BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

18 June 2014
Accessibility help
Text only
Legacies - South-West Scotland

BBC Homepage
 Legacies
 UK Index
 South-West Scotland
 Article
Listings
Your stories
 Archive
 Site Info
 BBC History
 Where I Live

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 
Myths and Legends
Sawney Bean: Scotland's Hannibal Lecter

King James VI
© SCRAN
The story unfortunately falls down, as there is no official record of there ever being an Alexander Bean anywhere. Not surprising in an era before censuses you might think, but there are absolutely no records of the trial or execution of the Beans, something which surely would have aroused great public interest.

This leaves us with the question of why anyone would make up such a horrific story, and who would be behind it? While the tale undoubtedly had currency around Ayrshire as a bogeyman type tale, the story first appears in print in pamphlets printed in Eighteenth Century England. This was the time of the Jacobite risings and Scots were regularly portrayed in a bad light in the English press at this time, either ridiculing them or giving a sinister edge to the Scottish character.

The story of Sawney Bean would have been a godsend to anti-Scottish propagandists south of the border, eager to portray their northern neighbours as ignorant and capable of any depravity. As Fiona Black notes in The Polar Twins:

"The monstrous figure of Sawney, as written history, was probably an English invention. Cannibalism has a long history as a means of political propaganda used by a dominant culture against those they want to colonise; as an English invention Sawney may be considered as a colonial fiction written to demonstrate the savagery and uncivilised nature of the Scots in contrast to the superior qualities of the English nation."




Pages: Previous [ 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ] Next


Your comments

1 Jan Gillies from Logan, Cumnock, East Ayrshire - 19 December 2003
"Great story, hard to believe but probably true, even if there is no documented proof."




Print this page
Archive
Look back into the past using the Legacies' archives. Find nearly 200 tales from around the country in our collection.

Read more >
Internet Links
Scottish Archives Network
–Visit the knowledge base for information on Sawney Bean
Gazetteer for Scotland
Local history weblinks from Ayrshire libraries
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Web sites.
Highland
A Victorian view of Ossian
Related Stories
Witch finder general
Spring Heeled Jack
The gibbetting of Spence Broughton




About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy