Britain's zig-zag economy


When Sir Mervyn King spoke of the "zig-zag" pattern we could expect in 2012, he wasn't wrong.

Official data - and private surveys - have been all over the place lately.

But the underlying message has not changed: the recovery is still fragile, and so is the optimistic mood we have seen in global financial markets since the start of 2012.

The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development does not exactly have a shining record as a forecaster.

When it said recently it expected the UK economy to shrink slightly in the first quarter of 2012, I did wonder whether the downbeat prediction would turn out to be a counter-indicator - a sign that we had definitely avoided a double dip.

And so it proved - at least until Thursday. No sooner had that forecast come out than we had a string of upbeat business surveys suggesting that growth in the first three months of 2012 might be stronger then we thought.

The purchasing managers survey for manufacturing - the PMI - hit a ten-month high in March, and the service sector survey for that month made back nearly all of the fall of the previous month.

On their own, the PMI surveys for the quarter as a whole are pointing to growth of around 0.5% in the first three months of the year.

That's roughly what the Bank of England has been expecting - but significantly above most city forecasts.

But, as the PMI's manufacturing numbers confirm, the picture painted by these private surveys is a good deal stronger than that shown so far by the Office for National Statistics, which highlighted an alarming 1% fall in official manufacturing output in February.

'Best guess'

What are we supposed to conclude from all this?

First, the surveys are unlikely to be completely wrong. When you look back at the past few years, they have been a pretty good guide to where the economy is heading.

However, as Geoffrey Dicks at Novus Capital markets pointed out recently, short-term, the correlation with the official data is pretty weak.

On a month-to-month or quarter-to-quarter basis the surveys are not good at telling us what the ONS will come up with - even if they do tell us which direction the wind is blowing.

Second, the best guess is still that the UK will record very modest growth in the first quarter. But if so it will rely heavily on the relative strength in services.

Weakness in manufacturing and - especially - the construction sector could all too easily mess things up.

But, finally, even if we avoid a technical recession we cannot assume that the second quarter will bring more growth. Indeed, with the extra Bank Holiday the figure could very easily be negative.

Since the autumn of 2010 the UK has shrunk in three quarters and grown in two.

The best guess now is that it will grow slightly in the last quarter, then stagnate or even fall slightly in the spring, before gathering some steam in the second half of the year. But that is all it is - a guess.

UK and global investors seem to believe, among other things that the eurozone crisis is over; that the US economy is back on track for a "typical" recovery; that the price of oil will not seriously disrupt global growth; and that China will engineer a soft landing for its economy.

Even if those brave assumptions turn out to be right, there will surely be plenty more zigs and zags in the UK recovery before 2012 is done.

Stephanie Flanders Article written by Stephanie Flanders Stephanie Flanders Former economics editor

So it's goodbye from me

After 11 years at the BBC, I'm leaving for a new role in the City.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 144.

    #142 me cont.

    no recession, no depression although we are moving lower over time (troughs deeper than intervening peaks)

    Social unrest is the key as this will lower expected asset value returns and will get the banks off the hook.

    There is a plan but you are all looking in the wrong places.

    Oh, and no one is leaving the Euro.

  • rate this

    Comment number 143.

    #131. No_7

    Mornington Crescent was closed for ever and a day.
    Meanwhile it became a radio 4 parlour game.

    It perfectly, perfectly, mimicked the operation of the economy in general.

    Specifically the herd instinct,

    If you haven't listened I recommend it.

    Psychology of the herd instinct par excellence.
    Our future depends on it. Frighting.

  • rate this

    Comment number 142.

    Firstly, it's not Zig & Zag (horizontal), it's zUg & zOg (Up & dOwn, vertical)

    Technical recession = 2Q of zOg
    Technical depression = 9Q of zOg

    I think we will miss Q1/12 zOg by the skin of our teeth (although the fuel purchases brought forward will make no difference)

    Q2/12 will be zOg (quite convincingly)
    Q3/12 zUg (only just)
    Q4/12 zOg (crash!)

    Q1/13 zUg (up from v.low base)

  • rate this

    Comment number 141.

    "UK and global investors seem to believe.. that the eurozone crisis is over"

    look at the level of unemployment in Spain(23.6%) & portugal (15%) (youth unemployment 50.5% & 35.5%) & theres no sign of slowing, having to carry that level of unemployment is unsubstainable & they will have to borrow more. The failed Spanish bond issue should be seen as a warning that the Euro crises is far from over

  • rate this

    Comment number 140.

    135. No_7
    "How can the next boom be engineered without using all those now discredited mechanisms?"
    But there is a boom! Haven't you seen the huge profits and bonuses at the banks?
    Ok, they're robbing savers and pensioners and above all get free wealth in the form of 'QE' or 'welfare for banks' as I call it, but it's still boom time for bankers. Cheers, mine's a double!


Comments 5 of 144



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.