HS2 to boost UK economy 'by £15bn a year' says report


Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin: "The main reason we need HS2 is a heart bypass for the clogged arteries of our transport system"

Related Stories

A new report says the HS2 rail project could boost the UK economy by £15bn a year.

Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin presented the findings as he reasserted the case for the new rail line.

The report, from accountants KPMG, says that regions outside London will be the biggest beneficiaries of the new service.

But the economic boost will not be felt until 2037, it says.

In a speech at the Institute of Civil Engineers, Mr McLoughlin argued that rejecting HS2 would amount to a "national loss of nerve".

Start Quote

KPMG is ignoring one of the fundamental causes of lacklustre growth in many parts of the UK, which is a shortage of skilled labour and of easily and readily developable land”

End Quote

HS2 was necessary because the "clogged arteries" of the nation's transport system needed a "heart bypass", he said.

But Mark Littlewood, director general of the Institute of Economic Affairs, told the BBC: "Any private investor would consider this to be a colossal waste of money.

"That is not to say that we don't need to improve capacity. Rail is an extraordinarily expensive way of doing that."

The government was asking UK taxpayers to take "a huge gamble on their extremely dodgy numbers", he added.


Mr McLoughlin argued that the benefits of HS2 were not simply faster journey times and new jobs, but up to 500,000 fewer lorry journeys a day on the country's roads, according to a separate report.

"High Speed Two will make Liverpool stronger. Manchester stronger. Leeds stronger. Britain stronger", he said.

"A £15bn annual boost to the economy. With the North and Midlands gaining at least double the benefit of the south."

Dismissing "scare stories" over the budget, he maintained that it would remain £42.6bn, with a contingency fund of £14.4bn.

But earlier this week, the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) criticised the scheme, saying: "So far, the Department [of Transport] has made decisions based on fragile numbers, out-of-date data and assumptions which do not reflect real life."

The committee also said there was no evidence the line would help the growth of regional cities and would instead draw even more business to London.

KPMG's report was commissioned by HS2 Ltd, which is a non-departmental public body wholly owned by the Department for Transport.

Report author Richard Threlfall, KPMG's head of infrastructure, said: "What I hope this work will do is put some new evidence into the debate, because what we've seen over the last few months is an awful lot of opinions and to be honest not a lot of evidence on the ground as to what effect this will have.

"And what our report shows, beyond any reasonable doubt, is that HS2 will deliver massive benefits to the UK economy."

Map showing the route of phase 1 & 2 of the proposed high-speed service

John Longworth, director general of the British Chambers of Commerce, told the BBC: "Businesses up and down the country are absolutely convinced that this is a really important infrastructure project. It is one of the key infrastructure projects for the UK."


This report tots up the benefits in a new way.

It analyses how better transport links have apparently fuelled business and productivity across various different cities, then applies that to HS2.

Saving time still plays a part, but it's a smaller part.

Instead, there's more importance placed on all those extra seats this scheme provides, not just on the new high speed trains, but on the rest of the rail network too (all those extra commuter services we're being promised).

Critics say the government is just moving the goalposts in a desperate bid to make its project look better.

He argued that simply renovating existing rail lines that were "creaking at the seams" would cause "chaos".

The latest study was commissioned by HS2 Ltd, the company responsible for developing and promoting the project.

It says Birmingham's economy could be boosted between 2.1% and 4.2% a year, while Manchester would benefit between 0.8% and 1.7%.

For Leeds, the boost would be 1.6% and London 0.5%.

Conservative MP Andrew Bridgen: "Enough is enough. This is tremendously bad value for money"

Wednesday's report calculates the benefits of the project in a different way from previous efforts.

Time saved is a less important part of the calculation. Instead, the report includes the benefits of extra seats, which means passengers will be able to work while travelling.

It also takes into account the reduction in congestion elsewhere on the network.

"The point about High Speed Two is that you won't have to travel on it to gain from the better transport system and economic growth it will support," he said.

