Why it is Catch-22 for Liberia's development hopes

President Johnson Sirleaf – who won the Nobel Peace Prize in 2011 – has won praise for her efforts to get Liberia’s national debt written off. Liberia's President Sirleaf has won praise for trying to get the national debt written off

Related Stories

When BBC Radio 4's Today programme embarked on its plan to "adopt" Liberia as a country, I seem to remember my colleague and fellow presenter John Humphrys asking an important question about the country: why is it that progress towards development there is so slow?

He was right to raise it.

After all, the instability and civil war that completely managed to wreck the country over a 23-year period are over. There is a competent president in post, aid is pouring in, and the debt hanging over the country has been written off.

And yet for many people in Liberia, conditions are still medieval. Many people are living on incomes of $5-10 (£3-6) a week, there are only about 100 or so doctors in the country to look after the 3.5 million people there, roads are pot-holed and only a small percentage of the population have access to electricity.

Yet, what is so striking about Liberia is that in a place where there is so much to be done, I have never seen so many people with nothing to do.

More than 80% of the workforce is unemployed (if the concept can be meaningfully measured at that kind of level). All over the country, at all times of the week, you see people just hanging out. Young men sitting astride their mopeds (there are plenty of them around as young veterans of the war were given the money to buy mopeds to encourage them to hand in their weapons).

Children selling low-value goods at the roadside are a familiar sight in Liberia Children selling low-value goods at the roadside are a familiar sight

Or you see children and women on the sides of streets or in bustling markets hopelessly under-worked engaging in low value retail activities.

One boy told me that if he wanders around for half a day, he can sell about 12 packets of biscuits. That is a lot of work for a child in return for very little income.

Think how much more productive everybody could be with some well-organised tasks, some decent management and a bit of equipment.

Which brings us back to the John Humphrys question.

Why does that kind of development not occur? Why does Liberia not take off? Why does it not become a tiger economy following the model of others from Europe and Asia to the Americas, which heaved themselves out of the poverty of subsistence agriculture by opening factories?

After all, manufacturing quickly makes relatively unskilled workers very productive indeed. In principle, Liberia should be highly attractive to employers with wage rates there at about $5 a day in the formal sector of the economy, making them about a fifth of those in the most industrial parts of China.

Liberia's President Sirleaf: The fundamentals are in place

Having spent an intensive week in the country (a ludicrously short time to start pontificating on it, I admit) I came to think I had a not very original answer to that Humphrys question. So let me set it out here.

It all comes down to the many different Catch-22s of development. Let me give you an example of the sort of thing I mean. For industry to settle in a country, you first need electricity; for electricity, you need some trained workers; for trained workers, you need some schools; for schools you need some money; for money, you need some industry.

There are more subtle examples too: to hire expert foreigners to manage your electricity industry and get things moving, you need civil servants who know how to hire foreigners. But you probably don't have any civil servants expert in hiring foreigners - you really need to hire foreigners to acquire some.

The general point is that Liberia starts from the disadvantage of having multiple disadvantages simultaneously. If we had any one of the country's problems, we would fix it pretty quickly - if we had no electricity, we would be able to build some up pretty darn fast. If we had no schools, we would rapidly create some.

If the civil service was weak, we would establish one by hiring good people from the private sector. But if we lacked electricity, schools and civil servants, the challenge of building each of these sectors together would be more than the sum of the challenge of building each individually. Progress will not occur on one front without progress on the others, and achieving progress on all fronts is going to be slow.

A female market trader with her goods One of Liberia's many market traders

An important implication of this is that we should not judge Liberia by western standards. When you ask a question about why something has not happened, it is generally because you can't assume that kind of thing happens in that environment.

Western donors who attach tough terms and conditions to their aid and who want endless compliance forms to be filled out, appear not to get it at all. There simply are not enough people to fill those forms out and so aid often takes too long to get through. A point made by President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf to me, in an interview.

As a final Catch-22 example, I would cite the Liberian tax system. Tax revenues provide money to support health and education but health and education are necessary for a well-functioning tax system.

I spent an afternoon with a tax inspector in Bong County and was dismayed to find his office was a small empty dilapidated building, furnished with a table, a couple of chairs and a cupboard. It had only just acquired a lock on the door. The inspector's taxpayers typically didn't keep accounts; he didn't have transport to get around to see them… and so on and so on. Where do you start in building a tax system out of that?

