Detroit: From American dream to American nightmare

A Detroit paint factory is in a state of disrepair amidst the city's economic collapse A Detroit paint factory lies in a state of ruin typical to the city's collapsed industrial base

Related Stories

Three months ago, Detroit became the largest city to file for bankruptcy in US history. The trial to determine whether a city of Detroit's size can stop paying its bills will have huge potential repercussions for cities and states across the country.

Perhaps no-one is awaiting the trial's outcome as much as Erma and Gordon MacDonald, who have been married for 63 years.

"I'm smarter than her," jokes Mr MacDonald, 87. "Only a stupid person would agree to marry me."

A jester at heart, Mr MacDonald says people always ask him why he laughs so much.

Mrs MacDonald, 82, has an easy answer: "It's so we don't cry."

In their tiny one-bedroom flat decorated with photos of their children and grandchildren, the MacDonalds grow silent.

Erma and Gordon MacDonald: "If they take my pension away, then we'll be in bad shape"

They contemplate a future in which the pension that Mr MacDonald earned over 39 years with the Detroit Police disappears - a potential casualty of Detroit's bankruptcy filing.

"I don't know what else to say - we're up in the air," Mr MacDonald says. He worries more about his wife, who is in poor health, than about himself.

"I take 15 prescriptions," says Mrs MacDonald, "and I kind of jokingly said if they take [my healthcare] away, which pills do I stop without dying?"

'American nightmare'

While it might seem unfathomable that the MacDonalds could face such a choice, the reality is that if Detroit's bankruptcy filing is allowed to proceed, the city will face extremely difficult decisions.

Kevyn Orr, the emergency manager brought in to run the city by the state of Michigan, argues there is no way forward for Detroit other than through the fresh financial start that bankruptcy brings.

The city is anywhere from $18bn (£11bn) to $20bn in debt - with $9bn a result of ballooning pension and healthcare costs.

A car is towed in Detroit, Michigan City authorities tackle the problem of abandoned cars on Detroit's streets
James Canty talks to car owner James Canty (left), manager of Detroit's parking department, deals with car owners who often only appear once their car is about to be towed
Michigan Central Station Michigan Central Station, built in 1913, has been closed since 1988. Once the tallest railway station in the world, it now stands decayed and abandoned
Road with graffiti The work of graffiti artists can be seen around much of the city
Diego Rivera's murals at the Detroit Institute of Arts As a way of paying off the city's debts, Detroit's emergency manager has proposed selling prized artwork from the Detroit Institute of Arts

It has already cut basic services to the bone, pushing more residents to flee. The city's population now stands at 700,000, down from two million at Detroit's peak.

Wait times for emergency calls now top one hour, and less than a third of the streetlights function.

Start Quote

If Detroit is able to file for bankruptcy, then every other big city is going to be watching this”

End Quote Prof John Pottow University of Michigan law professor

More than 80,000 properties have been abandoned. Nature, it seems, moves faster than federal court.

Despite all the hardship, those representing the city's pension schemes say a bankruptcy filing would allow the city to renege on promises made long ago.

They dispute Mr Orr's calculations, and say it's unfair that the 23,500 retirees who spent their lives working to keep Detroit safe and clean could be left with nothing.

"They're taking away the American dream and turning it into the American nightmare," says Donald Hall, who spent 29 years as a detention centre officer and now depends on the $850 he receives from the city every month.

All eyes on Detroit

There's no question that Detroit is unique among US cities, to fly so high and fall so far, to build landmarks like the majestic Michigan Central Station that less than a hundred years later have the aura of Roman ruins.

So then what impact, if any, could a successful bankruptcy filing have on other cities?

"On the one hand, Detroit is in an unusual position because it has had massive depopulation coupled with a collapse of the industrial sector," says University of Michigan law professor John Pottow, an expert in bankruptcy law.

'The jewel in the crown'

Graham Beal

Emergency manager Kevin Orr has proposed selling prized artwork from the Detroit Institute of Arts (DIA) to pay off the city's debts.

Founded in 1885, the DIA was the first US organisation to buy works by impressionists like Henri Matisse and Vincent van Gogh.

"It's [the] jewel in the crown" of Detroit's cultural attractions, says director Graham Beal (pictured above).

Assessors from Christie's auction house have spent weeks in the museum's galleries, trying to figure out how much the 3,500 works owned by the city are worth. It's estimated to be somewhere in the tens of millions of dollars.

Standing in the sky-lit courtyard of the museum, surrounding by Diego Rivera's epic murals of factory workers on the Ford production line, Mr Beal says it's abhorrent that the works of art lovingly collected could be sold.

"No one talked about selling art in the Great Depression," he says.

"On the other hand, Detroit was not alone in making legal commitments to people which it had no funding for."

According to a study by economists at Northwestern University, cities and counties across the US have a total of $574bn in unfunded pension obligations.

Already, cities such as Providence, Rhode Island, and San Diego, California, have shown signs they are crumbling under the weight of the financial promises made to retirees.

"If Detroit is able to file for bankruptcy, then every other big city is going to be watching this," says Prof Pottow.

Can it be fixed?

James Canty is a lifelong Detroit resident and manager of the city's parking department. I followed him on his daily rounds as he tried to rid the city of some of the thousands of abandoned cars that line its streets.

The job was once done by the police. Now, Mr Canty's team has taken on the role of enforcer in an attempt to free up overworked officers.

In neighbourhoods where it's hard to tell which, if any, of the houses are occupied, Mr Canty points to a white Chevrolet sedan with shattered windows here, a pick-up truck missing a wheel there.

Frequently, as soon as a tow truck arrives to remove the offending vehicle, the vehicle's owner suddenly appears, as if by magic.

The excuses are often similar - what looks like a derelict car is in fact in the process of being mended.

It's not hard to see Detroit's financial position in the same way as these dented and decrepit cars - they may or may not be broken, depending on who is looking at them.

Is it better to clear the way for something new - or to be forced to fix what only appears beyond repair?

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    PPI 11:49:

    Why has the FCA asked the sellers of PPI to look at 2.5 million complaints again? Because a couple of years ago it noticed that increased numbers were suddenly being rejected. When it probed why, the FCA discovered that some banks may have been treating more of their complainants unfairly. So the banks have got to deal with a large chunk of them all over again. Those banks just don't learn, do they?

     
  2.  
    EUROZONE INFLATION 11:36:

    Eurozone inflation fell to 0.3% in August, adding to worries it may end up with deflation. That's a bad thing for countries in the main, as consumer spending slows down. People wait to see if prices will fall before buying. The European Central Bank is under pressure to do something to help. Interest rates in the 18-country bloc are already flat on their back, though, so something more complicated is expected.

     
  3.  
    TESCO PROFIT WARNING 11:23:
    Tesco trolley

    Tesco is also cutting costs. "Capital expenditure for the current financial year will be no more than £2.1bn, which is £400m less than planned and £600m less than last year. IT will be affected and plans to refurbish its stores will be slowed."

     
  4.  
    PPI 11:03:
    FCA logo

    The news of the extra work for the banking industry comes in an update from the FCA (Financial Conduct Authority). It told the banks and others to re-open these rejected or underpaid cases. Martin Wheatley, chief executive of the FCA, said: "Making sure anybody previously mis-sold PPI is treated fairly now, and paid redress where its due, is an important step in rebuilding trust in financial institutions. In around two and a half million complaints this was not necessarily the case so, at our request, firms will be looking at these complaints again."

     
  5.  
    PPI 10:58:

    The banking industry has just been landed with another massive task as part of its attempts to clean up the scandal of mis-sold payment protection insurance (PPI) policies. The FCA says that "banks, credit card providers and personal loan companies have agreed to reassess more than two and half million complaints from 2012 and 2013 which they may have either unfairly rejected or paid too little redress to." Wow.

     
  6.  
    RBS PROFITS 10:43:
    RBS logo

    The results just published reveal the cumulative and horrific cost of mis-selling interest-rate hedging deals to business customers. This has cost it £1.4bn. That comprises £1.1m in compensation and £0.3bn in administrative costs.

     
  7.  
    RBS PROFITS 10:34:

    The largely state owned bank RBS - which includes NatWest - has reported a 53% jump in its half-year profits to £2.17bn. The profits rose because the bank had to set aside much less money to cover bad debts. So-called "impairment losses" were just £282m in the first six months of the year, compared to a whopping £2.1bn a year ago.

     
  8.  
    FINED AND BANNED 10:24:

    The FCA is scathing about Craig Cameron's dishonesty. "Cameron deliberately flouted regulatory requirements, which were designed to safeguard retail investors, in favour of selling high risk unregulated collective investment schemes (UCIS) for potentially lucrative gains," it said. "The UCIS have failed and the investors, many of whom should never have been exposed to these high risk investments in the first place, have paid a heavy price for his actions".

