Budget 2011: How the fuel duty cut is funded

Man filling petrol The chancellor's efforts will not stop prices at the pump from rising

Chancellor George Osborne's move to cut fuel duty was well heralded, but it is not the fuel duty stabiliser he spoke about in opposition.

Instead he has introduced a less effective stabiliser - one that will cost him less.

Under the announced changes, the cost of fuel will not be kept the same regardless of fluctuating oil prices.

The chancellor admitted he could not simply raise and lower taxes to ensure this, since doing so would be too costly.

Instead, Mr Osborne will follow Gordon Brown in raising the supplementary charge on the North Sea oil industry whilst the price of oil remains above $75.

This will raise some £2bn ($3.3bn), which can be used to fund the 1p fuel duty cut, along with a postponement of a 4p inflation-linked cut.

This total decrease in the planned fuel duty of around 5p in real terms will come into effect at 1800GMT on Wednesday.

If the price of oil falls below $75, however, the fuel duty goes back up and the tax on oil companies back down.

Oil money

The fall in fuel duty is not as generous as it first seems when taking into account the 2.5 percentage points increase in tax on petrol that accompanied the VAT rise from 17.5% to 20% in January.


PDF download Budget 2011[1.1 MB]

Most computers will open PDF documents automatically, but you may need Adobe Reader

And the fuel duty will continue to rise with inflation, although this year's 4p increase is now delayed until January and the next planned inflation-linked rise will be delayed until the following summer.

Moreover, as the price of oil rises, so will the tax the government receives from the North Sea oil companies.

In the short term, the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) and the National Institute of Economic and Social Research (NIESR) estimate that every £10 increase in the price of oil equates to around £2.5bn extra for the exchequer.

That is the money that Mr Osborne had initially hoped he would be able to use to cut the price at the pump by varying taxes.

Start Quote

Motoring costs should fall for families and businesses as a result of fuel duty changes announced in the Budget”

End Quote

But the OBR warned that this extra income would be offset by money lost in other taxes.

High oil prices make it more expensive for companies to do business - driving down profits, wages and the taxes paid by companies and employees not involved in North Sea oil.

The OBR forecasts that over the first year a £20 increase in the cost of oil would cost more than £3bn in lost revenue.

Then there is the impact of inflation - currently at more than double the target.

This pushes up interest on government debt and the costs of some benefits, more than £1bn, according to the independent forecaster.

All in all, the OBR and NIESR both conclude that over the first year the government will gain very little from a rising oil price.

New tax

Instead, the chancellor has increased a supplementary tax on oil companies from 20 to 32% - following on from Labour's 2002 increase.

Start Quote

If the likes of Shell and BP don't complain that this will undermine their efforts to squeeze the last drop of oil and gas out of the North Sea for the benefit of the UK, I will drink a litre of their finest unleaded petrol”

End Quote

It means oilfields in the UK are now taxed at between 60% and 85%, depending on their age.

The new tax will raise about £2bn in extra revenue.

The OBR calculated that each cut in fuel duty of 1p costs about £500m.

And because the cuts are not all coming in at once, it allows the chancellor to fund the cuts announced in the Budget.

Long term

Problems remain over the longer term.

If the oil price continues to rise, this will still hit the forecourt.

The OBR calculated that each £10 increase in the cost of oil equates to 7.4p on the cost of fuel.

The chancellor's cuts also do not affect the larger element of fuel duty rises - that linked to inflation.

The built-in 4p increase planned for April will still take place - it has merely been delayed until January.

And the inflation-linked increase planned for next April will take place too, during the following summer.

The rate of inflation, therefore, will have a far larger impact on duty rises than the new stabiliser over the coming years.

Finally, if oil prices remain high, the OBR forecasts the exchequer will actually lose money over the longer term

The OBR predicts that if the cost of fuel remains £20 more than the level in September for four years, the negative impact on the economy - and the Treasury - will be up to £7bn a year.

That would make it even harder to sustain or limit further cuts in fuel duty.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.