Oh, and if that wasn't bad enough, the population of prime age adults - the ones who all societies rely on to do most of the important tasks - spent their formative years in war, being taught how to destroy things rather than how to create them. The human capital was wiped out by the years of self-destruction along with the infrastructure.

In short, why does development take so long, even in a place where the intentions of those in power are good? The answer is because while any one physical or human institution can be reformed or improved rapidly, it simply takes a long time to create them all from scratch.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    11:31: Black Friday

    A Tesco spokesperson has told the BBC: "Over 600 Tesco stores have Black Friday offers available in store. In the interest of customer safety a small number of these stores contacted police last night to help control crowds safely and stores are now trading normally."

     
  2.  
    11:16: Black Friday

    Greater Manchester Police, who were called to seven Tesco stores last night and made three arrests, are not happy. Chief Constable Sir Peter Fahy, said: "The events of last night were totally predictable and I am disappointed that stores did not have sufficient security staff on duty."

     
  3.  
    11:08: Brazil's avoids recession
    Brazil

    Brazil's economy has recovered in the past three months - but only slightly. It expanded 0.1% - narrowly avoiding recession. In the previous quarter, it contracted by 0.6%.

     
  4.  
    11:00: House prices

    Average UK house prices rose by just 0.1% in October, according to figures released by the Land Registry today. The average property was worth £177,377 in the month, it says. However, the Land Registry index, which is based on the prices at which properties are actually sold, also shows that UK prices rose 7.7% over the year. In London, they rose by 18.6% in the last 12 months.

     
  5.  
    Via Twitter Jonty Bloom Business correspondent, BBC News

    tweets: "The number of people killed by cold weather last winter was the lowest since records began, official statistics show."

     
  6.  
    10:48: Eurozone unemployment
    Eurostat

    This graph shows how the unemployment rates in the eurozone, wider EU, the US and Japan compare since 2000. As you can see, the EU and US reached similarly high levels at the height of the financial crisis, but the US has fared a lot better since.

     
  7.  
    10:34: Black Friday

    Alan Cameron from Aberdeen emails: "Black Friday is designed to appeal to the worst off in society, and is about unashamedly exploiting naked greed and desires in society."

     
  8.  
    Black Friday Willard Foxton

    tweets: "Piketty's 'Capital in the 21st century' is 65% off in Amazon UK's Black Friday sale. Someone has a sense of humor!"

     
  9.  
    10:22: Cameron immigration speech

    Mr Cameron gets to the crux of his speech. "I will insist that in the future those who want to claim tax credits and child benefit must live here and contribute to our country for a minimum of four years," he says. "If their child is living abroad, then there should be no child benefit or child tax credit at all no matter how long they have worked in the UK and no matter how much tax they have paid. And we will introduce a new residency requirement for social housing - meaning that you can't even be considered for a council house unless you have been here for at least four years."

     
  10.  
    10:20: Black Friday

    Retail analyst Nick Bubb says Black Friday is likely to "bring forward business from December, reduce gross margins and undermine consumer's willingness to pay full-price again before Christmas. It is therefore good to see that Next are thinking long-term and preserving their pricing power..."

     
  11.  
    10:15: Eurozone unemployment

    Separate figures show that the average rate of unemployment in the 18 countries in the eurozone remained at 11.5%, despite the economy's deterioration.

     
  12.  
    10:08: Eurozone inflation

    A preliminary estimate for the level of inflation (that's the rise in the prices of everyday goods and services) in Europe shows a drop to 0.3% in November - down from 0.4% the month before. Falling oil prices accounted for much of that drop, but the slow creep toward deflation will add further pressure on the European Central Bank, which targets inflation of 2%.

     
  13.  
    10:00: Cameron immigration speech

    "Put simply, our job is to educate and train up our youth, so we are less reliant on immigration to fill our skills gap," says the PM. "And any politician who doesn't have a serious plan for welfare and education, has no sensible long-term plan for controlling immigration."

     
  14.  
    09:58: Cameron immigration speech

    "For the sake of British jobs, British livelihoods and British opportunities we must fight this dangerous and misguided view that our nation can withdraw from the world and somehow all will be well."

     
  15.  
    09:58: Cameron immigration speech
    Cameron

    "We are Great Britain because of immigration, not in spite of it," says David Cameron in his opening salvo. "Throughout our long history, we have always looked outward, not inward. We have used the seas that surround our shores not to cut ourselves off from the world, but to reach out to it - to carry our trade to the four corners of the earth. And with that trade has come people, companies, jobs and investment."

