Eurozone leaders begin crunch debt talks

Nicolas Sarkozy and Angela Merkel in Berlin. 20 July 2011 Angela Merkel wants private investors to share taxpayers' burden if Greece restructures its debts

Eurozone leaders have begun delicate negotiations to agree further help for Greece and prevent other economies from being dragged into the debt crisis.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel and French President Nicolas Sarkozy have agreed a common stance, but details of the deal have not yet been released.

Comments from the Dutch finance minister suggest the plan may include restructuring Greece's debts.

Whether they can convince the rest of the eurozone remains unclear.

Jan Kees de Jager said a so-called selective default on Greece's debts was "potentially inevitable".

He said French objections to such a default had been "swept under the table", according to the AP news agency.

There are also indications that a new tax on Europe's banks to help fund any new aid packages may not be part of any eurozone deal.

Arriving at the summit, the head of the Eurogroup of finance ministers, Jean-Claude Juncker, played down the idea of a bank tax.

"I do not think there will be an agreement on that subject," he said.

Germany has long insisted that private lenders to Greece should be forced to take losses as part of any further rescue deal for Athens.

One major bond investor, the German insurance giant Allianz, has called for a restructuring of Greek bonds into centrally backed European bonds, in return for investors accepting a 30% loss on their bond investments.

But the suggestion that private investors should suffer losses has been opposed by France and the European Central Bank, which fear it could spark a Europe-wide banking crisis, push Spain and possibly Italy into trouble, and even jeopardise the solvency of the ECB itself.

Start Quote

It is an unusual moment when British politicians, more than the Germans, are urging closer European integration ”

End Quote

Meanwhile, new figures from Markit's PMI survey show that the eurozone's private sector grew at its weakest pace in almost two years in July, recording a score of 50.8, down from 53.3 in June. Any score above 50 indicates growth.

"The eurozone recovery lost almost all of its momentum in July," said Markit's chief economist Chris Williamson.

Also on Thursday, Spain was forced to pay a higher rate of interest to borrow money from international investors. Madrid had to offer a yield of 5.9% on 10-year bonds, up from 5.4% at a similar auction last month, in order to raise 1.8bn euros ($2.6bn; £1.6bn).

'Very serious'

Policymakers are discussing a range of measures at the summit in Brussels, including a new loan package to Greece and the role of private investors in any debt restructuring.

Start Quote

Nobody should be under any illusion; the situation is very serious”

End Quote Jose Manuel Barroso European Commission President

But German Chancellor Angela Merkel has cautioned against over optimism.

Greece received its first aid package in May last year, but the debt crisis continues to undermine confidence in global financial markets, with some commentators suggesting it threatens the future of the euro itself.

Politicians and investors are calling for decisive action to help bring the crisis to an end.

"Nobody should be under any illusion; the situation is very serious," European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso said on Wednesday.

"It requires a response. Otherwise, the negative consequences will be felt in all corners of Europe and beyond."

Debt to GDP ratios

  • Greece 142.8%
  • Italy 119%
  • Belgium 96.8%
  • Ireland 96.2%
  • Portugal 93%
  • Germany 83.2%
  • France 81.7%
  • Spain 60.1%

Source: Eurostat. Government debt expressed as a percentage of economic output.

The Governor of the Bank of England, Sir Mervyn King, has said that the crisis in the eurozone posed the most serious and immediate risk to the UK's financial system.

President Barack Obama has also weighed in, calling Mrs Merkel on Tuesday night to stress the importance of tackling the debt crisis in sustaining the global economic recovery.

The International Monetary Fund has also called on European leaders to take swift and decisive action.

Delaying such action further would be "very costly" for the world economy, it said.

Spending cuts

However, there are divisions among policymakers about the best way to resolve the crisis.

There appears to be consensus on the need for a new loan agreement, analysts say, thought to be similar in size to the 110bn euro ($156bn; £97bn) package agreed last year.

However, there is also a growing consensus that this will merely act as a sticking plaster, and that the fundamental problem of Greece's indebtedness needs to be addressed.

Athens has already implemented a raft of wide ranging austerity measures, including spending cuts and tax rises, and earlier this month agreed to further drastic action to cut its debt.

Bank tax

Start Quote

There will thus be great relief that this half-baked [bank tax] proposal appears to have been dropped”

End Quote

But there is a growing sense that these will not be enough. The only way to resolve the problem is to restructure Greece's debts, many observers argue.

Germany has proposed allowing Athens more time to repay, effectively rolling over existing debts into new bonds.

It wants private investors, largely banks, to participate in this restructuring.

But the European Central Bank has strongly opposed this plan, arguing that such a rollover would constitute a default in the eyes of the international credit ratings agencies and, as such, would undermine investor confidence and the euro itself.

It is these divisions that explain Mrs Merkel's attempts to dampen expectations ahead of the summit.

Countries most exposed to Greek debt

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 314.

    It is possible to be pro Europe and be anti EU.

    The EU is increasingly becoming an undemocratic, self serving bureaucracy, completely out of touch with Europeans.

    Once again I say, it is not Europe that is the problem, it is the Institution called the EU.

    It needs wholesale reform and the eventual demise of the Eurozone as currently constituted will be the catalyst of this.

  • rate this

    Comment number 250.

    Notwithstanding that 10 economists in a room will have 11 different views, there are some basics that few will argue, in particular that one cannot continue to spend more than one earns (Mr Macawber recognised this a long time ago!). Sustaining the euro, and Greece, is all about politics, but in the end economics will prevail . . . and something will go bang! Greece, other PIIGS, the euro . . .

  • rate this

    Comment number 178.

    The constant refrain of the 'prop up the Euro at all costs' brigade is that, as we conduct a significant proportion of our trade with the Eurozone, we are in some way impelled to contribute financially towards a solution.
    Market economies MUST face the full moral hazard of poor management or the whole problem is merely shifted down to a deeper and even more potentially damaging structural level.

  • rate this

    Comment number 123.

    What people still do not realise is that YES money goes OUT to the EU but much more money comes IN from the EU in forms of grants and project funding etc
    In a RADICAL europhobe scenario; the UK would grind to a halt if the euro went down. we don't have to adopt the euro to be affected by it.

    Plus many companies in the UK export to the EU, which is the BEST thing for the economy = MONEY IN

  • rate this

    Comment number 59.

    I accept the health of the eurozone has a direct effect on our economy & we cannot ignore what is happening elsewhere in the EU. That being so why are we so opposed to being in the euro & at the same time giving billions of pound we dont have to aid troubled EU nations. This where we have no say in the control or managment of the eurozone. We dont want it but have to accomodate the consequences?


Comments 5 of 10


More Business stories



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.