Fertility trade: Eggs, sperm and rented wombs

Sperm fertilising an egg

Related Stories

The growth of the fertility industry has meant women's eggs and men's sperm have become commodities like any other, to be bought and sold.

Along with rented wombs, it's a sign of an industry benefitting from the trend for working women to start their families later, when they might have more problems conceiving.

If a woman can no longer produce her own healthy eggs, she might go to a clinic which offers donated eggs, to be fertilised by the husband's sperm and then implanted.

"The demand is quite excessive," says Amanda Segal at the Shady Grove Fertility Reproductive Science Center near Washington DC in the US.

"With a donor egg, they are still a part of their partner if they are using their partner's sperm," she says.

"And she gets to carry their child."

Advertising for donors

In some countries, the law allows women who donate eggs to be paid for their services.

Start Quote

You immediately realise what a gift this young woman (the donor) is giving”

End Quote Amanda Segal Shady Grove Fertility Clinic

"At the Shady Grove Fertility Centers, we cap it at $6,500 (£4,000)," says Ms Segal.

Donors have to be between the ages of 21 and 31 and the centre advertises on Facebook and Google to target young women.

"In any month, we probably have about 1,000 applications," says Ms Segal. "Out of those 1,000, only 5% make it to egg donation."

The purchaser can end up paying about $25,000 once the pre-screening procedures, medicating the donor, and the fee paid to the donor for her eggs are taken into account.

But Shady Grove Fertility does offer a full refund if no baby is delivered, no matter how many cycles are involved.

Ms Segal recognises that some people might think it distasteful that women's eggs, the source of all human life, have become a commodity to be bought and sold like any other.

"When you are on the other side of the fence," she says, "you immediately realise what a gift this young woman (the donor) is giving."

Surrogacy law in the UK

  • Surrogacy is not illegal in the UK
  • Only surrogacy arrangements that are informal and non-commercial are allowed
  • It is an offence to profit by helping someone else to make a surrogacy arrangement
  • Surrogacy agreements are unenforceable

Also in demand is donated sperm. Figures suggest that 10% to 15% of all heterosexual couples have trouble conceiving and many single and gay women are also opting to have babies using donated sperm.

One of the biggest exporters in the world is Cryos International in Denmark. Its service allows customers to bypass strict regulations which control the supply of sperm in clinics in many countries by having products shipped directly to people for home insemination.

Managing director Ole Schou says lesbian couples make up about 10% of their clientele, with single women accounting for about 40% of demand. "It is like an avalanche, a tsunami," he says.

Online browsing

He notes that they tend to be highly educated, well-situated females who have focused on their career and then, in their 30s, start thinking about reproduction.

Start Quote

If you want to say it's a baby factory, fine. If you want to say that it is helping the women change their lives, it is another way to look at it”

End Quote Dr Nayna Patel Ak-Shanka clinic

Unlike obtaining sperm from a fertility clinic, which has acquired it from a sperm bank, Cryos International enables customers to browse online to choose the donors which suit their needs - essentially shopping for a father.

"I don't like the word father, we call it a donor," says Mr Schou, "But yes, you can choose between the different types of donors and the different qualities."

In some cases, the customer knows who has donated the sperm, although rules determining the identity of the donor vary from country to country.

Sperm is also tested, selected and screened according to different rules.

Standards in the US are determined by the Food and Drug Administration, while in Europe there are the Tissue Directive standards.

"We also have different quality in terms of concentration - the concentration of motile sperm per millilitre after thawing," says Mr Schou.

Prices for 0.5ml of sperm range from $50 (£30) to $500.

Exploitation?

Another, more controversial way, for infertile couples to have a baby is through a surrogate mother.

Sperm from the man can used to fertilise his partner's or a donated egg. A surrogate is then paid to carry the child until it's born.

The practice is not illegal in the UK, but it is restricted by various legal rules which, generally speaking, allow only surrogacy arrangements that are informal and non-commercial.

But in some countries, including India, it is legal and offers poor women an opportunity to make what for them is a large amount of money. But it also raises the question of whether they are being exploited.

On average, a surrogate at the Ak-shanka clinic in Anand in Gujarat state will get $7,500, or up to $10,000 if she is carrying twins.

Surrogacy law in India

The Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ART) Regulation Bill 2010 would mean that:

  • Surrogates will have to be 21-35 years old and can only undergo five live births, including their own children
  • Surrogates will not be allowed to donate their own eggs to a couple and will forego any rights to the child
  • Intended parents will have to be married and prove that surrogacy is permitted in their home country and that the baby has the right to return
  • Gay couples may be prohibited from surrogacy as gay marriage is not recognised in India

On top of that, explains Dr Nayna Patel, who runs the clinic, they will be compensated for not working, and their food and accommodation is paid for during pregnancy.

Surrogates live in a house owned by the clinic throughout the pregnancy, although they can go home for a brief spell or in case of an emergency.

However, Dr Patel points out: "Most of the time we would like them to stay with us, just to take care of their health."

Thought is given to the psychological effects on surrogates who have their babies taken away from them soon after birth. "We never take a surrogate who does not have a living child of her own."

While in the surrogate house, they get lessons like a beautician's course, embroidery, tailoring, and spoken English.

"Even after finishing surrogacy, they come back to the house for the free lessons," says Dr Patel. "If you want to say it's a baby factory, fine. If you want to say that it is helping the women change their lives, it is another way to look at it.

"It could be enough to buy even a house or educate her children. I have records of what the surrogate does with the money - if they buy a house or a piece of land, they give me all the details, the documents, and I think that that is extremely satisfying," she says.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories

RSS

Features

  • NS Savannah, 1962Nuclear dream

    The ship that totally failed to change the world


  • Ed Miliband takes a selfie at a Cambridge hairdressersNo more photo ops?

    Why is Ed Miliband drawing attention to his public image?


  • Espresso cup7 days quiz

    Which city serves the strongest cup of coffee?


  • Glasgow 2014 quaichs and medalsQuaich guide

    What do the Scottish gifts given to Games medallists symbolise?


  • Malaysian plane wreckage in UkraineFlight risk

    How odd is it for three planes to crash in eight days?


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.