Does SSE fine match the offence?

 
SSE training centre in Perth

In any competitive market where prices are opaque and difficult to understand, there will be mis-selling.

So it is perhaps not surprising that a big power provider, SSE, has today been fined a record £10.5m for what the energy regulator Ofgem calls "numerous breaches of its obligations relating to telephone, in-store and doorstep sales activities".

These breaches included misleading customers about the size of bills they would receive and about tariffs offered by rivals.

Ofgem says that there were "failures at all stages of SSE's sales processes, from the opening lines on the doorstep, in-store or over the phone, through to the confirmation process which follows a sale".

It is unedifying stuff.

That said, given that historically most power companies have offered a dizzying and confusing number of different packages and tariffs for gas and electricity, some would argue that the whole business of marketing power is a mis-selling racket. And that's why attempts by the regulator to introduce greater simplicity and transparency into pricing have been widely welcomed.

So what is perhaps most shocking in Ofgem's report is the disclosure that "the people employed to do the main auditing of doorstep sales received a commission on sales and therefore had a financial interest in not reporting misbehaviour".

The idea that the internal watchdogs had an incentive to turn the Nelsonian eye on sales people is an interesting approach to governance.

To be clear, SSE says it has learned its lesson - and unlike many companies publicly spanked by a regulator in this way, it was prepared to answer for its sins on Radio 4's Today Programme this morning (so that's a big hello to our banks, which don't yet have the confidence of an SSE to look their customers in the eye, as it were).

Squeezed bonuses

Its corporate affairs director Alan Young said that compliance monitoring was now an independent operation within SSE, and that the company was guaranteeing to reimburse customers made worse-off by switching to it.

Doorstep selling by SSE was now history, he added.

That said, no heads have rolled among SSE's senior executive team - although their bonuses have been squeezed, Mr Young said.

So here's a question: does the punishment match abuses which went on for up to three years?

On the one hand, the £10.5m - which goes to the Treasury - may be greater than the consumer detriment proved by Ofgem.

On the other, that fine is 0.5% of the cash generated year-in and year-out by SSE. For a company of SSE's size and stability, it is a financial gnat bite.

 
Robert Peston Article written by Robert Peston Robert Peston Economics editor

UK living too high on the hog (again)

How worried should we be by the UK's record current account deficit, our inability to pay our way in the world?

Read full article

More on This Story

More from Robert

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +112

    Comment number 11.

    Let me see...

    Directors to lose £10.5m ? No.

    Shareholders to lose £10.5m ? Erm, no again.

    Customers to see combined bills increase by £10.5m ? Could be !

  • rate this
    +93

    Comment number 3.

    Mis-selling has become the modus operandi of big business, profiteering by deceit. There is little doubt this behaviour is replicated in the industry and consumers are being tricked into contracts. Fines of the companies profits will not do the trick, what must happen is Directors must be jailed, fined and banned from holding office.

  • rate this
    +87

    Comment number 2.

    It's time to make directors of companies personally responsible in law for these kinds of cons. Send them to jail. Deceit, mis-selling, price fixing etc. I'm convinced most, if not all, big companies -- banks, trains and airlines, supermarkets, insurance, you name it -- are up to tricks like this. Tiny scams at the level of the individual consumer but carried out on a massive scale.

  • rate this
    +82

    Comment number 8.

    Ah yes, but if you steal a case of bottled water you get sent to jail for 6 months.

    Go to be made an example of, you see.

  • rate this
    +76

    Comment number 29.

    Big business is getting away with murder.They are above the law.
    They get fined, we pay. They lose money because of bad investments,we pay. Meanwhile we are all shivering in our homes as they make record profits.

 

Comments 5 of 676

 

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.