UK QE has failed, says quantitative easing inventor

General view of the Bank of England (file photo)

When the UK embarked on quantitative easing (QE) in March 2009, in the aftermath of the Lehman Brothers collapse, the Bank of England was expected to administer a monetary stimulus equal to £50bn, writes Liam Halligan.

Over the past four years, such "extraordinary measures" have extended somewhat more, with the Bank's bond-buying programme now amounting to £375bn - almost eight times the original estimate.

Since the financial crisis began, the Bank of England's balance sheet has expanded four-fold. But where did the phrase "quantitative easing" come from?

Arguably among the most controversial economic policies of recent years, QE is surely the most unpronounceable. Not many Western analysts are aware that this tongue-challenging name originated in Japan, the modern-day spiritual home of money-printing.

Find out more

Even fewer know that the man who coined the phrase comes from Germany - which, of all the big Western economies, has probably the most deep-seated aversion to printing money.

In the mid-1990s, Prof Richard Werner, a German academic fluent in Japanese, was working as an economist in Tokyo. Japan's real estate bubble had burst and property and share prices were tumbling. The country was locked in a debate about the use of unconventional monetary policy to support asset prices and boost broader commercial activity.

Prof Werner submitted an article to Nikkei, a leading business newspaper, advocating a new type of radical monetary measure.

Rather than attempting to shift interest rates, he argued that the country's central bank, the Bank of Japan should instead intervene directly to influence the size of the money supply by taking steps to encourage commercial banks to extend more credit.

Prof Richard Werner Prof Werner argued against lowering interest rates or expanding central bank reserves

"I was promoting a policy that involved more credit creation, rather than changing the price of money," says Prof Werner.

"So when I wrote my article, and after the newspaper's editors insisted on a phrase readers would understand, I added the Japanese adjective for quantity to the standard expression for monetary stimulation. 'Quantitative easing' was the literal translation back into English of these two Japanese words."

Prof Werner's article was widely noticed. Several years later, in fact, the Bank of Japan decided to implement extreme monetary measures and adopted the Japanese name the German economist had coined.

"In 2001, the Japanese central bank said, 'Now we're actually doing this'," he recalls.

"To communicate this to global markets, they had to give the policy a name in English. I suppose the translators had a bad day, or were under time pressure. Normally, you'd try to come up with something slightly more fluent than 'quantitative easing', but they did only a literal translation."

While the Bank of Japan adopted the precise name of Prof Werner's policy, it was somewhat less accurate when interpreting his actual proposal.

Incredibly, the Japanese version of QE that was eventually implemented was a policy Prof Werner had specifically ruled-out.

Prof Werner's argument was that, because more than 95% of the money supply in a modern economy is derived not from cash or reserves, but from private bank lending, it is essential to get banks to lend.

So he urged the Japanese government to enter into private long-term agreements to borrow from commercial banks, instead of issuing government debt.

The Bank of Japan's version of QE, in contrast, involved creating money out of nothing at the central bank.

"That's absolutely not what my policy was about," says Prof Werner. "In my original article, I specifically argued against either lowering interest rates or expanding central bank reserves. That was my whole point - traditional solutions weren't going to work. Actually, it was a bit upsetting."

Then, in an additional twist, the Bank of England also later adopted Prof Werner's QE label - but, again, to describe a policy with which he didn't agree.

"It was one thing when the Bank of Japan did it, because that was over in Japan and was some time ago," he says. "But once the Bank of England also started using the phrase, I thought 'Hang on - I've got to speak up and make clear that the original definition is quite different.'"

Quantitative Easing: Step by step
Credit First, with the permission of the Treasury, the Bank of England creates lots of money. It does this by just crediting its own bank account.
Buying bonds The Bank of England wants to use that cash to increase spending and boost the economy so it spends it, mainly on buying government bonds from financial firms such as banks, insurance companies and pension funds.
Investment The Bank buying bonds makes them more expensive, so they are a less attractive investment. That means companies that have sold bonds may use the proceeds to invest in other companies or lend to individuals.
Economy boost If banks, pension funds and insurance companies are more enthusiastic about lending to companies and individuals, the interest rates they charge should fall, so more money is spent and the economy is boosted.
Recovery Theoretically, when the economy has recovered, the Bank of England sells the bonds it has bought and destroys the cash it receives. That means in the long term there has been no extra cash created.

