BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

24 September 2014

BBC Homepage
»BBC Local
Things to do
People & Places
Religion & Ethics
Arts and Culture
BBC Introducing
TV & Radio

Sites near Liverpool

North East Wales

Related BBC Sites


Contact Us

Latest Features


Flooding Apology

By Paul Coslett
Liverpool City Council has apologised for the controversial flooding of a Welsh village 40 years ago to build a reservoir to supply Liverpool's water.

Liverpool City Council has formally apologised for the flooding of a Welsh village to provide water for the city. The village of Capel Celyn in Merionethshire was flooded as part of the Treweryn water scheme to build a reservoir to provide water for the city. The 40th anniversary of the opening of the reservoir is on October 20th.

The flooding was proposed in the late 1950’s as Liverpool’s demand for water grew. A £16 million scheme was put forward to dam the valley of Tryweryn four miles upstream from Bala, creating a reservoir 8000 acres in size and submerging Capel Celyn a village with a chapel, a school, Post Office, burial ground and eight stone built houses. An earlier proposal to dam and flood Dolanog, home of hymn writer Ann Griffiths, had been dropped partly because the project would not have been able to meet Liverpool’s rising demand for supply.

A motion passed by the council on Wednesday 19th October reads

 “We realise the hurt of forty years ago when the Tryweryn Valley was transformed into a reservoir to help meet the water needs of Liverpool.

Protest sign
One of the protest signs

“For any insensitivity by our predecessor council at that time, we apologise and hope that the historic and sound relationship between Liverpool and Wales can be completely restored.”

The project was highly controversial and sparked numerous protests from the start. The Tryweryn scheme is often seen as a catalyst event in the campaign for Welsh independence. An act of Parliament was required for compulsory purchase orders and despite no Welsh MP voting for it the motion was pushed through the House of Commons.

Clashes at the opening
Clashes at the reservoir opening

Aeron Jones who was ten years old when his family had to leave their farm said “I would think that the fact that there is an apology shows that there is a change of heart in this latest generation in Liverpool. It’s come as a shock actually. But I would think in general it would be welcome. I wouldn’t guarantee that all that’s been done would be forgotten just by apology. The whole word ‘Tryweryn’ now to the Welsh nation sort of fires up a whole emotional issue.”

A Tryweryn Defence Committee was formed in 1956 and included prominent Welsh personalties including Lord Ogmore and Megan Lloyd George. Although the campaign had widespread backing and was not politically rooted it did inspire Plaid Cymru and in its campaigns.

Derelict buildings
Buildings are left derelict

In 1956 police were called to Liverpool Town Hall to eject three Welshmen, Alderman Gwynfor Evans, president of the Welsh National Party and Dr Tudor Jones and a 65 year old farmer David Roberts whose land and buildings were amongst those under threat. The men had left the strangers gallery to make protests in a passage behind the back benches. Once work was underway two men were fined for draining oil from a transformer at the site, while in 1963 an explosion damaged a transformer.

The situation was not helped by the high handed attitude of Liverpool officials, speaking to the The Times in 1956 on the subject of financial remuneration for the Welsh residents Liverpool’s deputy town clerk Mr Harvey said “Whose water is it? After all, God provided it.”

The reservoir today
The reservoir today

The opening ceremony on October 21st 1965 attracted numerous protests with 100 police officers on patrol as Alderman F.H. Cain, the chairman of Liverpool’s water committee opened a discharge regulator to start the flow of water. During the ceremony, attended by 400 guests, posters reading ‘Hands Off Wales’ were displayed and pieces of rock where thrown at Liverpool’s Lord Mayor and Chief Constable.

Decades later the effect of the project on English-Welsh relationships could still be felt in a 1998 House of Commons debate about the powers of the proposed new Welsh Assembly the Plaid Cymru MP Dafydd Wigley said “I do not need to impress on Ministers the significance of drowning the valleys and extracting water from Wales. The way in which the Liverpool corporation took the Tryweryn valley, kicked out the residents of Capel Celyn and created a reservoir to provide water for industry on Merseyside without any recompense is probably one reason why three of the four hon. Members representing Gwynedd are from Plaid Cymru, The significance of that for the Assembly is very great indeed.”

last updated: 19/10/05
Have Your Say
What do you think of the flooding of Capel Celyn? Add your comments here.
Your name: 
Your comment: 
The BBC reserves the right to edit comments submitted.

disgraceful. what a coincidence the apology coincides with their bid for the eisteddfod. stick your apology. From a welsh man waiting to be delt the next humiliating, demoralizing blow from English hands.

There is a long term water shortage problem in Manchester. Manchester Council have looked at a variety of options. They favour building a huge man made reservoir where the city of Liverpool stands today. This will be a 30foot embankment encircling the lower parts of the city and water will be stored there from the Mersey, then the water will be pumped to Manchester. Each resident will be provided with a caravan located on land on the outskirts of the city and £5,000 compensation per head. Children will be educated in marquees provided. Work will be provided to all in surrounding farms. Cofia Lerpwl!

Get a grip guys. Im Welsh, living in Lpool, and regardless of this village being flooded (terrible I agree), it wouldnt change the large chip on their shoulders that a lot of Welsh people have towards the English! Oh, and Eilir, please I hope your not serious. I personally think this gesture is pointless. its like the current council apologising for the militant 1980s Liverpool council for the way it ruined this city - there would be no point- the damage would have already done!

Hey Jonathan Tasker, got news for you, Wales have had their own Government for about 4 years now!!

Jonathan Tasker.
An apology too late. The damage is done and never forgotten. Its not the people of Liverpool I blame but the arrogance of the English politicians who obviously felt Wales is an inferior country. When O when will Wales have its own Government and then we can charge them for the water they so desperatly wanted.

Mrs Garden
I think that post event apologies by the council (for most if not all of whom were not even in politics) just act as empty gesture. We cannot change the past, but only look ahead. I have been disgusted at how many times various apologies have been issued - for the slave trade for example, HOW does that change anything? MOVE ON and stop apologising for things we cannot change. Hollow gestures.

eilir williams
Thanks for the apology . Now right your wrong - take it down , remove it , and let the people of Capel Cely move back

An apology is a start,however all those people should have proper compensation for the forced move at 2005 prices and with all the infalationary interest! In the USA the native americans got huge payouts from injustices in the forced move to reservations from their native lands in the 1800's. If compensation lawyers get a hold of this one the Welsh could be finacially compensated in the blame culture of 2005!

Go to the top of the page

About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy