Freezing cold v sizzling heat: Which is worse?

A man walks along the frozen shore of Lake Michigan in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Matthew Yglesias may disagree, but there's a reason why the Mamas and the Papas were California Dreamin'

There has been a lot of interesting news coming out of the great polar vortex of 2014. A Michigan lighthouse encased in ice. People throwing pots of boiling water into the sub-freezing air. People scalding themselves by throwing pots of boiling water into the air.

Perhaps most importantly, however, the cold weather has set off a regional boasting match not seen since the great East Coast-West Coast hip-hop showdown of the 1990s.

On Tuesday, Slate's Matthew Yglesias wrote that he greatly preferred extreme cold weather to high heat:

Start Quote

The problem with cold is that you have to put on layers and layers of clothing to do anything at all”

End Quote Ezra Klein The Washington Post

The crucial issue is clothing and adaptability. I went out today wearing a warm hat and warm gloves and a scarf. I had four layers on my torso. I wore some corduroy pants, a warm pair of socks and some boots. All things considered, I was pretty comfortable. Don't get me wrong, not as comfortable as I am on a nice 72 degree day. I am very glad that DC winters don't normally get this cold. Still, I survived.

Contrast that with a very hot and humid day of the sort that we regularly experience in the summertime here and elsewhere in much of the country.

You just can't take off enough clothes to be comfortable, the New York-raised Yglesias writes. And sometimes you have to dress up, and then you just swelter in your nice suit or gown.

That's bunk, replied the Washington Post's resident Heat Miser, Ezra Klein. In true Wonkblog fashion, the native Californian provided a list of five points supporting his assertion that cold-lovers are woefully misguided. Cold kills more people than heat. More people move from cold states to warm ones because of climate than vice versa. You're more likely to fall and hurt yourself in icy cold weather. Staying warm is more expensive, both in clothing and home heating costs. And as for the bundling-up-easier-than-taking-off issue?

The problem with cold is that you have to put on layers and layers of clothing to do anything at all. Weddings and fancy dinners are a lot rarer than walking the dog or getting groceries. But in real cold, any excursion into the outdoors, no matter how minor, requires you to layer on shirts, sweaters, jackets, gloves, scarves, hats. And then, if you have small kids, you have to suit them up in all that, too. It's a nightmare.

Start Quote

If it's freezing, you can easily wear long underwear or a warm hat to make up the difference in body heat”

End Quote Jonathan Chait New York magazine

The New Republic's Isaac Chotiner (another product of temperate California) scoffed at Yglesias's suggestion that four layers of clothing were enough to survive the recent outbreak of sub-freezing temperatures.

"It is beyond my comprehension how people can be warm if the temperature is beneath 20 degrees and they only have, as Yglesias says, four layers on their torso," he writes. "I had seven on Tuesday."

Meanwhile, Jonathan Chait of New York magazine worries about the plight of the blue collar worker, as he speaks out in favor of the Northern climes in which his employer resides.

"Lots of jobs involve physical activity, which makes you hot," he writes. "If it's freezing, you can easily wear long underwear or a warm hat to make up the difference in body heat. But if it's too hot, you're going to hit the zero clothing bound, or whatever the professional dress standard is in your chosen field."

There's also the fact that New York City smells much more tolerable during the winter - a point that Chait somehow neglects to make in support of his argument.

But this California-born, Texas-raised product of the Sun Belt still tends to agree with his warm-weather compatriots. While walking to work Tuesday morning, the cold-induced pain in my face slowly turning to dull numbness, I couldn't help but think that there is a reason why the deepest level of Hell in Dante's Inferno is a frozen cave.



This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 11.

    Retired from the UK to Central Florida. I'm glad the temperature dipped below freezing yesterday but even happier that our Winter will be over tomorrow and I can get back to bike rides along the beach in the Mid 70's

  • rate this

    Comment number 10.

    Real comparison?

    Of course comparing temperate warmth with extreme coldness is quite unfair. Where I live the regular summer daytime temperature in the shade is 120 degrees F. If you are unlucky and break down in your car on an open road then you will be stuck in the sun. The temperature here will be in excess of 150 degrees F. If you do not get help within a few hours you too will be dead.

  • rate this

    Comment number 9.

    Here's the real comparison...

    Remove your clothing and go outdoors. Find a shaded place, with plenty of food and water. Now wait... If it's 90 degrees (F), regardless of humidity - you will perish from old age before you suffer any true ill effects from the weather. Below ~ 60 degrees (F) you will eventually die from exposure. At 40F, within a couple of days. A few degrees less, within hours...

  • rate this

    Comment number 8.

    Freezing cold have huge impact biodiversity,humans can go to shelters. some animals migrate to warmer parts (Whales & Birds) to country like sri lanka where i live. but whole lot of animals do not have a chance. We have more biodiversity(BD). that is why we need to pay more atten. to freak freeze and heatwaves.BD bring own set of problems like mosquitoes/pests.need to find Env friendly Solution.

  • rate this

    Comment number 7.

    -27F here in Central Minnesota this morning, and I would rather be in Florida. High heat is very uncomfortable, but -27F hurts and keeps hurting. Ouch!!!


Comments 5 of 11


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.