The price of Greek democracy

 

The Greek prime minister's decision to give his voters the final say in a referendum has sent the markets reeling

It is easy to see why the Greek premier has announced a parliamentary confidence vote and plebiscite on the eurozone's latest bailout package.

He presumably takes the view that there is almost no chance of Greece going back to work unless and until the Greek people publicly endorse his and the eurozone's economic recovery plan.

If that plan is to be effective, it would impose major sacrifices on most Greeks, in the form of serious cuts in public services, higher taxes, a raised pension age and - perhaps most seriously - years of declining real wages.

But without the approval of the Greek people, without an end to crippling pervasive strikes, how on earth could this austerity be followed by economic recovery?

So although Mr Papandreou's decision to hold a referendum has shocked investors and eurozone leaders, to criticise him would be to argue both that democracy is a bad thing and (many would say naively) that a Greek revival could be possible in the teeth of opposition from Greek people.

Which brings us to what matters for the rest of us - what chance that the Greeks will vote yes to the rescue package?

Opinion polls wouldn't suggest there's a high probability of Mr Papandreou winning the day. But views can change.

What's in it for the Greek people? Well, their country is to receive an additional 100bn euro of bailout loans, so that it can continue to pay its bills. And there is a non-binding agreement with banks to cut what the Greek government has to repay them by half.

Why do countries go bust?

But this rescue package will deliver only a modest reduction in the back-achingly heavy burden of Greek indebtedness.

Even if all goes to plan in a fiscal sense - and it hasn't done that in Greece for years - the ratio of public-sector debt to GDP in Greece would still be 120% in 2020.

Which is still a good 20 percentage points above the ratio considered the upper limit for what would allow private sector and economy to thrive.

Or to put it another way, the rescue does not promise a bright new dawn for Greece any time soon. Or to put it another way, the only way for the referendum to be won by Mr Papandreou would be for him to demonstrate that the alternatives are far worse.

For the rest of the world, those alternatives look shockingly bad.

They could include, in no particular order of probability or potentially devastating impact on the stability of financial market, default by Greece, exit by Greece from the eurozone or a much more generous rescue deal.

Let's examine these.

A decision by the Greek government to renege on all its debts would impose huge losses on European banks, the European central banks and European taxpayers.

Such a default would raise the spectre of default by other over-indebted eurozone governments, which in turn would undermine the perceived solvency of some very big banks. We could be back in the territory of paralysis of the European financial system.

Or Greece might decide to quit the eurozone, so that the exchange rate would be able to fall to a level that would allow the Greek private sector to compete.

This could have the spurious attraction that it would mitigate the ostensible fall in Greek wages necessary for recovery.

But its impact on markets could be even worse than a default, it could be a default on steroids: if it became accepted that membership of the eurozone isn't forever, huge doubts would arise about the true value of hundreds of billions of euros of contracts.

All that said, it is possible that under threat of a no vote, eurozone governments could sweeten the rescue package. This would force banks to write off more of what they're owed and would impose losses on public-sector lenders to Greece, including the European Central Bank.

This might be the least worst option, but it would be painful for eurozone taxpayers and banks.

Unsurprisingly, therefore, European stock markets have tumbled - and shares in big banks are down around 10% or so.

All or any of these frightening scenarios would make it harder and more expensive for European banks to borrow - which has negative implications for European economic recovery and (in a worst case) could see a few banks falling over.

Nor is it especially comforting that Mr Papandreou's government could tumble before a referendum. Any immediate general election would be the equivalent of a plebiscite on the bailout deal, and would therefore be just as destabilising to markets.

All that said, last week's eurozone rescue package could unravel long before political events in Greece take their course.

All the uncertainty has again depressed the price of Italian government bonds, pushing up the interest rate which Italy has to pay to borrow to punitive and dangerous levels.

The gap between the interest rate paid by Italy and by Germany to borrow for 10 years is approaching an astonishing 4.5 percentage points - which, with Italian government debt equivalent to more than 120% of GDP, means Italy could find itself in a vicious spiral of debt-induced economic contraction.

A price is already being extracted by investors for the refusal of Germany to allow the eurozone's bailout fund to expand its resources to much more than a trillion euros, just about enough to refinance the maturing debts of Italy and Spain for a year or so, and provide a bit of support to banks and other financially challenged governments.

In other words, the putative remedy for the eurozone that was negotiated just five days ago in such dramatic circumstance - and which was supposed to be the definitive and final word on the subject - is in danger of disintegrating even before it goes before leaders of the G20 most powerful economies on Thursday and Friday for their blessing.

 
Robert Peston Article written by Robert Peston Robert Peston Economics editor

Froth gone from UK recovery

The UK recovery has past its peak, but growth remains better than major competitors

Read full article

More on This Story

Global Economy

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 18.

