Why it is Catch-22 for Liberia's development hopes

President Johnson Sirleaf – who won the Nobel Peace Prize in 2011 – has won praise for her efforts to get Liberia’s national debt written off. Liberia's President Sirleaf has won praise for trying to get the national debt written off

Related Stories

When BBC Radio 4's Today programme embarked on its plan to "adopt" Liberia as a country, I seem to remember my colleague and fellow presenter John Humphrys asking an important question about the country: why is it that progress towards development there is so slow?

He was right to raise it.

After all, the instability and civil war that completely managed to wreck the country over a 23-year period are over. There is a competent president in post, aid is pouring in, and the debt hanging over the country has been written off.

And yet for many people in Liberia, conditions are still medieval. Many people are living on incomes of $5-10 (£3-6) a week, there are only about 100 or so doctors in the country to look after the 3.5 million people there, roads are pot-holed and only a small percentage of the population have access to electricity.

Yet, what is so striking about Liberia is that in a place where there is so much to be done, I have never seen so many people with nothing to do.

More than 80% of the workforce is unemployed (if the concept can be meaningfully measured at that kind of level). All over the country, at all times of the week, you see people just hanging out. Young men sitting astride their mopeds (there are plenty of them around as young veterans of the war were given the money to buy mopeds to encourage them to hand in their weapons).

Children selling low-value goods at the roadside are a familiar sight in Liberia Children selling low-value goods at the roadside are a familiar sight

Or you see children and women on the sides of streets or in bustling markets hopelessly under-worked engaging in low value retail activities.

One boy told me that if he wanders around for half a day, he can sell about 12 packets of biscuits. That is a lot of work for a child in return for very little income.

Think how much more productive everybody could be with some well-organised tasks, some decent management and a bit of equipment.

Which brings us back to the John Humphrys question.

Why does that kind of development not occur? Why does Liberia not take off? Why does it not become a tiger economy following the model of others from Europe and Asia to the Americas, which heaved themselves out of the poverty of subsistence agriculture by opening factories?

After all, manufacturing quickly makes relatively unskilled workers very productive indeed. In principle, Liberia should be highly attractive to employers with wage rates there at about $5 a day in the formal sector of the economy, making them about a fifth of those in the most industrial parts of China.

Having spent an intensive week in the country (a ludicrously short time to start pontificating on it, I admit) I came to think I had a not very original answer to that Humphrys question. So let me set it out here.

It all comes down to the many different Catch-22s of development. Let me give you an example of the sort of thing I mean. For industry to settle in a country, you first need electricity; for electricity, you need some trained workers; for trained workers, you need some schools; for schools you need some money; for money, you need some industry.

There are more subtle examples too: to hire expert foreigners to manage your electricity industry and get things moving, you need civil servants who know how to hire foreigners. But you probably don't have any civil servants expert in hiring foreigners - you really need to hire foreigners to acquire some.

The general point is that Liberia starts from the disadvantage of having multiple disadvantages simultaneously. If we had any one of the country's problems, we would fix it pretty quickly - if we had no electricity, we would be able to build some up pretty darn fast. If we had no schools, we would rapidly create some.

If the civil service was weak, we would establish one by hiring good people from the private sector. But if we lacked electricity, schools and civil servants, the challenge of building each of these sectors together would be more than the sum of the challenge of building each individually. Progress will not occur on one front without progress on the others, and achieving progress on all fronts is going to be slow.

A female market trader with her goods One of Liberia's many market traders

An important implication of this is that we should not judge Liberia by western standards. When you ask a question about why something has not happened, it is generally because you can't assume that kind of thing happens in that environment.

Western donors who attach tough terms and conditions to their aid and who want endless compliance forms to be filled out, appear not to get it at all. There simply are not enough people to fill those forms out and so aid often takes too long to get through. A point made by President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf to me, in an interview.

As a final Catch-22 example, I would cite the Liberian tax system. Tax revenues provide money to support health and education but health and education are necessary for a well-functioning tax system.

I spent an afternoon with a tax inspector in Bong County and was dismayed to find his office was a small empty dilapidated building, furnished with a table, a couple of chairs and a cupboard. It had only just acquired a lock on the door. The inspector's taxpayers typically didn't keep accounts; he didn't have transport to get around to see them… and so on and so on. Where do you start in building a tax system out of that?

Oh, and if that wasn't bad enough, the population of prime age adults - the ones who all societies rely on to do most of the important tasks - spent their formative years in war, being taught how to destroy things rather than how to create them. The human capital was wiped out by the years of self-destruction along with the infrastructure.

In short, why does development take so long, even in a place where the intentions of those in power are good? The answer is because while any one physical or human institution can be reformed or improved rapidly, it simply takes a long time to create them all from scratch.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    HOUSE SALES 10:21:
    A general view of residential housing on a street in south London

    UK property sales in June hit their joint highest monthly total since the financial crisis began, figures released by HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) show. But sales among young adults are low. There were 109,580 sales in June, the same as in November last year, and the highest since the end of 2007, HMRC says.

