|
London
Mayor, Ken Livingstone, has announced plans to install technology
that will enable mobile phones to work in all tube stations.
The technology may also allow Tube passengers access to wireless
Internet and digital radio.
London
Underground is currently seeking proposals from suppliers to provide
subterranean transmitters in stations and even in tunnels.
It's the latest plan to generate more money for the Underground.
Whichever phone operator wins the bid will have to pay Transport
for London, for the privilege.
Ken
Livingstone said: "We know that many Londoners would like the
convenience of being able to use their mobile phones at tube stations
throughout the underground network.
"We
also want to see how technology could be taken even further, for
instance wireless Internet so passengers could receive up-to-the-minute
travel information via their laptop or mobile phone."
Trials
are set to start at one London station in 2006, with full mobile
phone service a possibility on all Underground stations from the
summer of 2008.
Roger
Evans, Conservative transport spokesman said: "I think its
a good idea. My only concern may be that it could enable terrorists
to set off bombs remotely and we need to consider that threat.
"We
should also look into the potential for mobile phone companies to
pay for this themselves - given the extra revenue they will make
from customers using their phones on the Tube."
Concerns
were raised by the Liberal Democrats last year about the security
risks of such plans. Former London Mayoral candidate, Simon Hughes
said mobiles were a "cheap and effective long range detonator".
He
continued: "Using mobiles on the deep line sections... is unnecessary.
Texting is a luxury, security is not."
The
Mayor has also announced that he's pushing ahead with his plans
for a rival free paper on the tube.
Email us with your views
Let
us know what you think. Is mobile technology on the underground
a good idea? How will it affect you? Are the security risks too
great? e-mail
us
Your
views
Possibly the only good thing about Tube travel is not having to
listen to other passengers' (sorry, customers') inane mobile babble.
Considering the Madrid train bombs were detonated by mobile and
that an alleged member of that terrorist cell has just been detained
in Slough, wouldn't it be safer if Ken kept it that way?
Bennet Goodman
Not a good idea at all. You don't need people jabbering away when
you have finally got a seat and want to take a nap.
Lee Gibson
At first I thought this would be a good idea - but on consideration,
I think I can cope without sending a text on the tube, or needing
to make a call (where I would just have to scream at the top of
my voice anyway). Tube journeys are not typically all that long
- fair enough people need to use their mobiles if on a longer overground
journey, but surely we can wait just a few more minutes until we
are off the tube to make that important call to say we are running
late !!
Amy
Edwards SE1
Oh
god no, can you imagine what it would be like? it's bad enough with
those infuriating personal stereos, let alone mobiles. I will find
the whole thing totally intrusive, and yes I do own a mobile.
Alf Newman
Chipperfield
Hertfordshire
Occasionally I travel to Sweden on business. Imagine the pleasure
in using one's mobile phone anywhere in Stockholm whether in the
office or on the underground rail lines bored through solid granite.
Even
when we can use our mobile phones in London Tube tunnels there will
remain a major difference between how Stockholmers and Londoners
use their phones on trains. In Stockholm there is no need to phone
work/friends that one is stuck on a train because of signal failure,
points failure, late running, staff absence, leaves on the line,
wrong kind of snow, shortage of rolling stock, or any other of the
billion excuses in the Tube management's lexicon for awful service;
it simply doesn't happen there. So come Ken get the equipment installed
now so we can tell everyone why we are going to be late ... again.
Trevor
Jenkins
Please
no mobile phones on tubes. The ambient noise on the underground
is so
high that those using mobiles will be forced to shout the essential
information
that they are "on the tube". It is unpleasant enough to
be on a busy underground train
without increasing noise pollution further.
Andy
Guilbert
The
cons outweigh the pros. Great, we can phone ahead to tell people
where we are on the underground. So why not have in-built phone
systems on the trains like planes have, if that call is oh-so important?
I dont
want someone shouting down their phone next to me every morning;
its GREAT to have some peace on the way to/from work!
Also,
weve seen what happened in the 3/11 Madrid train bombing.
KEEP MOBILES OFF THE UNDERGROUND!!!
Lee
Haynes
What a
great idea! Even the backward transport systems in Australia allow
the use of mobile phones from underground stations and moving trains.
It's a godsent to be able to ring the wife and kids when I'm delayed
or stuck in a tunnel somewhere between work and home through the age
old 'operational fault'.
James Stracey
The only decent thing about travelling on the tube is silent passengers,
a chance to read the paper without having to overhear someone else's
conversation. I think the security risk of bomb detonation is far
too high, we're constantly being told passengers safety is the most
important thing when travelling - are we going to see passengers lives
at risk in order to
create some more revenue?
Joseph
Royall
Please
don't do it ! The bus is bad enough when people get going on the mobiles.
The tube will be even worse and of course the security is more important.
Let's face it though when the money is on the table are they really
going to be concerned with security or just the fat wad from the mobile
company?
James
NW11
Underground
on the tube is the one place you can be guaranteed not to have to
listen to other people's banal mobile phone conversations. That's
enough in itself to question the Mayor's plans, let alone the worrying
security implications.
Steve Lee
How
can they force this on the travelling public without any regard
to the health and safety hazard? There have been, and are, countless
protests around the country about the installation of mobile communications
transmitters above ground, particularly near schools and in residential
areas, because of the health risks from electromagnetic radiation.
The official inquiry headed by Sir William Stewart only recently
recommended greater caution. People can choose whether or not and
how long to use a mobile phone, but they cannot escape a transmitter
that is switched on constantly. Tube travel is dangerous enough
already without adding to the hazards and nuisance. Anyone concerned
about this move to put profit before public health and safety should
tell Ken Livingstone where to get off.
Gayle
Goshorn
London N2
Being able to use your mobile on the station platform, escalators,
etc is one thing but PLEASE NO, not on the actual trains.
It's so noisy everyone would have to shout, it would be a nightmare!!
Let's
get train air-con sorted out first (and, er, trains/signal systems
that are reliable).
Another
Metro?
Great,
another free newspaper; a few more thousand trees to be chopped
down every day.
Can
we assume there will be places to recycle these millions of newspapers
side by side with the metal vendors where you pick up them up?
No?
I thought not somehow...
Joe
(Kensal Green, NW10)
A WORLD
OF NO!!
The
tube is about the ONLY respite we have from the annoying, pinging,
mobiles and the shouty morons who believe they just cannot wait
a few minutes to take a call. On a cramped commute it's bad enough
if people try, to read a newspaper without people believing they
just HAVE to fish out their phone from the bottom of their bag to
take a call.
This
is madness of the first water and should be scrapped before it gets
any further!
Si
Belcher
You
can use your mobile on the Metro in Paris - why has it taken so
long for the companies in the UK to catch up?
Claire Tomlin
Wouldn't it be much better to actually get a decent service running
so that that we can all get to work and home on time rather than
invest in something like this?
Smitty
London NW3
|