China's new economic power fans fear, BBC poll finds

Yuan notes The value of China's currency is a major source of concern for many nations

Public concern is growing about China's economic power, according to a poll conducted for the BBC World Service.

The survey was carried out by the international polling firm GlobeScan/PIPA among more than 28,000 people in 27 countries.

It reveals that the respondees who say that China becoming more powerful economically is a bad thing have increased substantially.

The concerns are found across a number of China's key trading partners.

They are especially prominent among wealthier nations.

Compared to BBC World Service polling in 2005, negative views of China's growing economic power rose - and are now in the majority - in the US, France, Canada, Germany and Italy.

Negative views also grew significantly in countries such as the UK and Mexico but remain outnumbered by positive views in those countries.

But across the survey as a whole, China was still viewed positively.

Across all countries polled, an average of 50% expressed a positive view of China's economic power, while 33% were negative.

The two nations with the most positive views of China's economic growth were in Africa - Nigeria (82%) and Kenya (77%).

Indeed positive views were in the majority in all five African countries surveyed.

Across the developing nations polled, positive views of China were more numerous than negative ones - with the exception of just one country, Mexico.

'Psychologically unsettling'

Watch Eric Schmidt, chairman of China Entrepreneurs in Beijing, talks about China's growing economic might.

So what is behind these feelings about China's growing economic weight?

The survey does not tell us for sure, but there are some obvious candidate explanations.

In the period since the earlier poll - in 2005 - the world has been through an episode called the great recession, a result of the financial crisis.

The developed world was hard hit. The rebound now underway in the global economy is led by developing countries, notably China.

The recovery in the rich nations by contrast is more sluggish. The rise in unemployment caused by the recession is likely to take years to reverse.

Tom Friedman, the influential New York Times columnist and Pullitzer Prize winner, told the BBC: "there's no question that China's rise, coinciding with a sense of stagnation and paralysis among many of the leading western democracies, is psychologically unsettling".

Trade issues

Start Quote

China is still in many ways a freeloader on the international system. It's not a stakeholder.”

End Quote Tom Friedman New York Times

There is also a very specific economic issue, and that does emerge in the BBC survey.

People were asked if they think China trades fairly with other countries.

Those saying China is unfair were above 50% in Japan, South Korea, Germany and Italy. In the US, the figure was 45%, compared with 24% saying that it was fair.

The particular policy that has attracted so much attention, in the media and in business, is China's approach to its currency, holding its value down by intervening in the foreign exchange market.

Critics, and there are many of them, say that gives Chinese industry an unfair competitive advantage.

Tom Friedman is particularly caustic about this policy: "That's part of a broader concern of people which is that China is still in many ways a freeloader on the international system. It's not a stakeholder."

Regional view

Watch Victor Wang from Macquarie Bank talk about China's banking sector.

And what about the more positive view in the developing world?

In some countries especially in Africa, China has been investing heavily.

That brings jobs and infrastructure, though critics do see it as a grab for African resources, especially its energy and metals.

Perhaps some also welcome the sight of a developing nation emerging as an increasingly serious challenger to the rich world.

In some business circles, even among those who criticise China's policies, many nonetheless see the country as an opportunity.

More than a billion consumers are going to buy more goods and services as their living standards rise and Chinese firms will not be able to supply everything.


More on This Story

Global Economy


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 23.

    China's rise seems inevitable - a huge domestic market, a successful state capitalist model, a hard-working people. And another competitor is always a challenge for people to adapt to. More worryingly is that the new emergent China will seek to play a global role akin to the USA, which from a country with substantially less respect for human rights is worrying.

  • rate this

    Comment number 19.

    I find it kinda strange at the view that China's dominance is inevitable, when people aren't looking at the greater issues that come into play. China is a great manufacturer but a terrible innovator. It's well known that China mostly takes current ideas and then finds a way to make a cheap version. To really dominate, they need to learn to properly make innovative products and ideas - Not easy...

  • rate this

    Comment number 14.

    There's a lot of hypocrisy in the 'western' media around China's growth. They're condemned for doing many of the same things that the US and UK do. When they invest in Africa and do deals, it's a 'grab for African resources', whereas we do it for noble motives and it's obviously not a 'grab'. They 'interfere' in other countries, while we are 'forced to intervene'.

  • rate this

    Comment number 7.

    I think this is being viewed the wrong way by a lot of people. China has a huge population, many of whom will be lifted out of poverty with their economic rise. Its the same in India. Media induced paranoia about a challenge to western domination really misses the point.

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    I understand that China's expanding economy, communist ideals, huge army and human rights violations are potentially very worrying aspects, but the trade relations between the West and China mean that at the moment we need one another, and that's a definite improvement over the relations the West had with the previous eastern superpower.


More Business stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.