Q&A: What is 'forward guidance'?

Mark Carney Mr Carney said that his forward guidance policy was "working"

The governor of the Bank of England, Mark Carney, has overhauled his policy of "forward guidance", just six months after it was first implemented.

"Forward guidance" is a tool that Mr Carney has shown a penchant for in his previous job heading Canada's central bank, and that he more-or-less put into immediate action in a statement following the first policy meeting under his stewardship.

Mr Carney, and the Bank's Monetary Policy Committee (MPC), delivered explicit guidance regarding the future conduct of monetary policy in August.

But now he has adapted the plan, owing to falling unemployment and an economic recovery in the UK.

What is forward guidance?

It is making a promise about the future, particularly about future interest rates.

The Bank of England, like other central banks, directly controls the short-term interest rate at which it lends to or borrows from the High Street banks overnight.

This is the interest rate that gets set at each of the Bank of England's monthly Monetary Policy Committee meetings.

What's the point of forward guidance?

The Bank can only directly control the short-term interest rate. But this rate has already been cut to the lowest level that the Bank feels comfortable with.

Given that it has exhausted the more traditional option of short-term interest rate cuts, another way for the Bank to support the economy has been to offer this indicator, by which companies and mortgage borrowers can estimate for how long such low interest rates may be around for in terms of months or years.

Forward guidance is thus a way of converting low short-term interest rates into lower long-term interest rates.

The thinking is that if the High Street banks can be convinced that they will be able to borrow overnight from the Bank of England at just 0.5% for many nights - indeed many months or years - to come, then they will hopefully be willing to lend money out to the rest of us for the longer term at a commensurately lower interest rate as well.

Isn't that what Quantitative Easing is supposed to be for?

QE also seeks to reduce longer-term borrowing costs, but in a different way.

QE involves the Bank buying up debts (specifically, UK government debt in the form of gilts) from the market, in return for newly created money in the form of a deposit at the Bank.

By reducing the available supply of long-term debts for them to invest their money in, the hope is that this will make banks and other financial institutions diversify into other long-term investments - including new loans to the rest of us.

Or, to put it another way, by reducing the supply of long-term debt in the financial system, the Bank hopes to drive up the value of the remaining long-term debts, which is mechanically the same thing as driving down the "yield" or interest rate on such long-term debts.

Then why not just rely on QE?

There is no either/or here. The Bank of England can restart its QE purchases if it wants, while also providing forward guidance about its interest rate and QE plans.

However, recent market jitters over plans by the Federal Reserve (the Bank's US counterpart) to "taper" or slow down the rate of its own QE purchases has highlighted two problems with QE:

  • Firstly, it has played on fears, expressed by many bankers, that QE merely inflates bubbles in the prices of other investments, such as risky loans and share prices, which will then burst as soon as the QE stimulus is withdrawn
  • Secondly, the surprisingly strong reaction of markets to the change in tone from the Federal Reserve highlights how important market expectations- as opposed to the mechanics of supply and demand - are for the effectiveness of QE

How did the original version of forward guidance look?

In August, the Bank told the market that it intended to keep the Bank rate at its current historically low 0.5%, at least until the unemployment rate fell to 7% or below.

Mr Carney did not say that interest rates will automatically rise when that threshold is reached, rather that it is a "way station" for further consideration of the issue.

The Bank also added some conditions that would "knock out" forward guidance. These included any sign of runaway inflation, or threats to financial stability.

So what has happened since the summer?

In Mr Carney's own words: "The unemployment rate has fallen much faster than anticipated... and is likely to reach 7% by the spring."

This jobs growth has meant that the Bank has had to take a fresh look at its forward guidance policy.

As a result Mr Carney said that, instead of just the unemployment rate, the next phase of the Bank's interest rate policy would be determined by a range of different indicators. These included aspects such as the output gap - the gap between potential and actual output - and broad terms such as income and spending.

All this has made the policy somewhat more confusing.

However, Mr Carney argues that the change in policy has come because forward guidance is working and has helped to secure growth.

Any other chances of any other changes?

