BBC HomeExplore the BBC
Just to let you know, we're no longer updating this site. More information here

17 July 2009
Accessibility help
Text only
Inside Out: Surprising Stories, Familiar Places

BBC Homepage
England
Inside Out
East
East Midlands
London
North East
North West
South
South East
South West
West
West Midlands
Yorks & Lincs
Go to BBC1 programmes page (image: BBC1 logo)

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 
   Inside Out Extra: Monday March 21, 2005

CAR CLONING - YOUR NUMBER'S UP

Car number plates
Cloned plates fool congestion charge cameras

High fuel prices, traffic jams, parking costs and fines - British motoring doesn't come cheap. And if you live in the capital, there's the largely despised congestion charge to contend with too.

But for some motorists, driving has become even more of an expensive luxury.

Hundreds of pounds worth of congestion charges, speeding and parking fines have been landing on the doormat of innocent motorists.

So who has been racking up these fines and charges how are they getting away with it?

Inside Out enters the murky world of the ringer to find out.

The world of the ringer

Car cloners or "ringers", as they are known, are motoring bandits. They spot a hapless motorist, note the number-plate of the car, then get duplicate plates made.

Sporting the new plates, they cruise the streets with impunity.

Meanwhile, the unwitting motorist is watching fines and charges hit the "wipe your feet" mat at home.

This is just the situation Leon Ruiz found himself in.

Personal experience

Leon Ruiz
Whilst Leon takes the train, his cloned plates clock up bills

Leon journeys regularly in and out of London, but he takes the leisurely train.

Meanwhile, his car, or should we say, a car with his number-plates, has been equally as regularly triggering the congestion charge cameras.

Leon says "I was quite amused with the first one that turned up. I had heard of this sort of thing happening.

"But, by the end of the week, I had four of them."

Leon now has a very expensive doormat. He reckons that if he had paid all of them, it would have spiralled to £8,000.

And it wasn't just congestion charges that he was receiving.

"This guy went into the congestion charge zone, to my knowledge, no fewer than 28 different occasions," says Leon.

"He also got two speeding tickets on the M62 for speeding through roadworks that I got the benefit of," he says, with tongue firmly in cheek.

John Cahill
"I jumped out of bed, looked out of the window and there was someone pointing a gun at me."
John Cahill

Wake-up call with a difference

John Cahill was also a victim of car cloning, but it wasn't a parking fine that landed on his doorstep, it was an armed police squad.

John's car had supposedly been used as a getaway vehicle in an armed robbery, making John the prime suspect.

With the house surrounded by armed officers, John was escorted to the police station.

He was released after five hours when police confirmed his alibi.

They now knew that another cloned car was out on the road and the perpetrators of the crime were ringers.

Pick a number

Congestion charge bills
Congestion charges could be landing on your door mat

In order to get a pair of plates, or even one for that matter, the law demands that you provide your registration document with proof of identity.

But with some dodgy dealers, law goes out the window.

They will provide number-plates over the counter for a few used notes without that vital documentation.

Essentially, there are three in the chain.

The user of the dodgy plates, the supplier of the plates and the plate manufacturer - all equally as culpable in the dirty deed.

How to avoid buying a cloned car

Advice to anyone considering purchasing a used car privately:

Always have sight of the registration document V5 prior to purchasing a used vehicle.

Be satisfied that the seller owns the vehicle or is entitled to offer it for sale.

Ask the seller for proof of identity.

View the vehicle at the address shown on the registration document.

Check the vehicle identification number (VIN) - sometimes called the chassis number - corresponds with the number on the registration document.
This number can usually be found on a metal plate under the bonnet.

If you have limited knowledge of vehicles take an experienced person with you.

Be wary of handing over cash to someone who has been contacted through a mobile number.

Check if the vehicle has been seriously damaged, notified as stolen or is subject to outstanding finance.

The following companies provide this service for a fee - Carwatch UK Limited (Vehicle History Check) - 0870 010 7899*, Experian (Car Data Check) - 0870 6000 838* and HPI Limited - 01722 422 422.

