BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page was last updated in April 2009We've left it here for reference.More information

28 May 2012
Accessibility help
Text only

BBC Homepage

Local BBC Sites

Neighbouring Sites

Related BBC Sites


Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 

Your island

You are in: Jersey > People > Your island > Tackling anti-social behaviour

Youth

Tackling anti-social behaviour

Can Jersey make its streets safer by clamping down on teenage drinking, or introducing ASBOs?

Underage drinking, it is a problem that has always been there. But according to some it has got worse and, coupled with growing levels of violence, vandalism and disorder, reflects how our society is changing.

But what can society do about the problem? Many people would like to see a heightened police presence in our town at night.

St Helier already has a number of CCTV cameras at high profile trouble-spots like the Weighbridge, but does more need to be done? 

Off licence clampdown

Deputy Kevin Lewis is keen for Jersey to follow an idea that is being trialled in Scotland, namely to ban the sale of alcohol from shops and off-licences to those under the age of 21.

Deputy Lewis said: “The problems with the young people in and around town are alcohol fuelled. If we are going to hit somebody we need to hit these shops that are selling drink to young people.

“There are people over the age of 18 buying alcohol for young people and there are a few unscrupulous shops that are selling alcohol to young people.

Shelves in an off-licence

Alcohol - only sold to over 21s?

“In my book, anyone caught doing it should have there licence revoked and never get it back.”

ASBOs

The Anti-Social Behaviour Order (ASBO) – championed by former Prime Minister Tony Blair and the then Home Secretary David Blunkett – hit the headlines in 2004. It was designed to target bad behaviour among young people.

However, the scheme has come under fire for criminalising children and doing little to tackle the root cause of the problem. It was something that Deputy Lewis said the States had looked at and rejected.

Chairman of the Safer St Helier Group Colin Russell said they didn’t work because they became something that young people collected. In essence, the ASBO was seen by some as a badge of honour.

Mr Russell was keen for young people to enter into something called an acceptable behaviour contract, or agreement, which would avoid the need to go to court. He explained how the system would work.

He said: “You sit down with them and explain how their actions have impacted on society and on other people. You write all those things down and you have an agreement with them or their parents which asks how are they going to change their behaviour? They and their parents actually sign this document as willing partners in this agreement.”

According to Mr Russell, the agreement would set out what was expected of the young person and the penalties they would receive if they broke it.

He continued: “It is different from an ASBO as an ASBO is an order. This is an agreement to curb their behaviour. Once it is written down and put in front of them by trained people from children’s services or probation services, they then have to reflect on that.”

Boy working at a punch ball

Boxing can have a positive influence

Good citizens

Boxing has been a traditional outlet for wayward youths to focus their energy. Head coach at South Hill gym Dave Thompson believes the sport can have a positive impact on young people.

Dave Thompson said: “We never advertise ourselves and the gym is full of kids. As much as parents are afraid of boxing, it is the most protected sport going. There is no other sport where you have a doctor in attendance.

“For forty years I had to fight education about boxing, now people realise how disciplined it is and important it is with bad behaviour.

“We see people talking about all the kids misbehaving in town. At South Hill, we develop the kids into good citizens. I am very proud of the club’s record that over 55 years we have had some very good citizens of Jersey and they have all come through South Hill.”

‘Pussyfooting’

The issue provoked strong opinions from the public. Speaking on the BBC’s Talkback program, one caller named John had this to add: “It is all very well saying we can’t do this or that because they might have a complex for the rest of their lives, they need dealing with.

“I know the magistrates have been crying out to have the law changed so people can be dealt with. They could have a record, and if they behave themselves for two or three years then that record gets wiped.

Phone box in Birstall

Some believe vandalism is increasing

“It doesn’t need to stay with them for the rest of their lives. We have got to stop this pussyfooting about and deal with this.”

Colin Russell disagreed saying any punitive measures taken against children needed to be in proportion, even if it included habitual offenders.

He said: “If we start hammering everyone exactly the same we will end up with a load of young people who have criminal records attached to them for a bit of wanton destruction, which they shouldn’t have done.”

Colin Russell agreed that removing alcohol from the equation was the way forward.

Deputy Lewis added the States were desperately trying not to criminalise a small number of people.

He said: “It is finding the correct way forward that is going to be the problem. We can’t lock everybody up, that is for sure. We are trying desperately not to criminalise young people. It is small minority, but as you quite rightly point out, it only takes a small minority to devastate the island.

The youngsters now have human rights and they know it too. One of our local headmasters said they know their rights, but they don’t know there responsibilities.”

