Water
divining |  | Does
all of Jersey's water come from the island's rainfall or is there an extra untapped
source, deep underground? |
Water diviningWater
is the blue oil of the future - a valuable resource that could become ever more
scarce because of climate change. A struggle for control of this vital
commodity has already started in the Channel Islands. Jersey simply doesn't
have enough water to go around. There is emergency back up - sea water
can be converted to drinking water but it's expensive. So is there an alternative? Inside
Out's Russell Labey goes back to his native Jersey to investigate a strange tale
of science versus sorcery involving water divining. Scarce commodity
Jersey
is water scarce - the island has a desalination plant and sea water can be converted
to drinking water. But this desalination plant, the first of its kind in
the northern hemisphere, uses a staggering 70 times more electricity than Jersey
reservoirs. Jersey States have been looking to introduce water regulation
measures for 15 years. Standing in their way has been a lobby consisting
of water diviners and borehole drillers.  | | George
Langlois - exponent of the art of water divining |
They claim
that Jersey doesn't need new regulations because the island is sitting on vast
reserves of water replenished by underground streams from France. Many Jersey
people, including prominent politicians, have long held this belief. The
latest and greatest exponent of the ancient art of water divination in Jersey
is George Langlois.
George claims to have a 100% record in detecting water
and few dispute his skills. But his theory concerning where it comes from
has put him at odds with the geological establishment.
At the centre of
the argument is a question that is taxing the finest minds.
Does all of
Jersey's water come from the island's rainfall, or is there, as George Langlois
claims, an extra untapped source, deep underground? Science versus sorceryWater
divining | Water divining is also known as
dowsing and water witching. The term describes practices to find water and metal
through the fluctuation of the divining rod or device. Devices for water
divining include using Y-shaped rods, pendulums or twigs. Some proponents do not
use apparatus but 'feel' reactions to the presence of water. Divining
has existed for thousands of years. One of the earliest uses was for divination
reasons - to divine the will of the gods, to foresee the future and divine guilt
or innocence during trials. The Greek word rhabdomancy, shows that they
practised the art of divining. Divining was also widely used during the
Middle Ages. However, it wasn't without controversy. In 1659 it was declared Satanic
by the Jesuit Gaspar Schott. Today's form of divining is believed to have
started in Germany during the 15th Century to find metals. Its use spread to England
with German miners working in the coal mining industry. The American Marines
and Army are believed to have used dowsing to locate weapons and tunnels during
the Korean War and the Vietnam War. Divining can also be used for
searching for underground features and archaeological remains, oil, mineral ore,
and sometimes missing persons. |
George Langlois believes
that Jersey is sitting on top of millions of gallons of unused water - which come
not from rain that fell on Jersey - but elsewhere. He believes it reaches
here through underground streams. But the government's top geologists have
spent years studying the island and according to them it's a scientific impossibility.
You'd
think that with the weight of geological opinion stacked against George and his
supporters, Jersey States would push ahead with new water regulation - but, no.
Jersey States' Deputy, Sarah Ferguson, puts her trust in George Langlois. She
thinks that before water restrictions are imposed, his theory should be tested. So
the Jersey authorities asked George to identify a couple of places where he believes
deep water is coming in from France. Water from the Jersey boreholes was
then taken to the BGS labs in Wallingford for testing. At the labs the
analysts can tell whether the water they have collected is likely to have come
from rainfall on Jersey or from the hills of France. The latter would have
less of the rare oxygen-18 isotope If George is right, this extra, deep
water would make stricter regulations unnecessary. Conclusive evidence?So
what do the results show? The samples they found bore the same isotopic
fingerprint as Jersey rainwater, different from water that would have fallen on
French hills, which is where the diviners and borehole drillers claimed it fell.
Regulation is now imminent. But the diviners and drillers claim
foul so what's next?  | | Water
divining - can it really identify hidden reserves? |
New water
regulations are now on imminent. So is this the end of the matter? The
scientists say there's no French deep water under Jersey, but George is having
none of it and thinks the test drilling just didn't go deep enough
The
scientists appear to have proved George conclusively wrong. But it's going
to take a while for Jersey folk to give up a legend which they've clung onto for
generations. Links relating to this story:The BBC is not responsible for the content
of external websites |