme.

    07:35: Hornby earnings
    Hornby train sets in a toy shop

    Toy maker Hornby has reported a near 50% reduction in losses for the six months to the end of September to £520,000 - it lost £1.09m for the same period a year earlier. In June the Scalextric owner reported pre-tax losses increased to £4.5m from £2.5m a year earlier. New boss Richard Ames has embarked on a turnaround, since taking over in April. In the summer the firm announced it had ended its contract with a Chinese company after supply chain problems.

    Dulux boss Via Twitter Simon Jack Business correspondent, BBC News

    tweets: "Friday boss Matt Pullen runs Dulux hear him on dog, business and paint names like Sumatran Melody"

    07:14: Rolls-Royce deal

    Rolls-Royce has agreed a $5bn deal for engines with Delta Air Lines. New Trent XWB engines will power 25 Airbus A350s and Trent 7000 engines will power 25 Airbus A330neo aircraft.

    06:59: Market update

    Tokyo stocks closed higher by 0.33% as investors study Japan's preparation for an election next month. The Nikkei 225 index at the Tokyo Stock Exchange gained 56.65 points to 17,357.51, while the Topix index edged up 0.18%, or 2.54 points, to 1,400.18. In Hong Kong the benchmark Hang Seng Index edged up 25.42 points to 23,375.06.

    Banker's pay Via Twitter Simon Jack Business correspondent, BBC News

    tweets: "George Osborne's letter to Mark Carney on problems of higher fixed pay for bankers."

    06:39: Engineering boost BBC Radio 4
    James Dyson

    James Dyson is announcing a £1.5bn investment and has started building a new factory at the Dyson HQ in Malmesbury, Wiltshire. He has said it will eventually provide 3,000 new engineering jobs and he hopes it will lead to hundreds of new products being developed there. He'll be speaking to the Today programme later on this morning.

    06:24: Public borrowing Radio 5 live

    Karen Campbell of accountants Grant Thornton on Wake Up to Money says government borrowing is higher because tax receipts are down. Lower wage growth, lower stamp duty and lower gas and oil revenues have all caused tax to be down.

    06:14: Foreign direct investment Radio 5 live

    Foreign investment grew quicker in Wales last year than anywhere else in Britain, according to UKTI figures. Marc Evans is chief executive of Sure Chill and is on Wake Up to Money. His company has benefited from investment from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. Doing business in mid-Wales brings benefits, he says, but "it takes a little longer to get to the airport".

    06:02: Shale gas Radio 5 live

    "Are we serious about finding alternative energy?" asks David Buik, city analyst on Wake Up to Money. It's clean energy, he says. "The infrastructure is all there" when it comes to Ineos, he says.

    06:00: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning! Get in touch via or on twitter @BBCBusiness.

    06:00: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning folks. We have the latest public sector finance figures later this morning. But before that there are half year earnings from toy maker Hornby and brewer Fullers. Stay with us.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.