    Re No 6
    Perhaps they think the euro has lost its smarkle!

  • Comment number 17.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • rate this
    +25

    Comment number 16.

    If only this crisis had been better managed.

    There is a limit to what people will, or can tolerate. The gross unfairness in the system is plain for all to see. Until that is addressed, a genuine collective response to our economic problems is unlikely.

    A little democracy now would be a good thing.

  • rate this
    +8

    Comment number 15.

    Some may argue , this is all part of a bigger play to get extra cash / concessions out of the Euro countries, but the reality is Greece can't proceed in any direction , unless there is some broad agreement on the way forward. I would fear for Greece in the medium term if a general election was called instead , which would only muddy the Euro membership issue.

  • rate this
    +20

    Comment number 14.

    This is what happens when you condemn 11 million people to decades of abject poverty WITHOUT CONSULTING THEM.

    "Any immediate general election would be the equivalent of a plebiscite on the bailout deal"

    Not really. As the Greeks have already discovered when they threw out the last lot, they can't trust any of the politicians. In a referendum, their views aren't "interpreted" - they're clear!

  • rate this
    +8

    Comment number 13.

    If i have a 100 quid and I give you 10 and don't pay it back the other 90 is still worth the same. So why if Greece does not pay it back would the Euro be worth any less???
    Given that let Greece default the only losers will be those who lent money to Greece. So what is the problem?? Let Greece default and the badly run banks collapse.

  • rate this
    +9

    Comment number 12.

    Clearly the Greek people are going to vote not to pay back 100% of what they owe rather than voting to attempt to pay back 50% of an impossible amount just to bail out bankers again.

    They will vote to share what true wealth they have more fairly and efficiently.

    First domino to fall.

  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 11.

    It's curious that just after Merkel and Sarkozy talked to each other and then Papandreou... that Greek politicans started rebelling.

    It's just possible that democracy as a concept within the Euro area inparticular and the EU in general, died today.

  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 10.

    "...the putative remedy for the eurozone that was negotiated just five days ago...is in danger of disintegrating even before it goes before leaders of the G20 most powerful economies..."

    I am so glad that Robert has not run out of things to say about this nonsense because, I for one, am TOTALY SPEECHLESS!!! :-S

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 9.

    It demonstrates the ultimate self defeating effect of the absurd austerity the E/zone expected the Greeks to shoulder. Even with a yes vote there will continue to be major social turbulence and political instability and yet there is every likelihood that the additional austerity will add to Greece's insolvency not reduce it. Who's next for a Merkel lashing?

  • rate this
    +11

    Comment number 8.

    ...coming to a bankrupt nation near you.

    Also it seems that Portugal, Ireland and Spain have all requested concessions from the EU - like Greece had.

    It was obvious this was going to happen - so much so I said it last Thursday.

    The cards are toppling, as soon as the other PIIGS see a chink of light they will rush the door.

    ...and chaos will reign.

  • rate this
    +17

    Comment number 7.

    sotos_68 (No. 3) The previous Conservative government deliberately lied about the scale of the Greek budget deficit. Do you really want them back in power?

  • rate this
    +25

    Comment number 6.

    I wonder if Murkle and Sarko are smirking now

  • rate this
    +17

    Comment number 5.

    The clear risk here is now the Italian bond mountain. One of the weaknesses of the EU is that what is good or needed practically for Greece - is not good for the rest. If the markets do not judge the governments serious, the contagion will spread and I am then afraid Greece will just be forced out anyway amid a greater break up of the currency.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 4.

    Mr Papandreou's decision to hold a referendum is pointless unless it includes the 2 additional questions asking the Greek people do they want to remain in the euro and do they want to remain in the EU.

  • rate this
    +5

    Comment number 3.

    Papandreou eventually went back to the gambler's streak which characterises his political family, but he's down to his luck. The Greek people do not want referendums (specifically prohibited by the constitution, when dealing with fiscal matters); they want elections to get rid of this inept government. They will soon get their wish.

  • rate this
    +6

    Comment number 2.

    I told you in the previous blog - markets DON'T LIKE DEMOCRACY - they prefer stability and austerity oppression so they get their pound of flesh.

    Which clown associated markets with freedom eh? - sold a lie were you?

    Told the market is free and there to serve us all?

    What a crock you fell for - never mind, maybe you'll learn from this experience

  • rate this
    +74

    Comment number 1.

    Let's just get the defaults over with, all this can kicking is making it worse and adding to the uncertainty. Greece is bust, they won't pay any money back, nor will they grow again with so much debt.

 

Page 18 of 18

 

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.