    MARKET UPDATE 10:20:

    Tokyo stocks rose 0.84% by the end of Tuesday, boosted by a weaker yen as traders returned from a three-day holiday weekend. The benchmark Nikkei 225 index climbed 127.57 points to finish at 15,343.28, while the Topix index was up 0.79%, or 9.98 points, at 1,273.27. The gains were in line with a pick-up across Asia after pro-Russian rebels handed over the black boxes of the crashed Malaysia Airlines jet.


    More on the Bank of England interest payments. Essentially, the £3.9bn in interest payments transferred to the government by the BOE are a bit of an accounting wheeze. Whether the money really exists is debateable. It might be better explained as money the government hasn't had to pay out in interest payments to bond holders because quantitative easing means the BOE is the bondholder in question.


    The first three months of 2013 saw higher than usual income tax payments as higher earners delayed bonus payments until after the top rate of incomes tax fell to 45% from 50%. That's why income tax in the first three months of this tax year was 3.5% lower than in the first three months of last year. Even so, public borrowing isn't falling as predicted and missed analysts expectations for June by nearly £1bn. There were also £0.9bn worth of receipts from a Swiss tax avoidance deal last year.

    The Bank of England,

    The Treasury has pointed out that the public sector net debt (PSND) figures were affected by unusual tax receipts last year while the Bank of England transferred £3.9bn of interest payments due on government bonds. When the effect of those tax receipts is stripped out the PSND in June is £0.1bn lower than the same month last year.

    PUBLIC BORROWING 09:33: Breaking News

    Public borrowing was £11.4bn in June, official figures released this morning have shown. The figure is £3.8bn higher than the same month last year.

    A train leaving the Eurotunnel

    Eurotunnel has released half year results: It says core profit is up 6% to 216m euros (£170m) thanks in no small part to the recovery in the UK economy, leading to more of us taking trips over to the continent plus stronger freight traffic. Revenues are up 8% as well. Eurotunnel has kept its full year guidance the same saying it expects profits to hit 460m euros.

    Workers producing food at the Shanghai Husi Food Co., a factory of US food provider OSI Group, in Shanghai

    Chinese police are questioning staff of US food supplier OSI Group for selling expired meat, according to state media. Shanghai authorities on Sunday shut an OSI plant - a supplier to McDonald's and KFC in China - for mixing out-of-date meat with fresh product, re-labelling expired goods and other quality problems following an investigative report by a local television station.

    Rupert Murdoch, executive chairman of News Corporation,

    Time Warner has tightened up its bylaws just in case its shareholders get twitchy and try to call a special board meeting to discuss a second attempted takeover bid from Rupert Murdoch's 21st Century Fox, according to a report in the Daily Telegraph. It follows the news that Time Warner rejected an $80bn (£46bn) approach from Fox last month. The amendment blocks a standard rule that 15% of a company's investors can vote to call a special meeting.


    European markets have opened higher this morning, despite fears over further European economic sanctions against Russia. Royal Mail is the biggest faller on the FTSE 100 down 3.5% to 450.4p after is said its parcels revenues fell 1% in the three months to 29 June:

    • The FTSE is 0.42%, or 28.57 points, higher at 6,757.01
    • Germany's Dax is 0.67%, or 64.08 points higher at 9,676.13
    • France's Cac-40 is up 0.56%, or 24.07 points, to 4,328.61
    RUSSIAN SANCTIONS 08:23: BBC Radio 4

    Prof Marie Mendras, a former French government adviser, is speaking on the Today Programme about sanctions on Russia after last week's plane crash. She's particularly talking about Russia's order of warships from France. French President Francois Hollande is "stuck" she says. He may reconsider the sale of the second warship. "Each country is trying to defend its economic interests," she says.

    RUSSIAN SANCTIONS 08:13: BBC Radio 4

    The European Union's (EU) economic sanctions against Russia are likely to be tightened today, when European foreign ministers meet in Brussels following the downing of Malaysia Airlines flight MH17, the BBC's Europe Editor Gavin Hewitt tells the Today programme. It is most likely those sanctions may see more people added to the list of proscribed persons in an effort to bring EU sanctions in line with those in the US. But Germany and the UK are at odds over how tough sanctions should be, he adds.

    ROYAL MAIL Via Twitter Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    tweets: Royal Mail: despite parcels performing less well, letters decline is not as rapid as expected. Performance in line with guidance

    LIDL TAX 07:48: BBC Radio 4

    BBC business reporter Joe Lynam points out that as a German company that operates in the UK, Lidl doesn't have to disclose the amount of corporation tax it pays in Britain, but adds it is likely the supermarket does not want to be seen in the same light as Starbucks, Google and Amazon, who were widely criticised last year over the amount of corporation tax they did or did not pay here.

