Iran oil sanctions divide Asia's four largest economies

US Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner with Chinese Vice Premier Wang Qishan Mr Geithner visited China and Japan in a bid to drum up support for sanctions against Iran

Related Stories

Oil has been one of the most politically sensitive commodities over the years. And now Asia's four largest economies are finding out how difficult it is to balance political will with economic reality.

As the US and European Union move to cut Iran's oil exports, China, Japan, India and South Korea are having to tread the fine line between international relations and national needs.

China, Asia's largest and the world's second-largest economy, is yet to give any hint if it will reduce its imports from Iran, despite a visit by the US Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner to Beijing to discuss the issue.

The signals coming out of India indicate it is keen to continue its relationship with Tehran.

On the other hand, Japan says it will take steps to reduce its reliance on Iranian oil. While South Korea, Asia's fourth-largest economy, is likely to follow suit, despite not having committed to anything as yet.

The difference in their approaches and their respective stands, are likely to have a bearing not just on the oil market but also on the success of the embargoes and their impact on Asia.

"It will really depend on individual countries and how they embrace the European and and the US sanctions," Amrita Sen of Barclays Capital tells the BBC.

'Complex situation'

The main focus is likely to be the stand that China takes on the issue. Beijing is the largest importer of Iranian oil in Asia, accounting for almost 20% of all shipments from Tehran.

Start Quote

We are getting to a point where China is saying enough is enough, we are not going to be a part of this”

End Quote Tony Regan Tri-Zen

Any reduction in that amount is likely to hurt Iran. However, analysts say there is little chance of China making any such move.

"It is a complex situation as there is politics and economics involved," says Stephen Joske of the Economist Intelligence Unit.

"As far as politics is concerned, it was clear during the Arab Spring that China maintains a status quo against the governments in the region," he adds.

"On the economic front, China is far more reliant on imported oil than it has ever been in the past."

China's rapid growth in recent years has seen a surge in demand for oil in the country. Goldman Sachs has forecast that it will become the world's largest importer of oil within the next one-and-a-half years.

It currently imports almost 11% of its oil from Iran and analysts say given the huge domestic demand, it is unlikely that China will reduce the amount.

At the same time, China's political equation with the US may also play a part. Analysts say that Beijing is becoming increasingly wary of being told by the US on how to shape its policies.

"We are getting to a point where China is saying enough is enough, we are not going to be a part of this," says Tony Regan of business consultancy firm Tri-Zen.

'Securing future supplies'

India is also a major importer of Iranian oil in Asia and unlike China, it has far more cordial and closer political relations with the US.

An Iranian worker stands in front of  the South Pars gas field The US has been trying to curb Iran's oil exports which are big source of its national income

However, Indian authorities are more likely to follow Beijing rather than Washington on this issue.

"They are both rising superpowers and both are huge consumers of oil," says Ms Sen of Barclays Capital. "For them price matters and since volumes are huge they don't want to get involved in any such plans."

Ms Sen adds that historically India and Iran have enjoyed good relations and they are likely to continue to do business together.

"This is about securing future supplies," she explains.

Any doubts of which way India may go have been laid to rest after the Indian government said it will send a delegation to Tehran this week to discuss oil supplies and ways in which it can settle payments with the Iranian Central Bank.

Toeing the line?

Start Quote

They will do just enough to show that they have made attempts to reduce these imports and replace them with other sources”

End Quote Victor Shum Purvin & Gertz

The US has found some support from its long standing ally Japan. The Japanese finance minister Jun Azumi, assured Mr Geithner during his visit to Tokyo last week, that it will reduce oil imports from Iran.

At the same time, South Korea's knowledge economy minister Hong Suk-woo has been quoted by the Reuters news agency as saying that though it was too early to say if it would cut imports, Seoul's "basic stance is to co-operate with the US".

Together Japan and South Korea account for more than 20% of Iranian exports and a big reduction from them will have a significant impact.

However, analyst say that despite the rhetoric from both sides, they are unlikely to make drastic changes.

"I don't think they will cut all imports. They will do just enough to show that they have made attempts to reduce these imports and replace them with other sources," Victor Shum of Purvin & Gertz tells the BBC.

"They want to get waivers from the US so that Japanese and Korean companies can keep doing business with Iranian Central Bank," he adds.

Japan's decision will also be influenced by an increased demand for oil after the earthquake and tsunami last year.

The twin disasters resulted in various nuclear power plants being shutdown. As a result utility providers have had to turn to thermal power stations which require oil to operate, resulting in a rise in demand.

The Japanese Prime Minister Yoshihiko Noda has said he will consult the business community before making a final decision on cutting any oil imports from Iran.