Have your say

Should people have to be over 21 before they can buy alcohol? Do we need more CCTV cameras in town? Are ASBOs the answer, or do you think a good behaviour contract would work better? How would you like to see the problem tackled?

last updated: 20/04/2009 at 13:44
created: 20/04/2009

Have Your Say

The BBC reserves the right to edit comments submitted.

Nicola - Louise
Society has made kids the way they are today. They can't do this or that - Health & Safety laws. They can spit in your face etc etc yet you cannot give them a clip across the ear. They run rings round the law & the older generation as they know they can get away with it. If they are big enough to stick a knife in someone then they are big enough to get a slap & a 12yr sentence in an adult prison, but no they get wrapped up in cotton wool with a tap on the back. Society is a joke!!

enna
The only real way to solve the a/s behaviour is to make these children work to clean up the streets and to make them wear the brightest overalls so they are so humiliated in front of their piers,relations and public it would make them think twice before re-offending. The punishment MUST effect the offenders time and liberty, not their parents pockets. Jersey must deal with all offenders in their own harsh way and not bow to the UK's soft PC ways.

kim
get locked up greenfields is a great place to stay for a while a doddle

Sven
It's not that the kids have nothing to do, we have La Motte Street,Sport facilities like Skate Park, Surf Clubs etc. but if somethings done a few people always vadalize. We have bins along the beach and kids (people) still throw their rubbish on the ground, That's the story and it won't change if the laws don't change. If kids dump their rubbish let them clean the beaches, if they

Jason
a proper punishment scheme is needed like comunity service and offenders should have a curfew enforced jersey has a problem because there is nothing for these youths to do.I know if I had something that was exciting to do I wouldn't stand around on street corners drinking and causing trouble

Nikki
Yes a small number of the parents are to blame as thye are just as bad as the kids , TO those parents you are thier roll model, if you don't show them don't expect for anyone else to do this for you , they are your responsiblity not the states, kids do know right from wrong even (if this has to be taught in our excellent schools)It is only a small portion of our future generation who are the one's doing the bullying on our streets. DON'T let this affect the rest of the future generaion as they are the one's suffering. it is all down to bordom.No matter what the kids want to do there is a charge for this .State members get you hands in your pocket & ask the kids what they want on thier island , help distract them from bordom , many then maybe we will see a change in our FUTURE generantion.

Kim
Take their playstations, mobiles away and lock them up for a few weeks, taking is the solution not giving

June
I would like to enlarge on the idea put forward by Colin Russell that an acceptable behaviour contract will help young people.I believe that this should be done in context with those who can offer help to these young people - there are ample things going on in the Island.One only has to watch the Channel 4 programme 'Secret Millionaire' to look at what is being done througout the UK by dedicated people who set things up to keep these young people off the streets and away from drink aand drugs.

Stephen
Whilst we need measures to cure the problem of anti-social behaviour this should be linked to other interventions that provide alternative choices to youths, for example investment in youth clubs etc

BBoy Wind
Breakdance is the way forward, i'm bringing it to Jersey very soon. Karate and boxing have proved well in the past but these kids will only use the skills when drunk. It's better to dance against each other (battle) and amazing to watch rather than trade punches!

Mark
The UK's biggest problem is drinking, kids get it from their parents and it starts because pubs close too early and people drink faster because of this. Kids have everything and doing things that aren't aloud is exciting because they all have mobiles, pc, tv the newest fashion and it's nothing special to have everything.

J
“The problems with the young people in and around town are alcohol fuelled.”This is for fact a generalisation and cannot be tainted by the same cause.Why would you in sue and presume that all actions taken by younger people are one in the same ‘generalisation’ We are conditioned by our socal and financial upbringing and therefore you will see a general trend of those who offend. Why is this because of social conditioning, something that cannot be changed by laws or ASBO’s etc…. You need to tackle the route cause of the problem which is the families and their views on life. People wont commit crimes unless they lack something.“Boxing has been a traditional outlet for wayward youths to focus their energy”I agree karate boxing and judo are brilliant ways of letting out anger and energy, however our society and government is turning everyone into a bunch of nanny state whimps afraid of doing something non PC. I say do boxing and karate in every school and teach them a lesson in self control. Society fails because of the ever increasing social stratification and greed associated with modern living, this is the inevitable outcome of a capitalist society where we want more than we can get so violence and damage ensues to rise to a higher social status, and with kids that’s what it is the most rebellious one is mostly seen as the dominant figure.

You are in: Jersey > People > Your island > Tackling anti-social behaviour



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy