Banks and card issuers face £1.3bn CPP compensation bill

CPP building in York CPP is sending out letters to seven million customers

Related Stories

Seven million people could be in line for hundreds of pounds in compensation for being mis-sold credit card and identity theft protection.

Thirteen banks and credit card firms have agreed to provide up to £1.3bn towards a new compensation scheme.

It will reimburse customers mis-sold the products by insurer CPP.

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) said that customers had been "given misleading and unclear information about the policies".

The new financial markets regulator said that the affected customers could expect to receive letters from CPP from 29 August 2013, explaining how to claim compensation.

Broader scandal?

The banks and card companies, whom regulators found culpable of introducing customers to CPP's products, will pay money into the scheme as the claims are received.

Card providers involved

The banks and credit card companies that have agreed to provide compensation are:

  • Bank of Scotland
  • Barclays
  • Canada Square (formerly Egg)
  • Capital One
  • Clydesdale Bank
  • Home Retail Group
  • HSBC
  • MBNA
  • Morgan Stanley
  • Nationwide
  • Santander
  • Royal Bank of Scotland
  • Tesco

They have also agreed to pay to advertise the compensation scheme in national newspapers.

"We have been encouraged that, despite their different business needs, a large number of firms have voluntarily come together to create a redress scheme that will provide a fair outcome for customers," said the FCA's chief executive, Martin Wheatley.

The up-to-£1.3bn cost of the scheme is still only a fraction of the estimated £15bn total compensation bill faced by the banking industry for the Payment Protection Insurance mis-selling scandal.

The banks may have to pay further billions to compensate small businesses who were mis-sold complex financial derivatives called interest-rate swaps.

Questions have also been raised as to whether the latest mis-selling scandal will remain limited to products provided by CPP Group.

"ID theft insurance and card protection policies are poor value for money and many consumers were misled about the benefits," said Richard Lloyd, executive director of the consumer watchdog Which?

"These policies were widely mis-sold, so the FCA should name other firms they are investigating and make it as easy as possible for people to get their money back."

The FCA declined to comment on whether it was investigating other insurers, but said that it was keeping identity theft insurance, card protection and other general insurance products under review.

Meanwhile, the Financial Ombudsman Service said that the number of complaints it receives about card protection insurance has risen steadily, totalling 247 in the three months to June.

The regulator said it had been finding in favour of 76% of the complainants.

Unnecessary and exaggerated

During the period of mis-selling between January 2005 and March 2011, CPP sold 4.4 million policies and generated £354m in gross profit. A further 18.7 million policies were renewed during the same period, generating an income of £656m.

Many customers were put in contact with CPP when they rang a number on their new bank card in order to activate it. Many thought they were talking to their bank, but they were in fact being put in touch with a salesperson from CPP.

CPP then used the opportunity of the call to offer card protection insurance. If the customer bought the product, the bank got a commission.

Credit card bill - generic

The amount of compensation that an individual customer can expect will depend on what products they bought and for how many years, but could run into hundreds of pounds.

Victims will receive 8% interest on the amounts being reimbursed.

The CPP compensation scheme must first be voted on by customers and approved by the High Court, and the FCA said it did not expect the first compensation payments to be made until next spring.

The York-based CPP Group sold a card protection product costing about £30 a year, that was designed to cover losses if a card was lost or stolen.

It said customers would benefit from up to £100,000 of insurance cover, but customers were already covered by their banks. Generally, cardholders are not liable for unauthorised card payments on lost or stolen credit and debit cards.

A second product, sold for about £80 a year, was designed to cover costs if the customer's identity was stolen.

Still being charged

John from Cardiff contacted the BBC to say that he was still being charged by CPP for three unwanted policies, even after trying to cancel them for four years:

"I have tried in vain to cancel all three policies... but they just keep charging the cards.

"I'm disabled, as is my wife, so we have our shopping delivered.

"One day, Asda called to say our card had been cancelled.

"I called Barclays who said I had been a victim of fraud, so they had cancelled the card.

"They then put me through to CPP who sold me three policies, for myself, my wife and my father who has since died.

"At the time, I didn't even know what was going to happen about the £6,500 that had gone missing and I was very vulnerable.

"I feel I was pushed into buying these policies.

"I have tried in vain to cancel all three policies, but they won't even cancel the one for my now deceased father.

"They just keep fobbing me off and continuing to charge the cards."

The FCA's predecessor, the Financial Services Authority, found that CPP overstated the risks and consequences of ID theft when this insurance was being sold.

Financial lifeline

CPP's own bill for the mis-selling has reached £54m, according to the company's latest financial results released earlier on Thursday.

It covers, among other things, a £10.5m fine imposed on it last year, as well as an expected £14.5m in compensation payments for the 300,000 policies it sold directly, without the help of other banks or credit card companies.

The bill and the loss of business since the scandal first came to light in 2010 have put CPP into financial trouble.

The company's latest financial results contain a long note from its directors justifying why they think CPP can continue as a going concern, despite admitting that the firm notched up a £3.5m underlying operating loss in the last six months.

Last month, CPP secured a critical £36m three-year refinancing deal from its lenders that staved off the immediate risk of bankruptcy. The FCA said this deal was also critical to agreeing the compensation fund.

CPP's share price collapsed as a result of the scandal, from about £3 in early 2011 to 3p a month ago, but has recovered to about 20p since the company received its financial lifeline.

However, its share price fell to 16p in early Thursday trading following the scheme's announcement and release of CPP's latest financial results.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.