Chris Christie's bridge-sized headache

 
Chris Christie speaks at a conference in Idaho in July 2011. New Jersey Governor Chris Christie's presidential ambitions could be at risk

Related Stories

It looks like a bridge scandal is putting New Jersey Governor Chris Christie in some rough water.

On Wednesday, emails revealed that one of the governor's senior staff members ordered a political appointee to close lanes of a major bridge to New York City in order to punish the mayor of a New Jersey town who refused to endorse the governor in his re-election bid.

It's the kind of obvious alleged abuse of power that would resonate with most Americans, and which could prove very damaging if it can be directly tied to Mr Christie. There is hardly anyone who doesn't know what it's like to be stuck in traffic. The claim that ordinary citizens were forced to endure additional inconveniences because a New Jersey politician (or his staff) wanted to flex political muscle is fairly inflammatory.

Start Quote

It's almost the definition of an abuse of power”

End Quote Joshua Marshall TalkingPointsMemo

The Bergen County Record's website, NorthJersey.com, reports that traffic caused by the lane closures delayed emergency medical responders from reaching four patients - one of whom, a 91-year-old woman, later died at a hospital.

Mr Christie has been widely tipped as a potential frontrunner for the 2016 Republican presidential nomination, so the latest developments in this story quickly brought out commentators on the left and the right. The outrage (and glee) from liberals was as obvious as it was predictable.

"So petty. So vindictive. So Christie," writes the Washington Post's Jonathan Capehart.

He notes that Christie cancelled the one public event on his schedule today, writing: "Like all bullies, he's running away from a real fight. And it shows that he realizes that his political standing at home and nationally is in danger."

TalkingPointsMemo's Joshua Marshall thinks Mr Christie's political future has been seriously damaged:

It's not bribery or killing someone or a high crime. But it's vindictive and quite possibly illegal. It's almost the definition of an abuse of power. It won't sink Christie. At least not the evidence so far. But it will hang around his neck forever as that bad thing Christie's operation did that supposedly (depending on whether you're a friend or enemy) tells you who the real Chris Christie is about.

The editors of the Newark, NJ, Star Ledger write that no matter how things turn out at this point, the emails prove that Mr Christie bears responsibility for the scandal.

"If it turns out he did know, he is obviously lying and unfit for office - let alone a 2016 presidential run," they write. "And even if he did not, his officials are liars. If Christie can't control them, how can we trust him as a potential future leader of our country?"

Start Quote

I have had Congressmen, Governors, and the staffers of Congressmen and Governors tell me horror stories about dealing with Christie's people”

End Quote Erick Erickson RedState blog

Although Mr Christie has been considered a Republican rising star, having just been re-elected by a large margin, he has often been perceived as a moderate and never has been fully embraced by the conservative base. This lack of support was reflected in the response in many conservative quarters.

"We like to judge politicians based on their policy positions, and that's the main way they should be judged," writes Paul Mirengoff on Power Line blog. "But policy positions change based on which way the wind is blowing and the nature of the office being sought. Temperament and personality don't change so easily. And they also matter."

The National Review Online's Jim Geraghty writes:

If the allegations are true, the lane closures would represent a petty and obnoxious abuse of authority, one worrisome in a potential president. Some may erroneously insist this is a display of toughness or hard-nosed political power, but the form of the vindictiveness punished Fort Lee commuters of all political stripes, not just the mayor. The state isn't given the authority to shut down road lanes as a tool for enforcing political loyalty, and it's rather shocking that this point needs to be made.

RedState blog's Erick Erickson says that he has been ambivalent about Mr Christie's potential presidential candidacy and thinks the governor wouldn't have gotten far even without the bridge controversy. The problem is that he and his staff operate "as divas".

"I have had Congressmen, Governors, and the staffers of Congressmen and Governors tell me horror stories about dealing with Christie's people," he writes. "All of them seem to dread it."

This story, like many scandals before it, may eventually blow over. Politicians in the past certainly have made it through worse. The governor came out on Wednesday afternoon with a firm statement calling the actions of his staff "completely inappropriate and unsanctioned".

If Mr Christie is to survive the coming days with his political future intact, however, he will have to move quickly and skilfully. As early commentary on this story indicates, he has enemies on the left and the right who are sharpening their knives.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 45.

    'Abject stupidity' of Christie's staff will have a positive effect on the performance of those remaining?
    "I had no knowledge or involvement in this issue, in its planning or execution," he said, "and I am stunned by the abject stupidity that was shown here." Good call Governor!

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 44.

    'Abject stupidity' says Christie, instead of "immoral, unethical, hurts average working people," indicating that to him it is simply a matter of political miscalculation, nothing more, obtuse to any other dimension other than political expediency.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 43.

    The Republicans are at their old tricks again, hurting the economy by spitefully closing things down (first the government, now a few bridge lanes).

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 42.

    Its difficult for me to believe he didnt know about it in some capacity. If members of his inner circle know about it, and they ordered a member of the Port Authority that Christie himself appointed to enforce it, then im not sure how Christie was kept out of the loop. Best case scenario he is appointing some real low-lives which doesnt exactly fill me with confidence.