The Bank of England's interpretation of QE also involves the creation of central bank credits, as in Japan. But in the UK these have been used to buy government bonds from commercial banks rather than from the government directly.

Prof Werner says this is "a little better" than Japanese QE, as it "at least in theory increases commercial banks' reserves". He maintains, though, that the "best way to boost the economy is to increase bank credit", and that can only be guaranteed by governments borrowing from banks directly.

"That creates new credit," says Prof Werner. "The money supply then expands, transactions increase, there's more demand, more employment, more tax revenues and suddenly you have a virtuous circle."

'Household name'

In both Japan and the UK, QE isn't working, he says, because it doesn't focus on "the most important part of the money supply", which is bank lending. "UK QE has singularly failed, as bank credit is still shrinking."

When faced with the claim used by some British banks that the demand for credit is low, Prof Werner is dismissive. "I'm quite used to this argument, because banks in Japan used it for 20 years," he says. "The banks, of course, have become very risk-averse, as they have many non-performing assets."

Prof Werner is also critical of the UK's concentrated banking structure - which he argues has made the economy more vulnerable. "British banking is dominated by a small number of big banks - with just five banks controlling 90% of deposits," he says.

"Big banks want to lend to big firms and do big deals that give big bonuses. Small firms are too much hassle, and the banks are absolutely not interested - even though small firms need the credit and account for 70% of UK employment. So these small firms are credit-rationed and that's a problem."

"In Germany, 70% of deposits are held by 2,000 banks," says Prof Werner. "These local German banks lend a lot more to small- and medium-sized firms, and when the credit crunch happened most of them were fine."

When it comes to QE, although his policy recommendations have been misinterpreted in Japan, the UK and elsewhere, Prof Werner maintains his natural sense of humour about giving the world a phrase that's so challenging to say.

"It's become a household name anyway and I should get some kind of fee, some royalties, for that," he says with a smile.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    ARM PROFITS 07:49:
    ARM

    Cambridge-based chip designer ARM has posted first quarter results for 2014. Its pre-tax profits are up 9% on the previous year, to £97.1m. The company says 2.9 billion ARM-based chips shipped during the quarter, up 11%.

     
  2.  
    FLYBE EXPANSION 07:38:
    City airport

    Budget airline Flybe has announced a five-year deal with London's City Airport. New routes to and from Edinburgh, Belfast, Dublin, Inverness and Exeter will start in October.

     
  3.  
    PATISSERIE TO FLOAT 07:31:

    Patisserie Holdings, which owns five brands including the high-street chain Patisserie Valerie, has announced it will float on the London Stock Exchange. The company says it is seeking to raise approximately £33m.

     
  4.  
    HEADLINES
     
  5.  
    FRACKING 07:18: BBC Radio 4

    Ed Davey is also asked about fracking, and whether companies will be allowed to drill under private land without the permission of owners. Mr Davey says the government is "looking at the access rights". "The question is how those land owners are compensated and how those projects can go ahead," he adds.

     
  6.  
    GREEN ENERGY PROJECTS 07:16: BBC Radio 4

    Energy and Climate Change Secretary Ed Davey is on Today. He says the eight projects will add 2% to the average energy bill by 2020. But in return we are getting "secure, clean energy". He says the government has more renewable energy projects than they are prepared to pay for, so if any of the eight companies drop out, there are others who would take their place.

     
  7.  
    PRIMARK US VENTURE 07:12: Breaking News
    Primark

    Budget clothing retailer Primark has announced it is venturing to the US. The company, which is owned by Associated British Foods, says it will open its first American branch in Boston by the end of 2015. It plans to open further stores in the north-east of the country in 2016. Given the experience of Tesco and M&S in the US, you have to admire their optimism.

