N*E*R*D Nothing Review

Released 2010.  

BBC Review

Album four from Pharrell and company features its share of dancefloor fillers.

Mike Diver 2010

A decade ago the hottest production team on the planet was The Neptunes – Pharrell Williams and Chad Hugo. With a unique sonic palette, the award-winning duo worked on records by massive artists including Justin Timberlake, Kelis and Jay-Z. In 2001, they translated behind-the-scenes success into spotlight-stealing acclaim as N*E*R*D (No-One Ever Really Dies), adding Shay Haley to create a trio. Their debut, In Search Of…, flew off the shelves in its two guises – a hip hop original and a later-released rock reworking – and its follow-up Fly or Die was well received. 2005’s split seemed a Fawlty Towers-style end: history was happy, the band’s record unblemished.

But a (inevitable, these days) reunion yielded a so-so third LP, 2008’s Seeing Sounds, and here’s the group’s fourth collection: just as unremarkable as its immediate predecessor. It’s not poor, as such – with Williams and Hugo on board, many an average track has been elevated to pop classic status – but it doesn’t further any reputations in the slightest. And a by-product of this creative stasis is the risk that those first two albums will see their potency diluted by further just-enough exercises in funk-rock riffing and Williams’ puzzling romantic-cum-misogynistic lyrics. He is still a vital force in pop production and a regular guest vocalist on hit records, so one has to wonder why he persists with N*E*R*D when the songs are no longer as strong as they were.

Nothing – in its 10-track version – is bookended by a pair of swaggering floor-fillers. Party People, needless T.I. guest rap aside, is a close cousin of Fly or Die’s fine single She Wants to Move, famous for its absurd "her ass is a spaceship I want to ride" line and featuring a pre-Strictly Alesha Dixon in its video. The Nelly Furtado-starring Hot-n-Fun rides a bouncy bassline and oozes the same sort of grubby sexiness that characterised Britney’s brilliant Neptunes-produced brace of I’m a Slave 4 U and Boys. But little of what happens between is particularly memorable – Perfect Defect is a fairly appealing ode to a lover’s singular traits, and Hypnotize U comes over like Lil Wayne doing Spandau Ballet, but neither rank amongst their makers’ best.

No disaster, Nothing offers perfectly serviceable fare for fair-weather N*E*R*D fans. But anyone who vividly remembers the fire in the band’s collective belly around the time of their scintillating debut will be disappointed with this comparatively uninspired set.

Creative Commons Licence This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence. If you choose to use this review on your site please link back to this page.