Various Artists XFM The Debut Sessions Review

Album. Released 2008.  

BBC Review

As it stands it leaves you feeling bitterly short changed.

Damian Jones 2008

Billed as a best of the hottest UK acts of 2007 and the last 10 years, XFM Debut Sessions is very much a hit-and-miss affair. Granted there are one or two classic early performances spread across this compilation but really some of the acts don't even warrant a half-arsed b-sides album.

Take CD 1. Considering this is supposed to be dubbed 'The Class Of 2007', there are more than a fair share of howlers on here. How anyone could throw in Enter Shikari's techno hardcore dumper Jonny Sniper or anything by the brace snapping Dexys pretenders, The Rumble Strips, seems ludicrous. Surely a Klaxons' classic or a moody number from The Good, The Bad And The Queen would have been sufficient?

Thankfully the likes of Jamie T, The Enemy, The View, Bat For Lashes and even Calvin Harris go some way to fulfilling 'The Class of 2007' tag. Jamie T's live rendition of Sheila, in particular, sounds far grittier live than it ever did on record as does The View's acoustic rendition of Same Jeans.

And then there's CD2, appallingly titled 'The Best Of A Decade'. Unbelievably most of the tracks here are lifted from performances over the last four years with a meagre five songs making up the rest of the remaining six.

Yet again early performances from Arctic Monkeys and the likes of Muse would have gone some way to ensuring this was a CD worthy of its title. Seriously though when has anything by Nine Black Alps been worthy enough to match up to anything by the likes of Bloc Party, Editors, Kasabian or Kaiser Chiefs?

To make matters worse some of the recordings are shambolic here particularly The Libertines' barely audible What A Waster which sounds more like The Pogues' Shane MacGowan after ten pints of lager. Only Bloc Party's blistering rendition of Banquet, Editors' bombastic take on Munich and a tear jerking punch drunk New Born by Elbow come close to anything like 'Best Of The Decade'.

The sad thing is with a little more thought, XFM Debut Sessions could have been the classic compilation it threatens to be. As it stands it leaves you feeling bitterly short changed.

Creative Commons Licence This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence. If you choose to use this review on your site please link back to this page.