     
  8.  
    GREEN ENERGY PROJECTS 07:08: Breaking News
    Wind farm, Burbo Bank

    The Department of Energy and Climate Change has announced 8 big green energy projects. The contracts are expected to support 8,500 jobs. They include offshore wind farms and conversions of coal-powered plants to run on biomass. The projects will provide up to £12bn of private sector investment.

     
  9.  
    EXECUTIVE PAY 06:56: Radio 5 live

    Mike Amey is back on Radio 5 Live. He's discussing Vince Cable's warning over bankers' pay. He says the business secretary wants shareholders to be able to vote down pay, and good internal governance. If these measures fail to be implemented, there could be "another round of regulation coming down the tracks".

     
  10.  
    RUSSIAN TECH BOSS 06:45:
    Moscow Times

    This from the Moscow Times. The founder of Russia's biggest social networking site fled the country on Tuesday. Pavel Durov, who founded Vkontakte seven years ago, was forced out of the company on Monday for refusing to share users' personal data, according to the article. It says the social network is now controlled by billionaires Igor Sechin and Alisher Usmanov, who have close links with the Kremlin.

     
  11.  
    NICER NISA? 06:39: Radio 5 live
    NISA

    Amid the furore over the Co-op, here's a mutual that's doing quite well. NISA, which stands for National Independent Supermarkets Association and operates over 4,000 stores, has reported a 10% rise in sales. Chief executive Neil Turton tells Wake Up to Money NISA was founded in 1977 when locals "joined together to combine their buying power". Mickey asks him if NISA convenience stores are more expensive. "Price is not the big thing for consumers - it's availability," says Mr Turton.

     
  12.  
    EXECUTIVE PAY 06:33: BBC Radio 4

    The Today programme picks up on comments by Business Secretary Vince Cable. He has written to all FTSE 100 companies and urged restraint over pay. In a recorded clip on Today, Mr Cable said pay had, in the past, reached "ridiculous and dangerous levels" in the banking industry. But he said companies now have a chance "to make peace with the public". Mr Cable singled out Barclays, which has its annual meeting on Thursday.

     
  13.  
    MARKET TRENDS 06:25: Radio 5 live

    Mike Amey has more interesting markets analysis, after other pharma shares, notably Astrazeneca, also did well yesterday. "The two areas where there's the most activity at the moment are the pharmaceutical sector and things like telecoms and cable - which are both quite stable income streams, whether the economy does well and badly," he explains. When the economy starts to do better, activity starts off in the stable sectors and moves out to others, so what we are seeing is a "pretty decent recovery".

     
  14.  
    PHARMA SWAP 06:15: Radio 5 live
    Pills

    Pharma, which is business speak for pharmaceutical companies, is back in the news, with Swiss firm Novartis and GSK swapping assets yesterday. Mike Amey, managing director at Pimco, tells Wake Up to Money they are sensibly focusing on their areas of expertise and not trying and be "all things to all men". Investors seem to agree - shares in GSK went up 5% yesterday, and Novartis did well too.

     
  15.  
    SECURITISATION IS BACK 06:09: Radio 5 live

    The securitisation of debt - in which bundles of loans are sold on to investors - was one of the factors which led to the 2008 crash. But now both the ECB and Mark Carney are saying it could be a way to get money into the system again. Richard Hopkin, head of securitisation at AFME, tells Wake Up to Money the success of securitisation depends on who's in charge. He uses an analogy: "Cars don't cause accidents, it's the people driving the cars".

     
  16.  
    JAPAN TRADE 06:03: BBC World News
    Linda Yueh

    Barack Obama makes his first state visit to Japan today. He is expected to push the Trans-Pacific Partnership - an important trade deal that would eliminate trade barriers and standardise regulations. But, in a report on World Business Report, chief business correspondent Linda Yueh says Japan's rice farmers are worried it will mean the end of protection - in particular a 778% tax on imported rice.

     
  17.  
    06:02: Joe Miller Business Reporter

    Good morning. You can contact us throughout the morning by tweeting @BBCBusiness or emailing bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk

     
  18.  
    06:01: Ben Morris Business Reporter

    Good morning. We're expecting the government to announce several big green energy projects today. So stay with the Business Live page for that.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.