This page has been archived and is no longer updated.Find out more about page archiving.

Nicola Benedetti Szymanowski ~ Chausson ~ Saint-Saens Review

Album. Released 2005.  

BBC Review

This debut CD from 17-year-old violinist Nicola Benedetti shows a real individuality...

Claire Rogers 2005

In terms of choice of music and the way in which it's performed, this debut CD from 17-year-old violinist Nicola Benedetti shows a real individuality and maturity. It's an interesting programme well suited to her excellent technique and tone, which she intuitively adapts to suit each of the works.

In Szymanowski's gorgeous First Concerto her intense vibrato integrates well with the orchestra - interestingly, at the other end of the scale from the classic recording by Wanda Wilkomirska who often played with no vibrato at all. This is an excellent performance though, with soaring lines and some impressive double-stopping, especially in the Kochanski cadenza, and Daniel Harding and the LSO draw lots of detail from the vivid, colourful score.

To follow, Benedetti choosesthree works by French composers. She adopts a warmer, fruitier violin sound in a well-paced, luminous performance of Saint-Saëns's Havanaise, before playing Massenet's Méditation from Thais with real poise and control. Best of all though is her stunningly mature performance of the Chausson Poème. This piece suits her playing perfectly and she produces a consistent line throughout as good as some of the greats of the past.

The disc ends with 2 world premieres. First, a rarity. Contemplations is Heifetz's arrangement of a song by Brahms, orchestrated here by Julian Reynolds, and Benedetti captures the romantic mood of the piece with great sweetness and a tone to match. To finish, though, and bring the music up to date, she plays an interesting and evocative work written specially for her by John Tavener - Fragment for the Virgin - giving a performance full of vibrancy, delicacy and control by turns.

This is an excellent and enjoyable CD and at just 17 Nicola Benedetti shows all the signs of becoming an accomplished and individual violinist.

Finally, an interesting innovation from DG - the inclusion of a backing track for the Massenet piece, guaranteed to get all those Grade 6 violinists playing along to the LSO in their own front rooms. It's a great idea, and a great CD.

Creative Commons Licence This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence. If you choose to use this review on your site please link back to this page.