So even with the political will to stand by the US and European Union, Tokyo will have to first address the economic realities at home.

Graphic image showing Iran's top oil export destinations

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    ENERGY PROBE 07:40:

    The CMA's probe will see whether energy companies should be wholesalers as well as selling to retail customers (you). The gas market appears to be working better than the electricity market, and they'll try to find out why. They won't be looking at big business customers because that market looks fine, the CMA says.


    Bank of England governor Mark Carney is in all the newspapers today following his speech to the Commonwealth business conference yesterday. The FT interprets Mr Carney's speech as revealing deep concerns about household indebtedness and the effect an interest rate rise will have on households' ability to service their debts.


    Unilever, the food giant, has said first half net profit rose to 3bn euros (£2.37bn) from 2.68bn euros even as sales fell. Its cost savings plan is working well, it said. Excluding businesses sold or otherwise disposed of, sales rose 3.7%.

    SSE logo at the SSE Training Centre in Perth

    SSE and UK Power Networks (IKPN) are to pay an additional £3.3m for delays in getting power back up and running to households in southern England following last winter's storms. That's on top of the £4.7m the two energy companies are paying out to customers under guaranteed standards and in goodwill payments. It brings the total paid out by the two companies to £8m.

    ENERGY PROBE 07:04: Breaking News

    The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) will carry out an independent investigation to see if there are any features of the energy market which "prevent, restrict or distort competition and, if so, what action might be taken to remedy them," it says. It will report back by Christmas day 2015.

    INTEREST RATES 06:56: Radio 5 live

    Kathleen Brooks of thinks January will be the time for a rate increase from the Bank of England. Maybe a 25 basis point increase to 0.75%, she says. Bank governor, Mark Carney, said yesterday there may be more labour supply than previously thought. Wages growth is thus being held back.

    RUSSIAN SANCTIONS 06:44: BBC Radio 4
    Russian President Vladimir Putin

    Kathleen Brooks has now popped up on the Today programme. She says sanctions against Russia "are toothless at this point....Russia has a lot of energy that the West wants." She adds divisions in the West over energy policy have been exposed by the fact "the UK and France have a spat about sanctions and that just plays into Vladimir Putin's hands." Ms Brooks says there have "also been rumours that Russia has been unofficially propping up the rouble. The sanctions are not going to hurt the European Union's energy links to Russia."

    ENERGY PRICES 06:31: Radio 5 live

    If you have to steel yourself with a nice cup of sweet tea before opening your latest energy bill, spare a thought for Nigel and Linda Brotherton, who were told by Npower that their monthly direct debit was going to increase from £87 to £53,480,062. Npower has apologised and the incorrect bill has been cancelled. "It's a massive shock," he tells 5 live.

    GLAXOSMITHKLINE 06:24: Radio 5 live

    David Buik of Panmure Gordon is helping us digest the GlaxoSmithKline results on 5 live. "Sales to China is only about 3% of its total business," and so the bribery scandal there is an unwelcome distraction.

    ROUBLE 06:15: Radio 5 live

    Kathleen Brooks of is on 5 live talking about Russia. The Russia rouble has been "resilient" bearing in mind the new sanctions against Russia. "They are able to shrug off geopolitical risk quite quickly," she says. President Putin may be "breathing a sigh of relief," she adds.

    POUND 06:01: Radio 5 live

    The pound buys about 1.27 euros, its strongest in nearly two years - don't get excited that's not what you'll get from your local foreign exchange. Still, Kathleen Brooks, a research director at, is on 5 live talking about it. The strong pound has helped ease inflation, she says. "Over the period of the financial crisis we had sky high inflation," she adds. The recovery is consumer-driven, which is aided by a stronger pound, which means cheaper imports.

    06:00: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning! Get in touch via email at or on twitter @BBCBusiness

    06:00: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Good morning folks. So what's new? Facebook has posted some stonking profits for its second quarter, the US has - just - lifted its ban on flights into Tel Aviv and it's Thursday, so General Motors has decided to recall another couple of hundred thousand cars overnight. There's plenty more to come, stay with us.



  • Shinji Mikamo's father's watchTime peace

    The story of the watch that survived Hiroshima

  • A man hangs a Catalan flag at his balcony near Barcelona in 2013Caledonia homage

    Who are the Europeans with an eye on the Scottish referendum?

  • Elephant Diaries - BBCGoing wild

    Wildlife film-makers reveal the tricks of the trade

  • Hamas rally in the West Bank village of Yatta, 2006Hamas hopes

    Why the Palestinian group won't back down yet

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.