Duncan Smith denies sickness benefit tests to triple

Iain Duncan Smith Mr Duncan Smith said they were following Labour's plan

Related Stories

Iain Duncan Smith has denied reports that ministers are considering trebling "fitness to work" tests on people claiming incapacity benefit.

The work and pensions secretary said the government had "absolutely no intention" of changing the 10,000-a-week rate begun under Labour.

He also played down reports of extra cuts to incapacity benefit.

They were continuing Labour's plan but hoped to get more people working by extending support programmes, he said.

Departmental cuts

Mr Duncan Smith's comments follow remarks from Chancellor George Osborne, that benefits which the government had not given specific commitments to protect would be part of the summer spending review aimed at cutting the £155bn deficit.

Over 2.5m people are on incapacity benefit or employment support allowance - costing about £12.5bn a year.

Start Quote

We have got to look at all these things, make sure it protects those in genuine need, protects those with disabilities and protects those who can't work but also encourages those who can work into work”

End Quote George Osborne Chancellor

The government has said that NHS and foreign aid spending will be protected as it seeks to tackle Britain's budget deficit, but other government departments face 25% real terms cuts.

Mr Osborne has said that figure could be reduced, if more savings can be found in the welfare budget - on top of the £11bn cuts he has already outlined.

He said: "We have got to look at all these things, make sure it protects those in genuine need, protects those with disabilities and protects those who can't work but also encourages those who can work into work. That is the purpose behind our welfare reform."

The Guardian reported that ministers were considering trebling the rate at which "work capability assessments" of people on employment support allowance from the current 10,000-a-week.

'Good programme'

But Mr Duncan Smith told MPs said he knew there had been "some speculation in the media" but they intended to launch their "work programme" in 2011, "as we said previously".

"We have absolutely not intention of changing this current plan ... at present 10,000 claimants a week over the period."

He said Labour's own plan had been a "good programme" adding: "We want to make that happen".

Start Quote

Quite frankly this whole thing smacks of 'we have got this large bill with incapacity benefit - let's cut it”

End Quote Andy Micklethwaite ME sufferer

Ms Cooper challenged him about where he was intending to find additional savings - Mr Duncan Smith said they intended to roll out Labour's "work support programme" from two areas to across the country. Ms Cooper asked him where the extra jobs would come from.

She argues that the government's plans are simply benefit cuts, not reform, as they would not help people get jobs.

She said the Labour government had already outlined plans to save £1.5bn on sickness benefits through its own test - the work capability assessment.

Earlier she accused the government of a "slash and burn approach" to benefits - including plans to cap housing benefit - which could actually end up costing more in the long run, by increasing unemployment and homelessness."

Reassess claimants

Equalities minister Lynne Featherstone has also expressed concern at the proposals.

Writing on her blog, the Lib Dem MP said: "The previous Labour government tried to get people off such allowances and my experience as a local MP from surgery is that the 're-assessment' of people claiming has been variable at best."

In the Budget Mr Osborne announced there would be new caps on the amount people could claim in housing benefit, tax credits were reduced, child benefit was frozen and medical tests introduced for the disability living allowance from 2013.

The Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats had already said they would reassess all claimants of incapacity benefit and its successor, the employment and support allowance, for their "readiness to work".

Start Quote

What the government seems to be saying is abandon regional investment and encourage individuals to move out”

End Quote Louise Ellman Labour MP

Those deemed fit to get a job would be moved onto Jobseeker's Allowance instead - amounting to a cut in benefits and a requirement to seek work.

Under assessments carried out under Labour on new employment support allowance claimants between October 2008 and August 2009, 39% were deemed "fit for work" and a further 37% withdrew their claim before the test was complete.

Overall, of completed assessments, 68% were deemed fit for work, 9% were recommended for a support group aimed at several disabled people who are not obliged to find work.

The remaining 23% were recommended for a "work related activity group", with which a personal adviser carries out interviews and helps them get ready to return to work.

The Conservatives have argued that one in five incapacity claimants is fit for work - about half a million people. Before the election they suggested that could save £200m a year.

On Sunday, Mr Duncan Smith said he wanted unemployed council tenants to be given incentives to move to areas where there are jobs.

He argued that millions were trapped in "ghettos of poverty" unable to move for fear of losing their homes and people were "trapped" in areas with high unemployment.

He said his plans were about assisting people, not forcing them to uproot.

But Labour MP Louise Ellman, MP for Liverpool Riverside, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme the argument ignored the "need for regional investment in local areas".

"What the government seems to be saying is abandon regional investment and encourage individuals to move out - if you can find the homes they can live in. That isn't a policy, it's going back to the 80s and we don't want that."

Here are a selection of your comments

I'm all for it. I have been claiming IB since I left my last job due to mental health problems in 2007 when my sick pay ran out. I get £106 per week which is topped up with income support by £54 a week. I am single and that's a fair income for someone who lives alone. However with help and therapy and part time college, I have been working towards going back to work and studying and in September I am starting a full time university degree - a big step for someone with a diagnosed MH problem.

Mary, Manchester

These measures will affect those suffering with mental illness. People suffering from severe depression will be told they are 'fit for work' because there is no physical reason that they can't work.

Richard Stewart, Birkenhead

I have cerebral palsy and receive IB and DLA at the higher rates which means I have enough money to get by BUT I would work tomorrow if I could. If they can find me a job I will snap it up.

Julian, Clacton

I have been on incapacity benefit since 2008 due to being unable to work because I have multiple sclerosis. I did not ask to develop this, but the government seems to think that I am exaggerating about how my illness affects me and that I am actually fit and able to work. What employer is going to take someone on who has repeated bouts of illness and has no hope of recovery?

Mrs A. Johnson, Hemel Hempstead

When I broke my back and shattered my pelvis (among many other injuries) I obviously had to have a good deal of time off work. It drove me crazy. I couldn't wait to get back. Since my initial accident I have always worked. My employer knows about my problems and we just work around them. Sometimes I lie in bed in terrible pain but I always get up for work eventually! I can't stand people claiming benefits when they could work.

Dom Finn , Nottingham

Having worked in community mental health for years, I would say at least 20% could have gone straight back to work, and another 30% should have been working towards it. But benefits fund a very good lifestyle for some malingering people, where's the incentive to go back to work?

Deek, Norfolk

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More UK stories



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.