1. BBC Music
  2. Reviews
  3. The Circle

Bon Jovi The Circle Review

Album. Released 2 November 2009. Discography information comes from MusicBrainz. You can add or edit information about The Circle at musicbrainz.org.

BBC Review

Dependable drive-time rock delivered with an admirable straight face.

Tom Hocknell 2009-11-05

New Jersey rockers Bon Jovi return with their eleventh album and are reunited with Lost Highway producer John Shanks, fresh from recent stints working with Take That and Alesha Dixon.

Bon Jovi fans, and there’s plenty of them, who have not been put off by recent output will find plenty to love here. The band long ago developed into a slick, stadium-filling act, and although this album marks a slight return to their more traditional rock roots after the Nashville-influenced Lost Highway, not much has changed. Like a hairier and less-subtle version of Bruce Springsteen, they like to give voice to the blue-collar worker and refuse to progress stylistically beyond a form that's served them so well already.

Long-standing bands often believe their own hype; indeed, they are often the last ones left believing it, and someone’s clearly exploded a lyrical cliché bomb in the studio here. They’ve even titled a song Live Before You Die, which is wrong on too many levels to even begin listing here. There is no denying their skill with a tune, but there is the lingering sense that were Flight of the Conchords to do a heavy metal pastiche of, say, millionaires sticking it to the ‘man’, it would sound exactly like Work for the Working Man. It is commendable that Jon Bon Jovi can keep a straight face while writing lines such as “working man, empty pockets full of worry / had to get two jobs”, presumably referring to a rock star’s need for an acting career on the side.

That said, other than the band, few listen to Bon Jovi with a straight face, and stupid grins are to be found. The atmospheric Broken Promiseland could be lifted from Slippery When Wet, while swelling keyboards herald moments of genuine emotion, such as on Fast Cars. Love’s the Only Rule also utilises synthesized strings to great effect, and perhaps illustrates where referees are going wrong around the country.

The Circle is not going to surprise anyone, but maybe in such turbulent times this is exactly what people need: dependable drive-time rock dripping with references to getting up from your knees and not giving up.

Creative Commons Licence This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence. If you choose to use this review on your site please link back to this page.

Comments

You need to sign in to contribute to this page. If you haven't registered to leave comments, creating your membership is quick and easy.

    • 1. At 09:39am on 06 Nov 2009, fingerbob99 wrote:

      I was hoping Bon Jovi would find a new producer for this album and find a slightly different sound with maybe a bit more edge, Shanks has changed his approach though and this shows on 'When We Were Beautiful' using a choir for backing vocals and the whole song has a real ambience about it. 'Bullet' sees Sambora go back to his talkbox but with a bigger sound, Lyrics that could have been pulled off 'Hey God' (These Days) fit nicely.
      The Circle is a great addition for any Bon Jovi fan and wont disappoint, if you've never bought a Jovi album before now then this would be a great start point. 5 out of 5 for me (but i'm gonna say that cos i'm a big fan).

      Complain about this comment

    • 2. At 7:40pm on 07 Nov 2009, TheGenuineSeer wrote:

      Same tired rock cliches. The working man deserves better for his buck unless he is a moronic chav.

      Complain about this comment

      View these comments in RSS

      Explore the BBC

      This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.