'The best engineers come from Germany'

Is Germany's 'earn as you learn' model an election winning factor? Tanya Beckett finds out.

Related Stories

"I think the apprentices will be guaranteed a job when we go back, so I think we'll be OK," said Rhys from Bristol.

He and his fellow fresh-faced apprentices are huddled around a noisy workbench in Berlin. At just 19, he is one of the youngest in his group at this training centre.

Rhys, a keen rugby player, says he is settling into the German lifestyle and has even found a rugby club nearby.

He is one of just 2,200 young workers chosen from some 45,000 applicants by the electronics and electrical engineering giant Siemens for its pan-European training scheme.

Another apprentice, 21-year-old Gabriel from Northampton, says he came to Berlin to learn the German way.

"They are much more precise, they go into detail a lot more," he says.

"It helps you understand why all the best engineers and creatives come from here."

Start Quote

They are all expected to go home still working for Siemens - but in their homeland”

End Quote Martin Stoeckmann Head of training, Siemens

It is a point that was recently made by the British business lobby group, the CBI.

It warned that the UK's traditional educational route, of A-levels followed by a university degree, was not the only path to a good job and could help deepen a skills crisis in the UK.

The CBI called for more earn-as-you-learn schemes, supported by companies, alongside traditional degrees - and cited Germany as one of the leaders in vocational education.

'Excellent chance'

Siemens's trainees have come from all over Europe for the company's three-year programme, that will give them an income while they learn the art of German engineering.

"I know that right now, it's not the best time to find a job. It's why I'm doing this in Germany," says 20-year old Miguel from Madrid.

He hopes to return to Spain, despite dire employment prospects at home, where one in two young people is out of work.

Rhys, a British apprentice with Siemens British apprentice Rhys says he is confident his training will help him get a job

"Everybody knows what the label 'Made in Germany' means," says 22-year-old Vainius from Lithuania.

"This is a perfect example of how they do it. It is an excellent chance for everyone here."

In Spain, says Miguel, "we don't have opportunity to study practical and theory at same time."

Start Quote

It's a very practical, applied approach”

End Quote Nora Hesse Open Europe

In another classroom at the firm's vast training centre, a British girl stumbles over German grammar. Learning to speak German is part of the deal.

Apprentices here are encouraged to immerse themselves in the culture, offered help in opening a bank account and in other aspects of living abroad: it is a very German approach.

Germany's vocational system has been around for decades and is deeply embedded in society. A university degree does not have quite the same cachet here that it does in many other developed countries.

Youngsters who are not qualified for or interested in going to university can join a programme in which they work part of the week for a firm that pays them and teaches them relevant skills.

The rest of the time they spend in school.

Chambers of commerce and industry bodies are involved, to ensure that the work and the teaching are matched.

After their apprenticeships, the trainees often have jobs to walk into, in sectors including electrical engineering, sales and marketing, shipping and agriculture.

Roughly two out of three young Germans go through this system.

'They are loyal and proud'
Martin Stoeckmann, head of training for Siemens, Berlin Apprenticeships are goods for trainees and companies, says Martin Stoeckmann

"It's a very practical, applied approach, where young people are partly hired, partly subsidised in this dual education system," says Nora Hesse, a Berlin-based economist at the Open Europe think tank.

"They do receive some money but not too much, and their education is covered by the company that hires them," she says.

Martin Stoeckmann, who runs Siemens's training centre, says that the apprenticeships are a good investment for both the young people and the companies involved.

"Around 90% of them stay at Siemens after they finish their education. They are loyal and proud to be at the company," he says.

The company denies claims that schemes like this represent a brain drain, as Germany sucks in the brightest and best youngsters from all over Europe.

"They are all expected to go home - still working for Siemens - but in their homeland," says Mr Stoeckmann.

Advocates of Germany's vocational training point to the fact that despite the global recession, the number of young Germans out of work remains low.

An apprentice at Siemens's training centre, Berlin Germany has the lowest youth unemployment rate in Europe

Youth unemployment in Germany is under 8%, compared with 56% in Spain and 38% in Italy.

Since the 2008 financial crisis, the number of 15- to 29-year-olds not in education, employment or training has risen in most OECD countries - except in Germany.

Limited knowledge

However, some argue that there are drawbacks to this vocational bias.

Countries that combine school and work-based education, such as Germany, Austria, Denmark and Switzerland, may help young people into jobs, but in older age, these workers' skills can become obsolete, says the influential Munich-based Ifo Institute.

Knowledge is also limited to the operations of the company that trains them.

Yet with a crisis that has hit growth and the job prospects of many young people across Europe, for the apprentices at Siemens, this system offers hope.

Rhys says he is confident of his own future, thanks to the technical training he is getting.

But he says that back in Britain - where 960,000 people aged 16 to 24 are jobless - many of his friends face an uncertain future.

"I am worried for a lot of other people," he says.

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    09:30: UK GDP

    The UK economy grew by 0.7% in the three months to September, in line with City forecasts, official figures show. In the previous three months the economy grew by 0.9%. The first three months of the year were initially estimated to have seen growth of 0.8% but that was recently revised back down to 0.7%.

     
  2.  
    09:21: TSB EARNINGS

    TSB shares are up 1.8% in London to 263.70p. Numis analyst Mike Trippitt says the bank's profit beat his estimates in a note to clients. Impairments were lower than the market thought and costs were better.