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 41.

    DrJG: Lane closures occur daily, but not due to an act of political punishment

    It was wrong the aide ordered such, she should be fired and she was
    End of story

    Trying to link Christie to it when there is no evidence is wrong because its politically motivated which means its basically a fake story-
    again, where is the scandal?

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 40.

    LucyJ #38:

    Ha can be blamed for things he Should have known about. I am, professionally.

    Lane closures occur daily, but not due to an act of political punishment, which is what makes it a story. Republicans can only complain about stories with a political element if they are prepared to avoid all such stories when they suit their agenda - which their attitude to Obama proves not to be the case.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 39.

    david w #37:
    "So is 'competence' defined as knowing everything every subordinate is doing even if secret and unapproved?"

    By the reports, this was several days of traffic chaos, and planned over several weeks.

    A bit more that "everything", I think. Or else any senior politician could legitimately claim that other popular defense, the Ostrich one.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 38.

    DrJG: "I had no idea"

    You cannot really blame Christie for something he did not know about

    Eddie: I guess what is obtuse about your comments is the idea that this isn't a real story

    Its a politically motivated story which means it is not a real story

    So a few lanes closed down for a few days-
    this happens every day in America due to numerous reasons

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 37.

    @32
    "So lets get this straight: You are claiming one of the popular Nuremberg defences for him:

    >>"I am so incompetent that I had no idea what my (personally appointed) aides were doing."?

    So is 'competence' defined as knowing everything every subordinate is doing even if secret and unapproved?

    That sounds more like 'omniscience'.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 36.

    If an individual causes a United States citizens death by their action, then they should probably be charged with manslaughter.
    Is there a prosecutor looking into it?

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 35.

    So who was doing the investigation of bridges' lanes being reduced temporarily?

    http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/09/nyregion/christie-aide-tied-to-bridge-lane-closings.html

    'who turned them over under a subpoena from Democratic legislators investigating the lane closing, making it hard to determine in some cases who is speaking'

    Sounds like Democrats ordered the subpoena of emails+texts

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 34.

    @30 - We agree that Christie isn't personally implicated.

    But otherwise, I guess what is obtuse about your comments is the idea that this isn't a real story. For NJ residents, this is a big deal - in the specifics of messing with GWB traffic, and the general of what Christie's people were willing to do.

    This isn't trivial; not in NJ, and not nationally given Christie's ambitions.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 33.

    @22"Interestingly, this story shows that some in the GOP can play as dirty."

    To how many adults with a basic understanding of recent political history would that be surprising?

    Just like people with other political stances, there are many honest and genuine Republicans, but some who due to personal flaws or a group-think-based sense of righteousness couldn't be trusted with a burnt-out match.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 32.

    LucyJ #30:
    "Chris Christie just fired the aide who was responsible
    which was the right thing to do

    Blame his aide all you want

    But no one can blame Christie for something he did not know about"


    So lets get this straight: You are claiming one of the popular Nuremberg defences for him:

    "I am so incompetent that I had no idea what my (personally appointed) aides were doing."?

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 31.

    An observation, especially for those who somehow think these dodgy deeds can be turned to an attack on teh Democrats:

    I note that there seem to be plenty of the GOP happy to stick the knife between Christie's shoulder blades over this affair, perhaps because he is not seen as suitably rabidly right-wing, perhaps because he dared to work with the Obama after Hurricane Sandy. Dirty politics, yes...

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 30.

    Eddie: Christie hasn't been implicated personally, but his people have a lot to answer for

    Chris Christie just fired the aide who was responsible
    which was the right thing to do

    Blame his aide all you want

    But no one can blame Christie for something he did not know about

    As he had nothing to do with such, I think we are all ready to move on to a real story

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 29.

    @27 - The story was broken by the Bergen Record, which endorsed Christie. As a NJ resident, let me assure you no-one here thinks this is a fake scandal. Messing with the traffic on the GW Bridge creates havoc.

    The emails - all of which have been published - implicate Christie appointees, staff and his campaign. Christie hasn't been implicated personally, but his people have a lot to answer for.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 28.

    This is NJ politics, what did you expect!

  • rate this
    -3

    Comment number 27.

    George: this is no fake scandal

    It is a fake scandal drummed up by media

    There are traffic lanes closed all the time for accidents, etc
    and not all were closed, they were just reduced

    That being said this has to do with his aide and not him

    M: Christie's the one to win votes

    This just shows how scared the Democrats are of him
    because he stands a real chance at winning Presidency

  • rate this
    -5

    Comment number 26.

    Marie: It will be another election like 2012: Obama's blatant lies, while completely trashing Romney

    Based on the way they present information, I would say all of our mainstream media is pro-Democrat and anti-Republican

    Our media jumped all over Chris Christie even though he had nothing to do with such because they are pro-Democrat

    We all have to realize most media has a political agenda

 

Page 1 of 3

 

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.