The high-speed line would run between London and Birmingham from 2026 before being extended to Manchester and Leeds from 2033.


More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 718.

    Why does the British tax payer have to pay for this? Thatcher (the witch that you so kindly donated 10m toward her funeral) privatized just about everything except your Kitchen sink! Hence your nightmare utility bill costs. So the British Government should make the Rail companies pay for it! Oh I just saw a flying Pig laughing out Rip off Britain, unless one goes to Eton!

  • rate this

    Comment number 717.

    As originally configured HS2 will not carry freight. It would be too limited for that anyway, w/high speed timetable & linking only 2 cities in 1st stage & a handful more after 2nd stage completion.

    As I understand it, rail industry wants freight capacity on a new central Britain line so that it has time for maintenance on existing routes in order to increase their passenger capacity

  • rate this

    Comment number 716.

    I managed to find the Stop HS2 website, can anyone direct me to its associate Stop CrossRail ?

  • rate this

    Comment number 715.

    "Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin presented the findings as he reasserted the case for the new rail line"

    I struggle to believe this given the source... First hand experience of him in his role as MP! He oversaw relocation of medical center from a prime central location, close to care homes and good links, to the outskirts of town, on green belt land with only two buses a day... Genius!

  • rate this

    Comment number 714.

    I believe HS2 will shave 20mins off a London-Birmingham trip but the train won't terminate at New St Station in Birmingham. If you want to travel north from Brum before (or if) the line is extended you'll have to walk across town to get to New St. Which, by the time you reach the Platform in New St for you connection will probably take around...20 minutes! What a waste of money for no benefit.

  • rate this

    Comment number 713.

    Widen the existing WCML trackbed and you have to demolish houses and offices, widen the tunnels and bridges and cause untold chaos until it is finished. Double-decker trains would cause the same amount of chaos. Increase the length of the trains and you slow the network down. The easiest solution is to BUILD A NEW LINE.

  • rate this

    Comment number 712.

    "Half a million fewer lorry journeys a day" this is simply not true,and if it was it means half a million drivers out of work which will then cost us in social security payments.The department of transport love to cause trouble and waste money,look at the motorway network and the problems they have been causing for the past 18 months just so they can install speed cameras and variable speed limits

  • rate this

    Comment number 711.

    Total waste of money a vanity project by this goverment to give huge amounts of tax payers money to their friends in th construction industry to build this white elephant.

  • rate this

    Comment number 710.

    687. continentview

    "Thanks God that the victoriens where not that anal retentive otherwise the UK would still use canals..."

    Thank god that they cared about making things that last and have character, and didn't have the technology to trash the country as has happened since. All we've needed to do since then is improve working conditions but we've ruined the country too.

  • rate this

    Comment number 709.

    The problem is with the HS2 predictions is that no-one making them will be backing up their claims with their own personal finances. Not Cameron, Osbourne or the 'faceless ones' at KPMG would be willing to invest their own assets in HS2 on the promise of a return when their predictions are realised in full. What baseline & measures would they use after all? A good question to answer now I think!

  • rate this

    Comment number 708.

    As in all privatisations the only useful services will be classed as ' Premium ' and you'll be charged 6 times the reasonable price because someone in a red or blue cloak with a little hat will smile at you for 3 seconds.

  • rate this

    Comment number 707.

    The new report focuses on the benefits of extra seats. So reduce the number of unused seats in first class. Problem solved.

  • rate this

    Comment number 706.

    WHY would anyone with any sense want to get to Birmingham 'faster'? OR is it to get out of there faster?

  • rate this

    Comment number 705.

    if its a free market the govt should not be building anything. all it will be will be a direct subsidy to private shareholders who put their money in tax havens. british people are still lions led by donkeys. the uk taxpayer is being farmed by private companies with the connivance of the govt.

  • rate this

    Comment number 704.

    692. 90005Nelson
    Why not invest in double-Decker trains and double the railway capacity for everyone.!!!"

