Twitter: It's worth how much?!

Pop singer Katy Perry Pop singer Katy Perry is Twitter's most popular user with more than 46,720,000 followers

Related Stories

Twitter's much-anticipated launch on to the markets is fizzing with fanfare and debate over how - given that it has never made money - the microblogging site, priced at $26 per share, is officially worth more than $18bn (£11bn).

The facts seem to contradict themselves. Twitter's growth is slow, and it shows no sign of making a profit - its losses for the third quarter of 2013 increased to $64.6m, from $21.6m a year earlier. And more than half of its total registered users don't even use it.

But some analysts predict that in the months post-share sale, the seven-year-old company's worth will increase to $20bn and beyond.

That would give Twitter a valuation of more than double the likes of global carmaker Fiat, with its very modest-sounding market capitalisation of 6.9bn euros ($9.3bn).

But Twitter is not alone in its sector when it comes to big price tags, if not profits.

Online "scrapbooking" website Pinterest was valued at $3.8bn in October after its latest round of investment, giving it the same value, in terms of market capitalisation, as the UK's second largest house-builder Barratt Homes.

Yet while Barratt has reported a full-year pre-tax profit of £192m for 2012-13, Pinterest has never made any money.

Its digital "pinboards" may be attracting users, there may be talk of advertisers paying for posts, but it has no revenue yet.

Michelle Obama's Pinterest page Michelle Obama shares her thoughts through her Pinterest page

So why do these social media companies have this value attached to them?

Value v price

Aswath Damodaran, a finance professor at New York University's Stern School of Business, told the BBC it was a bit like buying a house.

"You look at what other people are paying for something a little bit like what you are buying," he said.

"[But] you have to think about whether you are going to price [the company] or value it."

Twitter, Mr Damodaran believes, is being priced by bankers and brokers - not valued - and that pricing is coming from comparing it to its peers.

By this he means that value is something more complex and emotional, but that pricing is based on at-the-time comparisons.

Most notably, with Facebook.

Mark Zuckerberg (left) and Jack Dorsey Facebook's IPO made a billionaire of founder Mark Zuckerberg (left); Twitter's founders, including Jack Dorsey, could be in line for a similar windfall

"The big difference between Facebook and Twitter is that Facebook was making money [when it launched its IPO in 2012] and Twitter is losing money," said Mr Damodaran.

Facebook had a billion active users when it launched its shares. While Twitter is growing its user base rapidly - up 39% over the past year to 500 million - only 232 million of these are active each month.

Start Quote

MySpace is a constant reminder that a high and mighty service can lose its lustre”

End Quote Larry Magid Technology analyst, CBS

According to a recent report by analysts Pew Internet, 72% of internet users in the US use social networking sites, but just 18% use Twitter.

Plus, while users are invited to tweet their thoughts in 140 characters, many do not engage on the platform at all, leaving their registered accounts dormant.

Others prefer to simply follow news feeds and favourite celebrities instead. This can cut the amount of time people spend on the site, and in turn the opportunities for advertisers to catch their attention.

A 'moon shot'?

Facebook's IPO famously ran far from smoothly, and its shares quickly halved in price, before recovering slowly over the next two years.

"Twitter is also entering a more crowded market than Facebook," said Mr Damodaran, "and there are many more queuing up to join."

Therefore, he added, Twitter should be valued at about $10-15bn. He wrote recently that "at $20 billion, it is a moon shot".

Twitter

Twitter logos
  • Founded in 2006 by Jack Dorsey, Biz Stone, Evan Williams and Noah Glass
  • Has 232 million monthly active users
  • According to its IPO documents, 500 million tweets are sent a day
  • Made a loss of $69m in the first six months of 2013, on revenues of $254m
  • About 85% of revenue comes from advertising on its site
  • More than 75% of Twitter users access the site from their mobile phone
  • Earlier this week the US singer Katy Perry overtook pop star Justin Bieber as the most followed Twitter user
  • In November 2012, a tweet from US President Barack Obama celebrating his election victory became the most re-tweeted message in the site's history

Chris Orndorff, who manages billions of dollars for clients at Los Angeles-based Western Asset Management, believes value is a lot to do with cash flow.