     
  9.  
    FINED AND BANNED 10:08:

    Another dishonest financial salesman has been fined and banned by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). This one is Craig Cameron who has been fined £350,000. Via his firm Burlington Associates, he conned 800 people into "investing" £30m in three unregulated investments that failed. They were new property developments in Croatia, Bulgaria and Montenegro.

     
  10.  
    WATER BILLS 09:53: BBC Radio 4

    Tony Smith, the chief executive of the Consumer Council for Water in England and Wales, has welcomed the price controls proposed by Ofwat. "We got customers pushing water companies to produce realistic plans in the first place, and we then wanted Ofwat to challenge the companies costs and particularly the cost of financing," he told the Today programme. "That's what they've done, they've come out with a much more realistic and less generous cost of financing and that's what reflected in this."

     
  11.  
    TESCO PROFITS WARNING 09:42:

    Well done to David Herro of Harris Associates, which apparently owns 3% of Tesco's shares. Earlier this month he told the Sunday Times: "In general, dividends should be covered by free cash. This is not the case with Tesco . . . Either [the company needs to cut the dividend] or generate positive cashflow. It should be cut if it's paid for by borrowing."

     
  12.  
    ICELAND VOLCANO 09:26:
    Volcano

    Don't panic. The wonderfully named Bardarbunga volcano is not posing problems as yet. This notice comes from the UK's National Air Traffic Control: "At present the UK Met Office advise that it is a lava eruption with no ash being emitted into the upper atmosphere. The Met Office further advise that current winds are such that if ash is emitted it is unlikely to affect UK airspace for the next couple of days."

     
  13.  
    TESCO PROFITS WARNING 09:07:

    This morning, before the Tesco announcement, the Motley Fool website for private investors published this front page article, extolling the value of investing in Tesco shares for its "big fat dividends". The half-year dividend has just been cut by 75%. Whoops!

     
  14.  
    MARKETS UPDATE 08:59:

    Despite the heavy falls for supermarket shares, broadly speaking the market is positive and the FTSE 100 is up 22 at 6827. Frankfurt's Dax is up 50 at 9510 and Paris's Cac 40 is 26 higher at 4392. If you're planning a bit of a trip the pound is looking pretty good. Its at 1 euro 2603 and $1.6603. Bulk money market rates being quoted here of course - your tourist cash is generally lower.

     
  15.  
    MALAYSIA AIRLINES 08:43:
    Malaysia Airlines plane

    The Malaysia Airlines plan in brief: 6,000 job cuts (a third of workforce); new chief executive; firm completely nationalised by state investment fund; long-haul routes slashed; return to profitability forecast by 2018.

     
  16.  
    SUPERMARKET SHARES 08:32:
    Tesco sign

    Tesco's profit warning and slashed dividend has knocked its rivals' shares for six. Sainsbury's is down 5%, Morrisons is down 4% and Marks and Spencer is down 3%. Waitrose is not listed, of course, being owned by the John Lewis Partnership. Asda is owned by US giant Wal-Mart, whose shares trade in US time.

     
  17.  
    TESCO PROFIT WARNING 08:20:

    The market doesn't like what it's seen in the Tesco statement. Shares are down 8%.

     
  18.  
    MALAYSIA AIRLINES 08:18:

    The job cuts - about 30% of the workforce - are part of a restructuring of the airline, which has seen a steep drop in passenger numbers following the two air disasters involving its planes.

     
  19.  
    MALAYSIA AIRLINES 08:15: Breaking News

    Malaysia Airlines says it will cut 6,000 staff. More details to follow.

     
  20.  
    WATER BILLS 08:12:

    Just to make it clear, the OFWAT announcement covers the 18 regulated water and sewerage companies in England and Wales.

     
  21.  
    NATIONWIDE HOUSE PRICES 07:54:

    The Nationwide's chief economist, Robert Gardner, says the fact that the economy is picking up means the property market will probably continue to thrive. "Consumer sentiment remains buoyant thanks to declining inflation and sustained increases in employment. The first increase in interest rates still appears some way off - we expect the first increase in the first quarter of 2015."

     
  22.  
    TESCO PROFIT WARNING 07:42:

    Tesco invents some new business jargon. "The actions announced today regarding capital expenditure and, in particular, dividends have not been taken lightly. They are considered steps which enable us to retain a strong financial position and strategic optionality." Strategic optionality? Who writes that sort of thing?

     
  23.  
    WATER BILLS 07:36:
    Tap

    Average bills for water and sewerage customers may fall by around 5% in real terms between 2015 and 2020, says the water industry regulator OFWAT. It has published its draft proposals for the industry's prices. The regulated water companies put forward their price plans last December and OFWAT will deliver its final ruling this coming December.