     
  3.  
    09:07: SPIRIT PUBS TAKEOVER
    pub

    More analysis on Greene King and C&C's offers for the Spirit pub chain. "The really interesting development, in our view, would be for all three businesses to combine. The result would be a leading pubco and a brewer, cider maker and distributor with a much stronger portfolio of brands," say analysts at City broker Canaccord Genuity this morning. "C&C also own Tennents, the leading Scottish lager. Belhaven (Greene King's Scottish estate) is a leading customer."

     
  4.  
    08:51: BANK OF DAVE Radio 5 live

    Dave Fishwick, the minibus salesman who founded the "Bank of Dave" is on Radio 5 live. What does the banking market need? "What we desperately need out there is challenger banks," he says. What's also needed is "tighter control of the bigger banks to prevent greed and corruption," he adds.

     
  5.  
    08:36: MARKET REPORT

    The fallout from Tesco's results yesterday continues today. The supermarket is the biggest faller on the FTSE 100 Index so far this morning down 2.3% to 167.05p. European markets are down generally. The FTSE 100 is down 0.45% to 6390.17, Germany's Dax is down 0.40% to 9011.29 and France's Cac-40 has fallen 050% to 4136.95.

     
  6.  
    08:23: PEARSON EARNINGS
    penguin

    Pearson's chief executive John Fallon says the firm's £50m cost-cutting programme is on track and "momentum in digital, services and emerging market education is building, which will drive a leaner, more cash generative, faster growing business from 2015."

     
  7.  
    08:06: SPIRIT PUBS TAKEOVER

    Could this be the beginning of a bidding war? The pub chain has said it has rejected a takeover proposal from Irish cider maker C&C Group today. Spirit is already in talks with brewer and pub owner Greene King about its proposed £723m takeover offer. C&C, the maker of Magners and Bulmers, has until 20 November to announce a firm takeover offer.

     
  8.  
    07:51: PEARSON EARNINGS

    Pearson has reported flat underlying revenue for nine months to the end of September and a 1% fall in in what it calls headline growth for the period. It blames the strength of sterling against key emerging market currencies for the fall. Penguin Random House has performed well in the third quarter, it adds without giving detail. It says the integration of its businesses is "progressing well and is on track to deliver benefits in 2015 and beyond".

     
  9.  
    07:38: HIKMA WARNING

    Hikma Pharmaceuticals says it has received a warning letter US Food and Drug Administration after an inspection at its manufacturing plant in Portugal. "In the letter, the agency raised issues related to investigations and environmental monitoring at the facility," said the firm, which is taking the letter "very seriously."

     
  10.  
    07:26: TSB EARNINGS
    The TSB logo

    Impairments - that is, bad loans - fell to £23m from £32.2m, said TSB. Loans rose 7.7% to £22bn compared to a year ago, but fell from a peak of £23bn six months ago. TSB won 9.7% of all new or switched bank accounts, it said, adding £500m of deposits.

     
  11.  
    07:18: PEARSON FINANCE CHIEF STEPS DOWN

    Robin Freestone, chief financial officer of Financial Times and Penguin Random House owner Pearson has announced he is standing down after 10 years with the firm, including eight in his current role. He will probably leave the firm in 2015 after a successor has been found, said the firm.

     
  12.  
    07:08: TSB EARNINGS

    TSB third-quarter profit before tax fell 14% to £33.1m compared with the same time a year ago, after operating expenses rose. But revenue swelled 18% to £199m

     
  13.  
    06:54: EU PAYMENT Radio 5 live

    Sarah Hewin of Standard Chartered on 5 live says the payment has to be made in the next few months. That could mean more borrowing, she says.

     
  14.  
    06:41: EU PAYMENT Radio 5 live
    British Prime Minister David Cameron

    Sarah Hewin of Standard Chartered is explaining why the UK has to pay an extra £1.7bn to the EU on 5 live. "The UK has been doing better since 1997 than we thought and that's resulted in this extra payment. The Netherlands will pay more, while France and Germany get a rebate."

     
  15.  
    06:29: AMAZON RESULTS Radio 5 live

    Paul Kavanagh of wealth manager Killik is talking about Amazon's loss-making results last night. "It begs the question about what is happening here with this strategy. The shares fell 11% in after hours [in the US]." Investors may be growing tired of ever-more sales expansion with little profit to show for it, he tells 5 live.

     
  16.  
    06:20: CHALLENGER BANKS Radio 5 live

    Paul Kavanagh of wealth manager Killik says it's difficult for banks to persuade customers they offer something new. When a challenger bank succeeds, the larger banks often take the best ideas, he says on 5 live.

     
  17.  
    06:12: CHALLENGER BANKS Radio 5 live

    Steve Davies is still on 5 live. He says challenger banks are forcing their larger competitors to think more about the customer and service - think Metro bank opening on Sundays. Competing on rates is more difficult, he says. TSB results coming up later.

     
  18.  
    06:03: CHALLENGER BANKS Radio 5 live

    Steve Davies of accountants PwC is on 5 live talking about so-called challenger banks. Can they challenge the largest high street banks? "They have to be able to offer something a little bit different," he says. "The challenge is around innovation," he says. Customer is key, he adds.

     
  19.  
    06:00: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning. Get in touch via email blizlivepage@bbc.co.uk and twitter @BBCBusiness.

     
  20.  
    06:00: Matthew West Business reporter

    Morning folks. It's Friday, we're nearly at the weekend. But before that, TSB kicks off bank earnings season and Shire has financials out as well. There's also some service sector data but the big bit of data is the first estimate of third quarter GDP. We'll bring you it all as it happens as always.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.