1. BBC Music
  2. Reviews
  3. Live at Reading

Nirvana Live at Reading Review

Live. Released 2 November 2009. Discography information comes from MusicBrainz. You can add or edit information about Live at Reading at musicbrainz.org.

BBC Review

Nirvana’s triumphant final UK performance finally released as a live album.

Stevie Chick 2009-11-09

Nirvana headlined the Reading festival in 1992 as they were unsteadily acclimatising to their newfound status as multi-platinum unit shifters, frontman Kurt Cobain loudly declaring his disaffection with fame, and denying rumours of drug abuse that dogged him and his wife, Courtney Love. Indeed, hearsay across the festival site that weekend whispered that Nirvana would blow out their headline set, that Cobain was hospitalised by an overdose.

Such offstage drama lends an undeniable tension to this live album of that performance. On the DVD of the show that accompanies Deluxe Editions of this release (the standalone CD omits a song and all the between-song banter, and is very much inferior as a result), Cobain rolls onstage in a wheelchair and fakes an addled collapse, before ‘recovering’ and leading Nirvana through a ferocious and full-blooded Breed.

This venomous energy burns throughout what is by no means a greatest hits set; alienated by much of his newfound fandom, Cobain was in no mood to play crowd-pleaser. Performances of Nevermind anthems like Come As You Are and Smells Like Teen Spirit are by no means perfunctory, but Nirvana truly come alive here when exploring the murkier corners of their catalogue: fiery takes of fan-favourite B side Aneurysm and covers of The Wipers’ D7 and The Money Will Roll Right In (by 1980s Californian punks Fang) are highlights.

The true revelation, however, is the then-unrecorded All Apologies, dedicated to Courtney Love and their 12-day-old daughter Frances Bean. “[Courtney] thinks everyone hates her now,” says Cobain, betraying a vulnerable, boyish grin as the Reading audience yells “Courtney, we love you!” at his request. The song that follows remains perhaps Cobain’s most moving, and in this early stripped-bare version – just Cobain’s brittle, chiming guitar and howl, Dave Grohl’s powerhouse drums and Krist Novoselic’s McCartney-aping bass-lines – perfectly fuses Cobain’s equal love for Beatles-esque melody and punk-rock’s searing honesty, with a haunting intensity.

Forget the indulgent soloing and theatrical spectacle many live albums trade in. Live at Reading delivers instead an opportunity to revisit a key moment in rock history, unedited and unadorned; to experience the greatest rock’n’roll group of their era playing what became, tragically, their final performance on British soil. On this evidence, it was a truly remarkable night.

Creative Commons Licence This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence. If you choose to use this review on your site please link back to this page.

Comments

You need to sign in to contribute to this page. If you haven't registered to leave comments, creating your membership is quick and easy.

    • 1. At 3:40pm on 11 Nov 2009, marshallsmother wrote:

      Ham-fisted shoegazing. Only musician worth a nod is Dave Grohl.

      Complain about this comment

    • 2. At 2:29pm on 12 Nov 2009, MrHallwood wrote:

      Absolute rubbish marshallsmother, this was not a clumsy performance at all, and I don't agree it is shoegazing either, a year earlier Kurt leapt into the drum it!?

      Although probably not worth parting with 15.00 quid for but definitely worth a download from some blogspot or bit torrent.

      Complain about this comment

    • 3. At 12:51pm on 13 Nov 2009, EarlMarischal wrote:

      Yet another example of the deification of the sad individual who hadn't the moral strength of character to cope with his life and took the coward's way out.

      Grohl is the only person from the band with any real talent.

      Complain about this comment

      View these comments in RSS

      Explore the BBC

      This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.