     
  24.  
    CAT BAIT 07:30:
    Cat

    Russia's biggest lender, Sberbank, is looking to boost mortgage sales by offering a free cat to anyone willing to buy a property with money loaned from the bank.

     
  25.  
    NATIONWIDE HOUSE PRICES 07:27:

    The lender says the outlook for the housing market remains highly uncertain: "The number of mortgage approvals fell by almost 20% between January and May, suggesting that activity was cooling. However, there was a modest rebound in June and it is unclear how much of the slowdown was due to the introduction of Mortgage Market Review rather than an underlying loss of momentum."

     
  26.  
    TESCO PROFIT WARNING 07:16:

    Tesco is cutting its dividend payout to shareholders. It says it will set the interim dividend at 1.16p per share - a reduction of 75% from last year's interim dividend.

     
  27.  
    HEADLINES
     
  28.  
    TESCO PROFIT WARNING 07:12:

    Tesco's profits were previously expected to be £2.8bn for the year - now it says below £2.5bn.

     
  29.  
    NATIONWIDE HOUSE PRICES 07:11:
    Houses

    House prices are still going up says the Nationwide building society. In August they rose by another 0.8%, pushing the annual rate of inflation to 11%. It's the 16th monthly rise in a row.

     
  30.  
    TESCO PROFIT WARNING 07:10:

    "We now expect trading profit for 2014/15 to be in the range of £2.4bn to £2.5bn. Trading profit for the six months ending 23 August 2014 is expected to be in the region of £1.1bn."

     
  31.  
    TESCO PROFIT WARNING 07:08:

    Tesco has brought forward the start date for Philip Clarke's replacement David Lewis as boss. He now starts the job on Monday.

     
  32.  
    TESCO PROFIT WARNING 07:05: Breaking News

    Tesco says its profits will be lower than expected. Dividends to be cut.

     
  33.  
    VIRGIN AUSTRALIA 06:49:
    Virgin planes

    Virgin Australia overnight announced losses of A$355.6m (£200.5m) for the year - more than three times its loss last time. It blamed "weak consumer sentiment" and too many planes - like its rival Qantas which reported its results yesterday.

     
  34.  
    CO-OP VOTE 06:35: BBC Radio 4

    Big changes to the structure of the deeply troubled Co-op group will be put to a ballot of members tomorrow. Phil Dorrell, of consultants Retail Remedy, tells Today that even if the changes go through, a new leadership will have lot of work to do. "This will be a large step-change. My one concern would be that it probably shouldn't be the final change for the Co-op, they should consolidate, make sure they get their businesses back on track, and then have another look at it in a couple of years time."

     
  35.  
    EUROZONE ECONOMY 06:22: Radio 5 live

    Wake Up to Money ponders whither the eurozone? This week France had to re-appoint its cabinet because of its failing economy. Italy re-entered recession earlier this month and even German GDP was down slightly in the latest quarter. Kathleen Brooks, from Forex.com tells the programme: "Some economies are falling at a faster rate than others but what we've really seen is the core economies Germany and France lagging behind Spain."

     
  36.  
    HOUSE PRICES 06:14:
    For Sale signs

    The gap between house sellers' asking prices and actual selling prices is widening, says the property website Hometrack. It explains that the market is cooling down, at least in terms of prices. It says sellers in England and Wales typically got 96% of their asking price in August, falling back for the third month in a row. But it adds house prices only tend to start falling when the percentage of the asking price that sellers achieve falls below 94%.

     
  37.  
    GOOGLE DRONE 06:03:
    Google drone

    Overnight, Google said it was developing drones to act as flying delivery vehicles. The company calls it Project Wing. But it said it would take many years to create a service with lots of drones making lots of deliveries every day. More here.

     
  38.  
    06:00: Rebecca Marston Business reporter, BBC News

    All of that. Stay with us - we're here 'til 13:00.

     
  39.  
    06:00: Ian Pollock Business reporter, BBC News

    Good morning, we are here again, to keep you informed, educated and possibly entertained.

     

Features

  • A painting of the White House on fire by Tom FreemanFinders keepers

    The odd objects looted by the British from Washington in 1814


  • Chris and Regina Catrambone with their daughter Maria LuisaSOS

    The millionaires who rescue people at sea


  • groynes at ClactonRunning the rule

    Will Clacton's voters opt for UKIP over the Tories?


  • Plane7 days quiz

    What unusual offence got a Frenchman thrown off a plane?


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.