S&P’s logical but tactless eurozone warning

The Standard and Poor's sign Standard and Poor's has not endeared itself to EU leaders

The reasons given by Standard and Poor's for warning that it may downgrade the credit ratings of all but one of the eurozone's member governments - the exception being Greece, which already has an exceptionally low junk rating - are in a sense uncontroversial.

As the leading ratings agency points out, eurozone banks have been struggling to borrow, a number of eurozone economies are buckling under the burden of big government and household debts, there is a significant risk of recession, there is a bitter dispute between eurozone leaders about how best to help governments finding it hard to obtain loans, and investors are in general increasingly wary of lending to the eurozone's public sector.

And, as it happens, the best and most sophisticated arguments for downgrading the ratings of all eurozone governments, under the current constitutional arrangements for the currency union, were made in a recent speech by the chairman of the Financial Services Authority, Adair Turner (see my post, The eurozone's borrowing costs may stay lethally high).

It is the timing that is so controversial of announcements that the six financially strongest eurozone governments, including Germany and France, could lose their AAA ratings, and 10 others could see their ratings reduced by relatively more.

It comes just as France and Germany reach an agreement intended to subject all eurozone countries to stricter disciplines on what they borrow - and only days before a European Union summit that's intended to come up with a proper solution to the eurozone's crisis.

S&P says it wants eurozone leaders to understand how much is at stake if this week's summit is another damp squib. But if its actions were to set off a panic that were, for example, to tip a bank over the edge, it could be accused of destabilising attempts to reform the eurozone in an orderly way.

Update 08:15, 6 December: As expected, the government bond prices of Italy and Spain have given up some of the gains they made yesterday - so the implicit borrowing costs for these governments has risen.

There has also been weakness in the bond prices of the governments, including Germany and France, in danger of losing their cherished AAA status

That said, as of first thing the influence of S&P has been limited: the borrowing cost for Italy, for example, is still around a percentage point below that penal and unaffordable 7% threshold that it was actually forced to pay recently.

This limited reaction is what you would expect: S&P's analysis is backward-looking, identifying the structural weaknesses in the currency union that have been conspicuous to investors for months and which the eurozone's leaders are trying to solve.

To put it another way, S&P cannot make or break the eurozone; only eurozone governments can do that. And we'll have a better idea by the end of the week whether those governments will go down in history as redeemers or destroyers.

Robert Peston, economics editor Article written by Robert Peston Robert Peston Economics editor

This column...

This column may be a bit quiet for a bit, because I am away from the office.

Read full article

More on This Story

Global Economy


Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    As Paxman put it "Who ARE these people?".

    More importantly, in whose interests do they operate, who elects them and why do they feel they can tell the democratically elected leaders of the world how they should run their countries?

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    Whose interests do these agencies represent?

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    Well, you have to go through the motions, even if your credibility is totally shredded. I still haven't got the impression that Merkel and Sarkosy have actually achieved anything.They're talking philosophy and everyone else is into 'brass tacks'. It is kind of weird, like an acid trip (not that I would know what that is like, oh no) but everything is kinda 'relative' or 'astral'.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    BBC & Northern Rock?

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    Before we start singing Beethoven's Ode to Joy, and wrapping ourselves in the Euro flag, S&P give a timely reminder that the Merkozy Plan is just another exercise in can kicking and the fundamentals are the same. EZ banks, many EZ countries (and the UK) are bust, insolvent, finished and there ain't enough credit in the rest of the EU to save us. This is the beginning of something epochal.


Comments 5 of 359


This entry is now closed for comments


  • Alana Saarinen at pianoMum, Dad and Mum

    The girl with three biological parents

  • Polish and British flags alongside British roadsideWar debt

    Does the UK still feel a sense of obligation towards Poles?

  • Islamic State fighters parade in Raqqa, Syria (30 June 2014)Who backs IS?

    Where Islamic State finds support to become a formidable force

  • Bride and groom-to-be photographed underwaterWetted bliss

    Chinese couples told to smile, but please hold your breath

  • A ship is dismantled for scrap in the port city of Chittagong, BangladeshDangerous work

    Bangladesh's ship breakers face economic challenge

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.