    ARM RESULTS 07:35:

    Chipmaker Arm posted a 9% rise in second-quarter profit, helped by strong demand to license its technology. The Cambridge-based company, which had previously made microchips for Apple's iphone and receives revenue for selling its blueprints and royalties, reported pre-tax profit of £94.2m.

    LIDL TAX 07:29: BBC Radio 4

    German discount retailer Lidl has disclosed it paid £25m in tax in 2013 following a campaign to get it to publish its full financial accounts in the UK. Bryan Roberts from retail analysts Kantar Retail suggests that means Lidl is paying around 20% in corporation tax on a 3% margin. Julian Bailey, a spokesman for Morrison's supermarket tells the Today Programme it is "a pity it took Lidl so much time" to disclose how much tax it pays.

    ROYAL MAIL 07:17:
    Royal Mail letterbox

    Royal Mail says it's had a weaker-than-expected performance in UK parcels, "largely driven by the intensifying competitive environment" in the three months to 29 June. "Given the increasing challenges we are facing in the UK parcels market, our parcels revenue for the year is likely to be lower than we had anticipated," it said.

    VODAFONE COVERAGE 07:10: Radio 5 live

    Jeroen Hoencamp, the Vodafone UK chief executive has been on 5 live talking about the firm's rollout of 3G to rural areas that previously had poorer mobile internet access. "We need to be very careful there won't be a digital divide between urban and rural areas," he says.

    CREDIT SUISSE 06:59:
    The logo of Swiss bank Credit Suisse

    It's not a great day to be a Swiss banker, especially one working for Credit Suisse, which has this morning reported its biggest loss in nearly six years. It took a 1.6bn Swiss-franc charge (£1.04bn) as part of its settlement with authorities over tax evasion charges. The bank has also reported a loss of 700m Swiss francs for the second-quarter, compared with a profit of 1.05 billion francs a year earlier.


    Communications firm Publicis, which you'll remember tried to merge with rival Omnicom, said it would be "very difficult" to meet its annual target of 4% growth in sales after a second-quarter slowdown. Part of the reason was the end of that merger, it said, as well as the strength of the euro.


    After a rally in Asia in the wake of a softer approach from Russia overnight, following the downing of Malaysia airline's flight MH17, European markets are expected to open a bit higher this morning. The Nikkei rose 1% to 15,368.28, while the Hang Seng rose 1.4% to 23,716.24.

    RUSSIAN SANCTIONS 06:37: BBC Radio 4

    London houses enough Russian money that the UK could "really hurt" the country through economic sanctions and the freezing of assets - particularly property, but businesses as well - following the downing of Malaysia Airline's flight MH17, should it want to, says money laundering expert Jeffrey Robinson, who has been described by the British Bankers' Association as "the world's leading financial crime author".

    PENSION PROTECTION FUND 06:25: Radio 5 live

    Lady Barbara Judge is on 5 live. She's the chairperson of the Pension Protection Fund, which pays your pension if your employer goes bust. It's basically a re-insurance system, she says. They manage £16bn of assets. "It's very important people get good guidance on what they're doing" in pensions, she says.

    TESCO 06:10: Radio 5 live
    Tesco"s chief executive Philip Clarke

    More from Richard Dunbar, investment director at Aberdeen Asset Management, on 5 live, this time talking about the departure of Tesco chief executive Philip Clarke. "He made some good decision tidying up the overseas portfolio," Mr Dunbar says. But, "it was also the UK business that was the problem" which he "didn't get to grips with." He may be asked to work until the start of next year to help the handover to his successor, Dave Lewis, he says.

    SFO INVESTIGATION 06:02: Radio 5 live

    Richard Dunbar, investment director at Aberdeen Asset Management, is on 5 live talking about the Serious Fraud Office's investigation into the foreign exchange market. "There are 15 agencies now looking into it," he says, and despite being a £15trn market, it is a "surprise such a big market can be manipulated in the way the SFO may feel."

    06:00: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning everyone. The big news from overnight is that Yahoo has acquired app analytics firm, Flurry, to help boost its advertising revenue from smartphones. As always you can get in touch with us at bizlievepage@bbc.co.uk and on twitter @bbcbusiness.

    06:00: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning everyone. There's a number of financial results and some economic data slated for today, so we'll be bringing you the best of that, and much, much more. Stay tuned.



  • ScissorsWithout Scotland?

    How might things change for the rest of the UK

  • VigoroAnyone for Vigoro?

    The bizarre Edwardian attempt to merge tennis and cricket

  • Payton McKinnonLeft behind

    Why do so many children die in hot cars?

  • Dr Mahinder Watsa Dr Sex

    The wisecracking 90-year-old whose agony column is a cult hit

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.