"One of the best ways to value a company is to figure out the present value of the cash flows," he said.

"For a more mature company, this is easier to do because they have a history of earnings, and generally reliable predictions about future earnings and cash flows.

"Relatively new companies do not have the history."

Therefore, he added, the stock was more likely to be volatile.

"The susceptibility of social media companies to changes in consumer tastes also makes valuing those companies much more challenging," he said.

'Scrabble for revenue'

Martha Lane Fox, co-founder of the travel website Lastminute.com, told the BBC she was confident Twitter could make money and hold its value.

"Yes it is a scrabble for revenue," she said, but the company "has an astonishing amount of money in the bank".

Advertising income from mobiles, rather than desktop computers, now accounts for over 70% of advertising revenue, and here, believes Ms Lane Fox and others, Twitter may be able to flourish.

She also predicted "a huge number of interesting deals and partnerships" that could boost it further.

Predicting the future?

Start Quote

The valuation is reasonable if the company can continue to grow its user base, generate cash flow from advertising, and successfully fend off the competition”

End Quote Chris Orndorff Western Asset Management

A lot of the "value" or pricing of these companies depends on a future demand for services, as well as possible advertising streams.

But, as past deals demonstrate - that future isn't always predictable.

Famously, ITV bought the website Friends Reunited for £175m in 2005, but in 2009 Brightsolid paid ITV just £25m for the site.

It had been superseded. Its "value" had been eroded. Its customers, the key to any company, had, in large numbers, moved on.

Similar problems were encountered at one of the early social media pioneers, MySpace. In 2005 News Corp purchased MySpace for $580m. When it was sold in 2011, its price tag had fallen to a reported $35m.

It too had been overtaken, and users abandoned its offering.

But, for San Francisco-based CBS technology analyst Larry Magid, these cautionary tales make the newer clutch of technology companies stronger.

"MySpace is a constant reminder that a high and mighty service can lose its lustre. However, the lessons of MySpace were not lost on Facebook, Twitter and services that followed," he said.

"I think the difference [now] is the execution and the demographics. To succeed, Twitter needs a diversified audience that transcends a particular demographic. MySpace was focused on youth - a particularly fickle audience."

Mr Damodaran said: "A lot of very valuable companies today - including Google - were once small, money-losing companies."

And Mr Orndorff agreed: "The valuation is reasonable if the company can continue to grow its user base, generate cash flow from advertising, and successfully fend off the competition. If not, then it will be remembered - or forgotten - like many of the 1998-99 tech bubble companies, and generate plenty of tax losses for investors."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    EMAIL DEATHWISH 08:19:
    Shiva Ayyadurai and actress Fran Drescher

    So, this follows on from yesterday's 5Live discussion with Charles Elvin, CEO of the Institute of Leadership and Management about unplugging from our smartphones at the weekend. The Daily Mail refers to a Wall Street Journal interview (tucked behind its paywall unfortunately) with the man who invented email, Shiva Ayyadurai. He says: "When I tell people I invented email, the first thing they say is, 'I want to kill you,'"

     
  2.  
    BURBERRY TRADING Via Twitter Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    Tweets: Strength of sterling worrying Burberry: "If exchange rates remain at current levels, the full impact on profit in FY 2015 will be material"

     
  3.  
    BURBERRY TRADING 08:06:
    shop

    The luxury firm says a strong pound may make a "material" dent in 2015 profits if it continues to be so richly-valued. Sales at reported exchange rates rose 9% to £370m in the three months to 30 June.

