Kathleen Sebelius for Senate?

Kathleen Sebelius speaks at a healthcare event in March 2014. The New York Times reports that Kathleen Sebelius is considering another run for office in Kansas

Related Stories

The New York Times reported on Wednesday that Kathleen Sebelius, who last week announced her plan to resign after five years as US health secretary, is "considering" a run for the US Senate in her home state of Kansas.

When news of her impending departure broke, journalists rushed to pen Ms Sebelius's political obituary. How would she be remembered? How responsible was she for the rocky rollout of the healthcare reform websites in autumn 2013? How much credit can she take for the late surge in enrolment?

As the Wire's Philip Bump quips, Ms Sebelius's last name should be changed to "Kathleen Sebelius-Who-Oversaw-the-Botched-Obamacare-Rollout".

Comeback stories are nothing new in politics, however. Ms Sebelius does have a history of political success in Kansas, having been elected as the traditionally conservative state's governor in 2002 and re-elected with 58% of the vote in 2006.

Start Quote

It's really hard to see why Ms Sebelius would envision any real path to victory so close to Obamacare's implementation”

End Quote Aaron Blake The Washington Post

On the other hand, it's not 2006 anymore, and Ms Sebelius would have to overcome the challenge of being second only to President Barack Obama as the public face of the still very controversial healthcare reform.

Her name was on the Supreme Court case challenging the law's constitutionality. She was grilled frequently by hostile Republicans during congressional hearings. Even her Rose Garden goodbye speech had an embarrassing missing-page glitch.

The report Sebelius would run for Senate has been dismissed by others in the mainstream press.

Bump writes that there may be a "parallel dimension out there in which Kathleen Sebelius' tenure as HHS Secretary was an unalloyed success, the sort of thing that would propel her to victory in the Kansas Senate campaign", but "that dimension is not this one".

"It's really hard to see why Ms Sebelius would envision any real path to victory so close to Obamacare's implementation," writes the Washington Post's Aaron Blake.

Others close to Ms Sebelius told Washington newspaper The Hill that they doubted the secretary would run.

Start Quote

If Kathleen Sebelius wants to come back to Kansas to run for office we will pay her bus fare”

End Quote Kelly Arnold Kansas Republican Party Chair

"I know she's tired," a former staffer says.

On the right the prospect of a Sebelius campaign was met with a mixture of glee and ridicule.

"If Kathleen Sebelius wants to come back to Kansas to run for office we will pay her bus fare," Kansas Republican Party Chair Kelly Arnold told the New York Daily News.

Stephen Kruiser writes on PJ Media that, for Democrats, "now we know what the shelf life for feigned shame over a job poorly done is".

"Just a few days after the left media tried to-wink, wink, nudge, nudge-pretend that [Ms Sebelius] was the fall gal for the nightmarish Obamacare rollout," he says, "they are now touting her troubled tenure as a resume builder."

Conservatives took to Twitter to post their suggested #SebeliusCampaignSlogans, which the conservative website Twitchy.com collected. Many riffed on the "404 errors" users received when trying to access the dysfunctional federal healthcare website last October - "404ward" and "404 more years", for example.

General consensus, it seems, is that Ms Sebelius has little to no shot at winning. Recent poll numbers seem to back that up. And yet, as Bump says, "weirder things have happened".

"Dead people have been elected to federal office," he writes. "Prison inmates have been elected to federal office."

(Proposed #SebeliusCampaignSlogan: "Better prospects than the dead or imprisoned".)

There's a personal angle in all this. The incumbent is 77-year-old Republican Pat Roberts, an old family friend of Ms Sebelius who backed her nomination to be secretary in 2009. Mr Roberts turned on the secretary in 2013, however, accusing her of "gross incompetence" and calling for her resignation.

According to the Times, beating Mr Roberts - or even making him sweat his re-election - could be why she is "weighing revenge".

There's also the chance that Mr Roberts could be unseated in the Republican state primary by fire-breathing grass-roots conservative Milton Wolf. Such a development has put several thought-to-be-safe Republican seats into play in recent elections.

At the very least, Ms Sebelius is a seasoned campaigner with name recognition and the ability to fundraise on a national level. She could present enough of a threat to draw Republican time and money away from other, more crucial races. All that means she's probably better than anyone else the Democrats, who haven't won a Kansas Senate seat since 1939, could put on the ballot at this point.

Ms Sebelius - who will not formally resign as secretary until her successor is confirmed - has until 2 June to file paperwork declaring her candidacy.


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 8.

    Regrettable that Kathleen Sebelius will not get the nod from the Kansas rednecks as Republican lore is way advanced in all Red states - gerrymandering, voter's rights act repeal and a serious attempt at the state level underway as Republicans change the electoral college vote calculation (by districting) are all coming to a 'perfect storm' for 2016!

  • rate this

    Comment number 7.

    The question? Healthcare for all/single payer - was defeated by 2 Democrat senators! UK democracy's cornerstone is the NHS: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LnY-jy_cE0
    Today's report on US democracy makes complete sense here: http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746 ".. organised groups representing business interests have substantial independent impacts on US government policy,.."

  • rate this

    Comment number 6.

    "At the very least, Ms Sebelius is a seasoned campaigner with name recognition and the ability to fundraise on a national level."

    Is that supposed to be a commendation?

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    I agree whole-heartedly with the commenter at #3.

    The federal healthcare website problems were embarrassing and very badly timed, but in terms of the substance of the healthcare reform, the website itself is almost irrelevant.

    Sebelius has implemented what, once thought impossible, now looks like will be irreversible reform.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    The Website may have been botched, but it is stupid to think that is all the Affordable Healthcare Act was.
    It was just a small part.
    The bottom line was she oversaw the largest public healthcare program for more than 2 generations, and much of it is an improvement on the previous set up, what isn't could be improved.
    Rapid reckneckism is just folly, Politics Yes, but still just folly.


Comments 5 of 8


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.