     
  16.  
    09:44: Black Friday

    John Lewis says it is currently selling one Nutribullet every 30 seconds. For the uninitiated, that's a food processor, or juicer, if you prefer.

     
  17.  
    09:28: Italian jobs

    Unemployment in Italy has reached a record high of 13.2%, according to official figures for the month of October. It's the largest percentage since figures were first collected in 1977. Even worse news for 15-24 year olds in the country - 43.3% were unemployed last month.

     
  18.  
    Black Friday Sgt Paul Marshall, Kingston Police

    tweets: "Even on #BlackFriday shoving people to the floor so you can get £20 off a Coffee Maker is still an assault."

     
  19.  
    09:12: Markets update

    European markets are lower this morning on the back of falling oil prices, which are nearing $70 a barrel. They've not been that low in four years.

    • The FTSE 100 is lower by 0.74% at 6673
    • Germany's Dax is lower by 0.47% 9928
    • France's Cac-40 is lower by 0.53% at 4359
     
  20.  
    09:05: House prices
    Graph showing house price growth since November 2004

    The annual house price has been falling since June, when growth peaked at 11.4%. Now it's only 8.5% higher than this time last year. It's worth remembering that house price growth is coming off a low base as well. Property values (that's the average for the whole of the UK) only began to rise in the summer of 2013, as the effects of the Funding for Lending and Help to Buy schemes began to be felt.

     
  21.  
    Black Friday Kadhim Shubber, reporter at the FT
    Asda

    tweets: "Unleash the capitalism #BlackFriday" (Click through for the full Vine video)

     
  22.  
    Black Friday Bryan Roberts, director at Kantar Retail
    Asda

    There are cheerleaders in Asda. Really. Bryan tweets: "Cheerleaders. This is my job. Honest."

     
  23.  
    08:24: Building Lego
    Malaysia Lego

    UK theme park operator Merlin Entertainments has announced it will open a new Legoland... in South Korea. The attraction is expected to open its doors in Chuncheon, Gangwon Province by 2017. There is already a Legoland in Malaysia, and the firm plans to build one in Dubai too.

     
  24.  
    Black Friday Bryan Roberts, director at Kantar Retail

    tweets: "6 minutes ago, this was a massive pile of TVs"

    TVs
     
  25.  
    Black Friday Sarah Butler, The Guardian

    tweets: "Crazy queues at Asda, but all calm and very British queue in place... So far"

    Black Friday
     
  26.  
    08:10: Black Friday

    Richard Main, a reporter at BBC London 94.9, emails in: "More than 150 people are now queuing to get into Asda on Edgware Road, in the hope of bagging a Black Friday deal. Police were called to the store in the early hours of the morning to control crowds. The current queue now stretches the length of the car park and is being penned in by a wall of shopping trolleys."

     
  27.  
    Black Friday Greater Manchester Police

    tweet: "At least two people arrested at #BlackFriday sales events already this morning. Keep calm people!"

     
  28.  
    08:02: Black Friday
    People sort through boxes of shoes in Macy"s

    A bit of Friday fun now. We want your best/worst Black Friday deals. What's the most ridiculous sale item you've seen or bought? What's be best/worst discount you've seen? Have you seen punch-ups over the last sale item or is everyone queuing politely? Send your stories/pictures/experiences/views of Black Friday to bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or tweet @bbcbusiness.

     
  29.  
    07:45: Betting campaign BBC Radio 4
    Betting terminal

    The maximum stake on gambling machines known as "fixed odd betting terminals" is £100. Many think that's outrageous, as it's possible to lose an awful lot of money in a very short time. Now more than 90 councils in Britain are campaigning to have that reduced dramatically - to £2. Sir Robin Wales, the mayor of Newham in London, tells Today that gambling firms deliberately target poorer areas.

     
  30.  
    07:34: House prices
    Graph showing the average house price to average earnings ratio

    One thing to note in the latest Nationwide figures is the price-to-earnings ratio, which has tailed off ever so slightly. This measures how high house prices are, relative to the average person's salary. The higher the ratio rises, the less affordable housing becomes. Since WW2, each time average house prices have reached six times average earnings, there as been a crash.