     
  4.  
    MOTHERCARE 07:50:

    Mr Newton-Jones has spent 30 years in the retail industry, including 18 years at Next. He first task is likely to be to continue to hold off the takeover bid from Destination Maternity, who offered 300p per share for the mother and baby retailer, valuing it at £266m. That was a significant premium to its share price. Mothercare issued a profit warning at the start of the year and is in the middle of a turnaround programme, but it still doesn't expect to return to profit until 2017.

     
  5.  
    MOTHERCARE 07:35:
     general view of a Mothercare store

    Mothercare has announced that its interim chief executive Mark Newton-Jones has been appointed to the role permanently. He will officially take up his position and join the Mothercare board on 17 July. Last week, Mothercare rejected a takeover bid from US rival Destination Maternity.

     
  6.  
  7.  
    INDIAN BUDGET 07:20: Via Email Simon Atkinson Editor, India Business Report
    Indian Finance Minister Arun Jaitley leaves his office to table the budget in parliament in New Delhi.

    Simon Atkinson, editor of India Business Report, outside the Indian parliament in Delhi, sends this on the Federal Budget: "Early on, this is a budget appealing to foreign investors. Promise to scrutinise retrospective tax laws - something that put off some firms after high profile Vodafone case and allowing up to 49% overseas ownership of defence firms."

     
  8.  
    INDIAN BUDGET Via Twitter

    Tweet from business reporter Shilpa Kannan: Fin min @arunjaitley "We cannot spend beyond our means - fiscal prudence is important for future generations"

     
  9.  
    MARKET UPDATE 06:54:

    Tokyo stocks declined 0.24% after the US Federal Reserve signalled its widely-expected intention to end its long-running stimulus programme in October. The Nikkei 225 index slipped 36.89 points to 15,265.76. Hong Kong stocks rose 0.28%. The benchmark Hang Seng Index added 63.79 points to 23,239.86.

     
  10.  
    PUBLIC SECTOR STRIKE 06:42: Radio 5 live

    Professor Gregor Gall of the Bradford University School of Management is on 5 live talking about today's proposed strike. Strikers should make sure this is the "beginning of something" rather than just a one-off, like the last major public sector strike in 2011, he says. Otherwise the strike may end up just being "letting off steam but not adding to their leverage at the bargaining table."

     
  11.  
    PUBLIC SECTOR STRIKE 06:31:
    A member of the general trade union GMB stands outside The Houses of Parliament in London on November 30, 2011

    More than a million public sector workers are due to walk out on strike later today in a series of disputes with government over pay, pensions and job cuts. Council staff, teachers, firefighters and civil servants are among those walking out. Someone is bound to tell us how much the strike is going to cost the economy later. In the meantime, if anyone wants to have a crack at it, send your answers to bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or @BBCBusiness on twitter.

     
  12.  
    NEW INDIA GOVERNMENT Via Email Yogita Limaye Business reporter, BBC News

    Dozens of media vans are parked outside parliament as the new Indian government prepares to deliver its much anticipated first budget. A short while ago, the finance minister Arun Jaitley left his office to go to parliament, posing with the traditional 'budget briefcase' - a bag that carries the document. Bureaucrats have been locked in for days preparing this plan.

     
  13.  
    SUNDAY TRADING 06:05: Radio 5 live

    Ewen Cameron-Watt, chief investment strategist of investment institute at BlackRock, is on 5 live, talking about Sunday trading for shops. "There's a law of diminishing returns for Sunday trading," he says. Will shops make back their costs, he asks? "Are we really going to be doing our weekly shop at 10 past 8 on a Sunday?" Not him, he says.

     
  14.  
    06:00: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning from the Business Live team. You can get in touch via bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or @BBCBusiness on twitter

     
  15.  
    06:00: Matthew West Business reporter

    Morning folks, lots of news promised for today. It's the start of a new era at Sainsbury's under boss Mike Coupe; we have the monthly interest rate decision from the Bank of England, India announces its first Budget under new prime minister Narendra Modi; another house price index - this time from the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors - and a trading update from Burberry. So plenty to come.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.