Whatever the Bank promises, it will always have the right to change its mind later. Indeed, Mr Carney did exactly this in his time at the Canadian central bank, breaking an earlier promise not to raise interest rates for at least a year.

This inability to tie its own hands presents the Bank with a conundrum - how to convince markets today to believe promises that in the future it may be strongly tempted to renege upon.

The economist Paul Krugman has dubbed it "credibly promising to be irresponsible", while other financial bloggers have likened the problem to "Jedi mind tricks".

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories


Business Live

    11:00: Russia rate cut

    There's been quite a sharp fall in the rouble against the dollar and the pound following Russia's interest rate cut. A dollar is buying around 70.84 roubles, a 2.78% fall for the Russian currency. One pound will now get you around 106.6 roubles, which is about a 2.72% fall for the rouble.

    Russia rate cut Via Twitter Andrew Walker BBC World Service Economics correspondent

    tweets: Russian central bank cuts interest rate - 15% from 17% due to "stabilisation of inflation and depreciation expectations"

    10:41: German beer

    Among general eurozone gloom, a bright spot for German breweries, who saw their first increase in sales volume in 2014 after seven years of declines. The Federal Statistical Office said overall sales of German beer in 2014 were 9.56 billion litres (about 16.8 billion UK pints), an increase of 1% over 2013.

    Fridgeonomics Via Blog Linda Yueh Chief business correspondent

    After a five-year effort, Unilever tells me that it has achieved zero waste in all of its 240 factories in 67 countries worldwide. It says that it generates efficiency savings of €200m a year by eliminating disposal costs. Read more of Linda's blog on the website.

    10:14: Housing minister Radio 5 live

    Housing Minister Brandon Lewis was on 5 live talking about house building. "I'm not a fan of targets," he says. Less regulation for small building projects is helping building, he adds. If we are short of housing, why the rise of detached houses? "We've had a period of [building] lots of apartments of flats... we need homes as well."

    10:00: Rental prices

    The graph above, courtesy of the ONS, shows the trend of percentage increases in rental prices. After rises nearing 3% in 2012, the dip to 1.5% may well have ended.

    09:43: Rental prices

    Private rental prices paid by tenants in Great Britain rose by 1.7% in 2014, according to the Office for National Statistics. A 2% rise in Scotland led the charge, while English rents grew 1.8%, and 0.2% increases were logged in Wales. As can be seen, London rent rises have outgunned the rest of the country.

    09:32: Bank of England lending data

    Mortgage approvals rose in December for the first time since June, the Bank of England said. This could mean that a steady reduction in home loans could be ending. There were 60,275 mortgage approvals last month, up from 58,956 in November.

    Via Twitter Richard Westcott BBC transport correspondent

    tweets: BBC News - Crossrail makes tunnel breakthrough under Liverpool Street Station

    09:12: Plane order

    All Nippon Airways has placed an order with a list price of $2.2bn (£1.46bn) for 15 planes from Boeing and Airbus. The Japanese flag carrier is looking to expand routes at Tokyo's central Haneda airport. The airline said it would acquire eight planes from US-based Boeing and seven from fellow duopolist Airbus.

    08:54: Eurozone crisis
    Alexis Tsipras

    Watch out for Greek fire. Or, continuing the Greek theme, maybe we'll see the golden mean. The prime minister who heads the nation's new anti-austerity government, Alexis Tsipras, has it in his diary to meet Jeroen Dijsselbloem, the current head of the eurozone group of finance ministers today to discuss the conditions of Greece's massive bailout.

    BT results 08:37: Via Twitter Rory Cellan-Jones Technology correspondent

    tweets: BT says ultrafast coming within a decade - but will it look that fast in 2025?

    08:29: Honda

    Honda cut its annual operating profit forecast by 6.5%. It has set aside more cash to cover its recall of cars to replace potentially faulty air bags. It now expects an operating profit of 720 billion yen (£4.1bn) for the year to March 31. It previously forecast 770 billion yen.

