Greece: Eurozone ministers delay decision on vital loan

 
People outside the parliament building in Athens protest against any further budget cuts (19 June 2011) Many Greeks are opposed to further cuts, which the government says are absolutely crucial

Eurozone finance ministers have postponed their decision on a 12bn-euro ($17bn; £10bn) loan to Greece until it introduces further austerity measures.

The ministers said they expected to pay the latest tranche of a much larger aid package by mid-July.

But its release depends on the Greek government surviving a vote of confidence on Tuesday.

Parliament then must also pass 28bn euros worth of new spending cuts and economic reforms.

This latest tranche - of a 110bn-euro European Union and International Monetary Fund aid package - is crucial as Greece needs the aid by July to pay off the creditors of its huge debts.

But there are also practical questions about whether the country can implement the reforms being demanded in return.

Greeks have already seen wages and pensions cut and there have been regular, mass demonstrations - even riots - in protest.

Start Quote

Letting Greece default in a disorderly, uncontrolled way would probably be a good deal worse for the global economy than Lehman's collapse”

End Quote

The latest public opposition to the cutbacks involves Greek workers at the state-owned electricity company, who are on the first day of a 48-hour strike.

Privatisation fears

After a seven-hour meeting in Luxembourg that ended early on Monday, the finance ministers said they would not approve the disbursement to Greece of the 12bn euros (8.7bn euros from eurozone governments and 3.3bn euros from the IMF) until the country's parliament passed the fiscal strategy and privatisation laws.

Asked how Greece could privatise a large state-controlled company every 10 days, as the current plans envision, Luxembourg Prime Minister Jean-Claude Juncker replied: "They will have to do so."

"This is something that affects me greatly," said Mr Juncker, who also chairs the meetings of the 17 eurozone finance ministers. "You look at the reaction of the people on the streets. You see they are rebelling."

The EU's economic and monetary affairs commissioner Olli Rehn said he was "certain that Greece will be able to take the decisions needed because the alternative is so much worse".

Greek bail-out timeline

  • May 2010: EU and IMF agree bail-out package to prevent Greece defaulting on its debts; in return, Greece agrees to make 30bn euros of budget cuts over the next three years
  • February 2011: EU and IMF experts tell Greece it must make further cuts to keep recovery on track
  • April 2011: EU figures reveal Greek deficit revised up to 10.5% of GDP, worse than previously thought
  • May 2011: Greece begins privatisation programme but is warned the IMF may not release more funds as Athens cannot guarantee it will remain solvent for next 12 months

The IMF said in a report that the eurozone's prospects depended on Greece and other bailed-out members righting their economies.

"A broadly sound recovery continues, but the sovereign crisis in the periphery threatens to overwhelm this favourable outlook," the body said.

In an effort to get the bills passed in parliament, the Greek prime minister last week reshuffled his cabinet, including appointing a new finance minister: Evangelos Venizelos.

"We have plenty to do, on a daily basis," Mr Venizelos said. "The political time has been compressed a lot. Each day is of extreme importance and hence we cannot afford to waste a single hour."

The government faces a vote of confidence on Tuesday but opposition parties are split over how to cut the country's growing budget deficit.

"In light of the government's thin majority of currently only four votes, support of the Greek parliament for more austerity measures is far from certain," said Tobias Blattner, a former European Central Bank economist who works at Daiwa.

New aid

A new bail-out package about the same size as the first was also agreed in principle by EU finance ministers on Sunday.

The new aid package, to be outlined by early July, will include loans from other eurozone countries.

It is also expected to feature a voluntary contribution from private investors, who will be invited to buy up new Greek bonds as old ones mature.

Mr Juncker said that money had to be freely given - or it would be seen as a technical default on debt repayments: "It is absolutely clear that no pressure will be put on the financial institutions, so as to avoid a Greek selective default. Voluntary means voluntary."

If Greece were to default - or seen to be in default - it would mean massive losses for European banks that hold Greek debt, including the European Central Bank.

Officials said the new plan was expected to fund Greece into late 2014 and total about 120bn euros.

Inspectors for the EU and IMF will make another visit to Athens on Tuesday in what the European Commission said would be a "technical mission".

The visit, which comes after teams from both bodies have spent months poring through the country's accounts, is unscheduled and the Commission did not say what its objective would be.

Stock markets and the euro fell early on Monday, pressured by the lack of resolution to the Greek crisis.

Leading indexes in Frankfurt, Paris and London were all down around 1% and the euro lost 0.5% against the US dollar in early trading, but stock markets and the euro later recovered to show only minor falls.

Countries most expose to Greek debt
 

More on This Story

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +16

    Comment number 148.

    Greece needs to default NOW and begin the long and painful task of rebuilding a shattered economy.
    Any additional loans added onto an already insurmountable debt mountain will just compound the problem!
    Their economy is tiny in comparison to the amount of money they owe already and its shrinking at an alarming rate,how can anybody suggest that more debt is the answer?

  • rate this
    +15

    Comment number 141.

    This whole situation is inevitable when you have monetary union without political union.

    Therefore, looking at the big picture, there are only two long-term solutions; a partial break-up of the eurozone, or closer political integration (federalism). Since there is no appetite for the later, then the eurozone will probably see a partial break up at some point in the future.

  • rate this
    +5

    Comment number 140.

    The Greeks cannot escape from cuts by defaulting, however much they want to. The 10.5% deficit means the government is still spending much more than receives, which means they are still borrowing money on top of their existing debts. If they default, no-one will lend Greece money again and they'll have to make the cuts anyway - probably faster and deeper. In short: you can't win.

  • rate this
    +6

    Comment number 66.

    Re Comment 37. I stand to be corrected, but I belive Germany officially repaid the last of her 'war debt' in 2009. Ther Germans were uncomfortable with Greece joining the Euro from the outset, as they were with other less stable economies. Looks like Angie was right all along. Unfortunately they are now being 'forced' to bail out the Euro, once again. Surpirsed they are still members.

  • rate this
    +25

    Comment number 63.

    This is nothing to do with saving Greece. It is to do with politicians wanting to keep their failed EU dream alive.

    The Euro has rules to prevent massive debt levels - why have these not been enforced?

    The Greek people should not accept being sold down the river and should force a bankruptcy.

    It may be painful but at least it will clear the slate and prevent the pain lasting for generations.

 

Comments 5 of 7

 

More Business stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • MercedesStory of the S-Class

    Mercedes-Benz has been producing the model since 1972. BBC Autos looks back at its history

Programmes

  • The night sky in ChileFast Track Watch

    Stargazing in Chile – visit the best place on earth to see the heavens above

BBC © 2013 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.