     
  31.  
    07:22: House prices

    The price of an average house in the UK rose by 0.3% in November to £189,388, according to the latest figures from Nationwide. Overall, however, the growth in house prices slowed to 8.5%, when compared to November of last year. It was 9% in October.

     
  32.  
    07:12: Energy penalties
    Drax

    "We are deeply disappointed with the magnitude of the fine," said Drax boss Dorothy Thompson. But Ofgem's Sarah Harrison says the firm "missed its target by a clear margin" and accuses it of "disadvantaging several thousand households in some of the most deprived areas in Britain".

     
  33.  
    07:06: Energy penalties

    Another generation firm, Intergen, is also facing an £11m payout. The companies failed to meet targets to insulate homes under two energy efficiency schemes that ran until the end of 2012. The failings meant that households did not receive the energy saving measures, which would have helped to reduce their bills.

     
  34.  
    07:00: Energy penalties

    The power generation company Drax, based in North Yorkshire, has been hit with a £28m financial penalty after failing to meet targets to provide energy efficiency measures to homes. It's the largest penalty ever handed down by the energy regulator Ofgem.

     
  35.  
    06:58: Black Friday Radio 5 live

    Ms Burge tells Wake Up to Money that over the last couple of years retailers and consumers have "engaged in a game of chicken". Consumers have started holding out on retailers, she says, in the knowledge that the closer they get to Christmas, the more likely they will be to get a deal as retailers start discounting.

     
  36.  
    06:45: Tech terms

    More from Andrew Miller on tech firms' terms and conditions. "They are often laughably long and written in the kind of legalese you need a law degree from the USA to understand," says the Labour MP for Ellesmere Port and Neston.

     
  37.  
    Via Twitter NASA
    Pic of a star being sucked into a black hole

    If you don't really get all this Black Friday stuff, it's not really your bag or the fact that the spirit of Christmas has been lost in worship to Mammon is getting you down, NASA has a solution for you. It tweets: "It's #BlackFriday, but for us, it's the 2nd annual #BlackHoleFriday. Today, we'll post pics & info about black holes".

     
  38.  
    06:32: Tech terms

    The chairman of the Science and Technology Committee, Andrew Miller, told the BBC: "I simply cannot say to a constituent of mine I know with 100% certainty what they're doing with that data because frankly I don't understand those legal terms and conditions".

     
  39.  
    06:26: Tech terms

    MPs are calling for social networking companies, such as Facebook and Twitter, to explain more clearly to users what they do with information collected about them. The Commons Science Committee says the firms' terms and conditions agreements are far too long and complex for any reasonable person to read.

     
  40.  
    Via Twitter Alistair Charlton, senior technology reporter at IBTimes UK
    Black Friday

    tweets: "Tesco website down, Currys website down, shopping chaos caught on video. It's #BlackFriday."

     
  41.  
    06:12: Black Friday Radio 5 live

    Natalie Burge, retail analyst at Planet Retail, says Black Friday is a "really strange phenomenon, but it makes sense in the US" because it comes after a public holiday - a bit like Boxing Day. Whereas in the UK it's just another day. Black Friday falls on "the day of the last pay cheque before Christmas" so retailers are spotting an opportunity to get consumers to part with their hard earned cash, she adds.

     
  42.  
    06:04: Black Friday

    Shareholders among you may still recoil at the term "Black Friday" - the name given to the stock market crash of October 13, 1989. But fear not, in the shopping context, the name has no such negative connotations. It's called Black Friday because many shops make enough money to put them "in the black" for the year, apparently.

     
  43.  
    06:00: Black Friday
    Black Friday

    Police were called to a number of supermarkets across the UK last night, amid concern about the size of crowds waiting for the doors to open on what's become one of the busiest shopping days of the year. Increasing numbers of British retailers are adopting the American tradition of reducing some of their prices for Black Friday - the day after Thanksgiving. Some websites are already reported to be struggling to cope with demand.

     
  44.  
    06:00: Matthew West, Business Reporter

    As always, you can get in touch by emailing bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or tweeting @BBCBusiness.

     
  45.  
    06:00: Joe Miller Business Reporter

    Good morning. In a long-awaited speech later, David Cameron will call for major changes to the benefits that can be claimed by European Union migrants. He'll say they should have to wait four years before they can claim in-work benefits such as tax credits, or be eligible for social housing. We'll bring you more on that, and the rest of the business news throughout the morning.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.