    08:16: Paper review

    The Guardian splashes on a report from the Institute for Fiscal Studies which claims young workers have been hit hardest by a squeeze in standards of living. The FT digests Shell and US rival ConocoPhillips's investment cancellations. The Wall St Journal says bets against currency pegs, like Denmark's krone with the euro, are on the rise following Switzerland abandoning theirs. The Telegraph reports on a likely windfall for gas companies as wholesale costs drop.

    Google results Via Twitter Stephen Shankland Senior writer at CNET News

    tweets: Google's capital expenditures jumped $1.13 billion sequentially to $3.55 billion in 4Q2014. Data centers ain't cheap.

    07:50: Market update

    Japan's Nikkei index added about 0.4%, clawing back some of the 1.1% lost yesterday, while the Hong Kong Hang Seng index dropped 0.1%, to 24,570.01. Japanese factory output rose 1% from the previous month, below forecasts, while household spending fell more than expected, down 3.4% on a year ago.

    07:33: PPI investigation

    The Financial Conduct Authority, the City watchdog, is planning to "gather evidence on current trends in complaints on payment protection insurance," it says. It could then decide to do an advertising campaign, a time limit on complaints or keep things as they are.

    07:25: BT results

    BT have updated everyone on their pension fund situation and how they will deal with a £7bn deficit. BT will pay £1.5bn into the fund by the end of April 2015. This will be followed by £250m in each of the years to March 2016 and March 2017. Low interest rates have hit the fund.

    07:16: Qatar Airways
    Qatar Airways plane

    Qatar Airways has acquired stake of just less than 10% in BA and Iberia-owner IAG. There's a cap on non-EU ownership of European airlines, but Qatar Airways might up its stake in future, it says.

    07:05: BT results

    BT says third-quarter earnings before tax and interests costs rose 2% to £1.57bn. Gavin Patterson, chief executive says: "All the major communications providers are responding to the strong market demand for fibre broadband, helping to drive take-up in what is already a very competitive market."

    06:57: US growth data BBC Radio 4

    US growth figures will be reported later on. What's the likely result, Today asks Ewen Cameron Watt of Blackrock? "The rate of growth is slowing a little bit but not enough to raise serious concerns," he says. Expect a "stable but robust rate of growth."

    06:45: Greece Radio 5 live

    Guntram Wolff is the director of European think tank Bruegel, and he's on 5 live, talking about Greece. "It was a mistake that Greece joined the euro, but it would now be a mistake for it to leave," he says. "We will have to come to a deal that will have a lower burden on Greece. I essentially think you will keep the nominal amount [owed to bond investors] but you will increase the maturity.. from 30 to 40 or 50 years."

    06:30: Amazon results Radio 5 live

    More from Ewen Cameron Watt of investment manager Blackrock on 5 live. He is giving his views on US results overnight. "Amazon and Google both essentially reported that underlying demand over Christmas was pretty decent," he says. After tax, margins at Amazon are below 1%, he says.

    06:20: Trademark news Radio 5 live

    The phrases "this sick beat" and "nice to meet you, where you been" have been trademarked by singer Taylor Swift, 5 live reports. Laura Harper of law firm Shoosmiths says she is trying to stop other people making money by putting the phrases on a t-shirt or other merchandise. She will have to prove the phrases are "synonymous" with her, she says.

    06:09: Shell results Radio 5 live

    Ewen Cameron Watt of Blackrock is the markets guest on 5 live, talking about yesterday's results from Shell. "These are very historic results because they reflect an average price of $75" per barrel of oil, he says. Bearing in mind oil is below $50 today, "the pain is yet to come," he adds. The firm has cut $15bn of investments. The longer the price remains at this level, the more likely more investment cuts will come, he says.

    06:01: House building Radio 5 live

    Figures from the National House Building Council show there was a 9% rise in homes built last year to 145,174, but the rise missed the government's 200,000 home target. Peter Vella of Countryside Properties is on 5 live. NHBC's figures don't take into account all homes started or built, so the industry could be closer to the target than thought.

    06:00: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning all. Overnight, online retail giant Amazon has reported weaker profits for the busy Christmas period. Stay tuned for the best business and economics news and get in touch via email bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or on twitter @BBCBusiness



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.