Will there be a British Business Bank?
Vince Cable was over-ruled over a break-up of RBS
So what is the state of play on the government's ambition to correct the perceived lack of credit for small and medium-sized businesses?
Well, the Treasury and the Business Department concede that Vince Cable has been over-ruled on the break-up of Royal Bank of Scotland, which he argued for in the letter I disclosed yesterday.
A Treasury source said: "We have already changed the strategy to radically shrink and de-risk the investment bank (belonging to RBS) and focus on the UK commercial bank. So not very different in practice to Vince's proposal, but we are doing it in a way that doesn't destroy millions of pounds for taxpayers".
Ouch.
As for Mr Cable's colleagues, they insist his proposal for the government to create a new British Business Bank, that would concentrate on lending to smaller businesses, is not dead - although he concedes such a bank will not be created by dismantling RBS.
In that sense, Mr Cable seems to be closer to Labour's leader, Ed Miliband, who is also pushing for such a bank - he calls it a British Investment Bank- than to George Osborne.
Will we ever see such a new state-owned lender?
Well much will depend on whether the Treasury's preferred policy, of getting the current big banks to provide subsidised loans to smaller businesses - through its "credit-easing" policy - is showing that it will have impact.
And we should know more about that in the next few days - when we will learn whether all the banks have signed up for credit easing and whether they do so with great enthusiam for its likely efficacy.
As luck would have it, I am about to board a plane to Germany - whose fearsomely effective Mittelstand manufacturers have the perceived advantage of access to a very supportive banking sector, that takes the long term view of their prospects.
For as long as I can remember, British politicians have bemoaned that the City does not take a Germanic long-term approach to supporting smaller businesses. Will they now despair of the private sector and do it themselves?
~RS~q~RS~~RS~z~RS~58~RS~)




US tornado rescue effort nears end
Smarter future
Light relief
Re-verse
Day in picturess
A leaf from nature's book
Click
Comment number 1.
Just_the_Fax7th March 2012 - 7:08
It is an anathema to Tory dogma to have a state run bank, they closed Girobank as it was too successful (it was). More of the same ideology that caused the mess, privately run financial services have done so so well, obviously it is far better to maintain the status quo and continue to pump billions of pounds of public money into private hands.
What a charade! A disgrace. UK for sale...
Link to this (Comment number 1)
Comment number 2.
Whigerston of the Winter Whigerstons7th March 2012 - 7:36
If banks aren't going to be the ones who will lend to SMEs, then the technologists will. This is the only salvation for anyone in small business; the provision of credit through by disruptive new hybrid tech-finance companies. The banks are dead; long live the bank.
Link to this (Comment number 2)
Comment number 3.
watriler7th March 2012 - 7:48
This role would naturally be performed if RBS were properly nationalised as a strategic policy to provide more competition and to act in the national interest and at the same time provide an exemplar of governance for the whole market including SME's and ordinary customers.
Link to this (Comment number 3)
Comment number 4.
RobHood787th March 2012 - 7:57
It sounds a good idea. BofE acts as lender of last resort to banks but who acts as lender of alst resort to small/medium companies? If they offer non-sexy interest rates, they'll be able to get round EU competition rules. We should also have a national infrastructure bank, to pay for things like crossrail, toll bridges, etc. I'll be waiting a long time me thinks....
Link to this (Comment number 4)
Comment number 5.
James Mansell7th March 2012 - 8:00
What there is in our economy is a shortage of equity which is actually what many of the companies need. To funnel savings and other debt instruments through banks into long term loans to companies isn't going to solve anything. Instead we need to focus on making access to equity finance from business angels and other investment vehicles.
Link to this (Comment number 5)
Comments 5 of 178