    Because you would have to rebuild all the bridges over the railway and re-align all their approach roads, and you would have to re-dig all the tunnels.

    A non-starter.

  • rate this

    Comment number 703.

    692. 90005Nelson

    simple, valid question, simple answer. Whats called the 'loading gauge' of the majority of UK railway will not allow higher double deck trains. Its an idea that has been tried & dusted off more than once, but it would mean every single bridge and tunnel on a route would need to be rebuilt, raised or enlarged by several feet, and it would cost more than HS2 !!

  • rate this

    Comment number 702.

    Be interested to see the names of directors/board members of the companies on this HS2 gravy train, another conservative piggy bank retirement fund....

  • rate this

    Comment number 701.

    HS2 will be good for the UK. All aboard!!!

  • rate this

    Comment number 700.

    Invest the £50bn on social housing, property for 1st time buyers, fibre-optic broadband, & manufacturing. Putting your eggs all into one basket is ridiculous. We are £1.2tn in debt.

    This £50bn is borrowed money.

    We have the ability to borrow money at low rates to invest in infrastructure that facilitates a competitive economy & helps reduce state costs: i.e., social housing over private.

  • rate this

    Comment number 699.

    I read this HYS and it just reminds me of how many sheep are still out there.
    Tell me how H2S will benefit all of us that pay tax but will never use it. A bit like Fracking, how will that help the public when its allready been said it wont make gas cheaper. Please wake up!


Page 21 of 56


More Business stories


BBC Business Live


    More CML stats, this time about Scotland. Mortgage lending to home buyers jumped by 32% between the first and second quarters of the year. The typical loan for first-time buyers was £95,000, up from just under £90,000 in the first quarter. And the typical gross income of a first-time buyer household was £32,300.


    Figures on regional mortgage lending have been published by the Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML) They look at London, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland in the second quarter of the year. A few tasty facts about greater London. The typical gross income of a first-time buyer household was £55,000. 63% of first-time buyers bought properties costing more than £250,000. And first time buyers typically put down 25% deposits, more than elsewhere.

    RBS FINE 09:32: BBC Radio 4

    RBS is very sorry for the poor mortgage advice it gave to 30,000 mortgage customers in recent years. Lloyd Cochrane, head of mortgages at RBS and its subsidiary NatWest told the Today programme that it reckons about 4% of those may have been disadvantaged financially. That's about 1,200 people. "We did not do a good enough job [but] very few customers lost out as a result of this," he said.

    Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: "RBS's Lloyd Cochrane tells me the bank spent many months retraining staff; management "takes responsibility" for selling mistakes."

    FOXTONS 08:56:
    Foxtons share price graph

    Shareholders don't seem happy about Foxtons' special dividend or higher profits. The shares are down almost 6%. Why? Perhaps some profit takers are among them. Or perhaps it's the warning that asking prices in London are dropping and it expects to see a slow down in transactions in the second half.

    No campaign stuff

    Business hasn't been shouting about the matter. Views have been dripped out. Bigger names who have spoken up include Douglas Flint, head of HSBC, against, and Standard Life, also against to the extent the business said it would consider leaving the country if it chose independence.


    Shares in London have begun higher. The FTSE 100 is up 48 at 6,822.76. In Frankfurt, the Dax is up 29.83 at 7106.70 and in Paris the Cac 40 is up 51.30 at 4393.41.

    • RBS and NatWest fined £15m for bad advice
    • Businesses doubt Scottish independence
    • Foxtons earnings jump after strong house sales
    BANANA MERGER 07:52:

    An update on Fyffes and Chiquita's attempt to merge and complete their corporate fruit salad. They say they hope to save $60m a year in overheads. Their official name for this plan is "the Combination". The capital C is vital, of course.

    RBS FINE 07:38:

    All this was happening four years after the government bailed out RBS, years after it had started eating humble pie for mis-selling payment protection insurance, and after it had been discovered committing other misdemeanours. The FCA said: "Only 2 of the 164 sales reviewed were considered to meet the standard required overall in a sales process."

