Great tits' 'black ties' smaller in the city

Great tit on a branch Size matters: City birds with smaller black ties had better survival rates

Related Stories

Urban great tits have smaller black breast stripes than their rural neighbours, a study has found.

Scientists discovered significant differences between birds living in Barcelona, Spain and a nearby forest.

Smaller "black ties" appeared to improve male great tits' survival rates in the city, while in the countryside birds with larger ties fared best.

"The urban habitat favours a different kind of bird than the natural habitat," said researcher Dr Juan Carlos Senar.

His team captured and recaptured birds over several years and used a predictive computer model to compare survival rates of great tits with different sized ties.

Great tit facts

Great tit

Why do city birds sing louder?

Watch inquisitive birds pinch milk

Why are birds laying eggs so early in spring?

"Recapturing a bird means that it is alive, and so we can relate survival probability to tie size," explained Dr Senar, who is head of research at the Natural History Museum of Barcelona.

The size of the distinctive black stripe on great tits' yellow chests is hereditary. It varies more in males, and is linked to their personality.

Male great tits (Parus major) with narrower black chest stripes tend to be cautious, while birds with wider markings are more dominant and aggressive.

In natural habitats, wide-tied birds are more successful; they father more offspring and are favoured by females choosing mates.

But in the city it is possible that caution may be key to survival, the study suggests.

Details of the findings are published in the journal Ecology and Evolution.

"The urban habitat is probably less predictable in any respect, and cautious birds can perhaps be favoured," suggests Dr Senar.

"But it is difficult to say why," he admitted.

Barcelona skyline Birds in Barcelona: Great tits with cautious personalities may fare best in the city

"Perhaps the relationship is more indirect. What normally happens is that a cautious personality is linked to a slow but very detailed exploration ability and innovation."

The team hopes the study will help the understanding of how birds adapt to urban habitats.

Previous research has shown city-dwelling great tits differ from their rural counterparts genetically and morphologically.

Building on this knowledge, the new study shows how the difference in plumage between birds living in urban and rural habitats is an example of "divergent" natural selection - when individuals of the same species become increasingly dissimilar over time.

Dr Senar said: "I like to advocate the urban habitat as a nice experiment in the 'wild' where we can see natural selection in action."

City life

Watch a city centre roosting spectacle

See animals making cities their playgrounds

Explore a cemetery packed with wildlife

Past research has shown some birds have adapted to city life by their larger brains relative to their body size, which may help them deal with the changeable conditions of urban environments.

And urban great tits' song has adapted to project further.

The researchers wrote that the question now is, "whether urban great tit females have realised that in the urban habitat, the 'high quality' males are those with small ties."

Dr Senar added: "I wonder whether urban females have realised that in the city, less is more."

Join BBC Nature on Facebook and Twitter @BBCNature.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

We've moved to BBC Earth

  • BBC EarthWe've moved!

    Click here to go to our new home at BBC Earth

BBC Earth highlights

BBC iWonder

Copyright © 2016 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.