1. BBC Music
  2. Reviews
  3. From Her To Eternity

Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds From Her To Eternity Review

Album. Released 11 May 2009. Discography information comes from MusicBrainz. You can add or edit information about From Her to Eternity at musicbrainz.org.

BBC Review

Imperfect, visceral, exciting and, ultimately, classic.

Chris Long 2009-05-08

Now that Nick Cave is the prince of glowering, gothic rock, it's difficult to imagine a time when it looked like he'd disappear, but after the break-up of his apocalyptic, bombastic post-punk noisesmiths The Birthday Party, that's how it seemed.

Yet unbeknownst to his fans, he was already plotting a new dawn as the Party reached their finale. In fact, what's most staggering about his Bad Seeds' debut is not the throbbing thrill of it, but the fact that it ripped out of him, through the mangle of his five new Bad Seeds, and into the world within months of his last band's demise.

Over two and half decades on, it has lost none of its slap-face quality. From the opening brood of Avalanche, a Leonard Cohen cover - what a bold debuting statement to make, opening with a cover - underpinned brilliantly by Barry Adamson's insidious bass and Mick Harvey's tumultuous drums, through the brutal, keening shudder of the title track, and out to the spine-gripping and strangely seductive closer, A Box For Black Paul, the album is a stunning piece of work that declared that Cave was far from finished.

And it's not simply a statement in power, but also in control. Nothing is wasted and, at just seven songs long, it leaves you desperate for more of the guttural call of Cabin Fever, more of the twisted vision of Saint Huck, just more of the maddeningly brilliant anger, flawed ambition and deep-burning fire of it all.

In the notes of this reissue, there is a quote from Nick which says that when they went into the studio to make the album, ''no-one knew what the songs were''. Now, as then, the answer is simple: imperfect, visceral, exciting and, ultimately, classic.

Creative Commons Licence This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence. If you choose to use this review on your site please link back to this page.

Comments

You need to sign in to contribute to this page. If you haven't registered to leave comments, creating your membership is quick and easy.

    • 1. At 10:40am on 11 May 2009, 74underground wrote:

      The track list displayed here (and discussed in the review) is for the debut album 'From her To Eternity' (9 tracks, not 7, and becoming 10 when re-issued a few years later), not the third album 'Kicking Against The Pricks' as the illustration suggests.
      A strange mix of clear errors I wouldn't have expected from a BBC review.

      Complain about this comment

    • 2. At 1:59pm on 11 May 2009, U13958695 wrote:

      This album was originally released in 1984 not 1988. Along with Eden by Everything But The Girl, it formed the soundtrack to the final month of my degree in Architecture. I haven't been able to listen since as it brings back all the fear and worry too clearly. Eden still sounds fantastic though. Go figure!

      Complain about this comment

      View these comments in RSS

      Explore the BBC

      This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.