    CARS TO RUSSIA 07:37: BBC Radio 4

    Sanctions have not dampened the enthusiasm of car firms to sell their vehicles in Russia - the world's seventh biggest car market. The Moscow Motor Show is getting underway and fully bullet-proof cars are on offer. Paul Willcox, chairman of Nissan Europe, told the Today programme he was taking the long view with nine new models being launched. "Our plan is in the next three years to grab 10% of the market," he said.

    RBS FINE 07:23:
    RBS pillar sign

    And there's more: "In the firms' own mystery shopping there were examples of advisers giving personal views on the future movement of interest rates," says the FCA. "This was highly inappropriate and may have resulted in the borrower being sold the wrong type of mortgage for them."

    RBS FINE 07:21:

    What did RBS do wrong? "Affordability assessments failing to consider the full extent of a customer's budget when making a recommendation, failing to advise customers who were looking to consolidate debt properly and not advising customers what mortgage term was appropriate for them," says the FCA.

    FOXTONS 07:16:

    Foxtons, the London estate agency that put the F in flashy, has benefitted from the past year's surge in home sales. Its half-year earnings are up 16% to £73m, and its half-year profits jumped 57% to £23m. That's a huge profit margin. So much so that shareholders are getting a special half year dividend on top of the normal one - £13m in all.

    RBS FINE 07:14:

    The FCA's statement on RBS's failings on mortgage advice include some gems: "The firms [RBS and NatWest] failed to ensure that advice given to customers was suitable. Two reviews of sales from 2012 found that in over half the cases the suitability of the advice was not clear from the file or call recording." This was happening two years ago.


    The Financial Conduct Authority confirms it has fined RBS and NatWest £15m for failures in their mortgage advice process.

    Ryanair poster

    Ryanair is pitching for business travellers. It says it will offer them free flight changes in future, as well as a 20kg checked-in bag allowance. But to get this they will need to pay almost £60 to join the Ryanair Business Plus club, via www.ryanair.com/en/business-plus. You need to put in all your details before it will tell you any more about it.

    Fish on plate

    News from Norway. Marine Harvest, the world's largest salmon farmer, is warning that Russian sanctions will present it with some short-term challenges. Meantime, the company reports operational earnings of 1.22bn crowns (£120m), nearly double last year's figure.

    RBS FINE 06:30: BBC Radio 4

    Richard Jeffrey of Cazenove Capital Management tells listeners to the Today programme that the impending fine for RBS over poorly sold mortgages is "disappointing". But he says we shouldn't beat up the banks too much as it is essential that confidence in the banking system is maintained.


    The Scotsman letter says business is worried about - yes, the pound - and the EU and tax and pensions. There are of course some industries that are warmer towards independence - the airlines for one. Remember Willie Walsh of BA said independence could be positive for the country and Ryanair backed the SNP's plans to cut air passenger duty.

    CPP 06:13: Radio 5 live

    Sarah Pennells of SavvyWoman.com has been on Wake up to Money, telling us that this Saturday is the deadline for millions of people to claim compensation for being mis-sold unnecessary credit card insurance, or identity protection policies, by the company CPP. Around seven million people are thought to have been mis-sold this "insurance" over the years. But so far only 1.7 million have lodged a claim.

    Oil rig

    More than 130 businesses have signed a letter saying the business case for Scottish independence "has not been made". The signatories come from a variety of businesses including banking, mining, engineering, food, whisky, and technology. The letter is published in today's Scotsman newspaper.

    06:01: Ian Pollock Business reporter, BBC News

    We are expecting the formal announcement that RBS is being fined £15 million for giving poor mortgage advice.

    06:00: Rebecca Marston Business reporter, BBC News

    Morning. Looks like we're in for a busier day than yesterday - let's hope so. Stay with us here on Business Live 'til 13:00 for the pick of the news.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.