If anyone is offered a vehicle for sale accompanied by one of the stolen registration documents, you should contact the police immediately.

Source: DVLA

Stopping this practice would be easy - if those who supply them to the public would play the game. But this is a game with no rules.

So, to hunt them out, the Inside Out team goes undercover.

On the trail

The team's reporter, Paul, finds that Tower Hamlets Council has been losing thousands of pounds in honestly earned (if that's not too far from the truth) parking fines.

His suspicions of the reasons why are confirmed. The ringers.

Paul visits a dealer he has been tipped off about in Stratford.

For £30, Paul buys a pair of plates that, in a fairly short space of time, could have saved him hundreds of pounds - if he had been that way inclined.

When Inside Out confronts the shop in Stratford they say they hadn't sold us the plates.

They also add that they weren't aware until recently that they needed to fully check the ID of a purchaser of a blank plate.

Unenforceable

With car cloning escalating and the police seemingly powerless to prevent the sale of false plates, the likelihood of becoming a victim is rising rapidly.

So if your letterbox is groaning with congestion charge bills, fines and other dubious financial delights of motoring - and the car has been nailed to the floor in the garage all the time - you may have become the latest victim of the ringers.

See also ...

On Inside Out:
Car cloning West Midlands
Car cloning North East
Mobile speed cameras
Pushing the limits

On bbc.co.uk
BBC Motoring
BBC Topgear

On the rest of the web
Drivers and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA)
Motoring

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites

Inside Out Archive

Inside Out Extra
View our story archive to see articles from previous series.

BBC Where I Live

Find local news, entertainment, debate and more ...

England

Meet your
Inside Out
presenter
Go to our profile of Morland Sanders (image: Morland Sanders)

Morland Sanders
your Inside Out Extra presenter.

Contact us
Contact the Inside Out Extra team with the issues that affect you.

Free email updates

Keep in touch and receive your free and informative Inside Out updates.
Subscribe
Unsubscribe

 

Readers' Comments

We are not adding any new comments to this page but you can still read some of the comments previously submitted by readers.

Andrew michaels
I was in Cyprus and my car locked in my garage, when my daughter rung to say that among other mail, there was a Congestion charge in the post! Knowing how these charges escalate on no payment, I had it faxed over to me, and subsequently paid with my Cypriot Visa Card, From Cyprus, over the internet. As i said earlier, the car was indeed nailed to the garage floor and Immobilised by removing the connection off the coil. On my return to the UK, Bingo, another ticket arrived. I thought that the best course of action is to do absolutely nothing! I was armed with airline tickets and alibis, and just sat tight and waited. Is 16 months to the date, and i have not heard a wisper! Normally, that is not the case. Has anyone ever been caught and if so, why my "keep the peace" money has not been returned?

lee
my car has been cloned aswell in my own town lots of people said they had seen it and i spotted it myself the next day a man stopped me and said his brother had the same car and that i had cloned his car i told him i got the car on a LN52 plate and had put my own number plate on it i phoned the police and was advised they would phone me back and yes days later im still waiting for that call

Marcus Vallance
I too have been a victim of car "cloning" and really suprised how common sense does not prevail amongst are Police force. 1) I had a Conjestion Charge notice land on my door mat - I alerted the Met Police who were not interested, eventually charges dropped. 2) I recieved a speeding fine (from the Met Police)for an offence that occurred before I even owned the car (a simple check on the DVLA database would have cleared this one up), to add insult to injury after the Police tried prosecuting the garage who I brought the car off had got nowhere they then chased me, eventually charges were dropped. 3) I am currently in discussion with Southwark Council about an alledged parking instance. To date I have not recieved an apology from anyone which I find very disturbing. One of the main problems is there is no common database to log suspicious number plates and therefore the Police, Councils and Congestion Charge people can work together (teamwork I think it is called) to catch these criminals.

amirah chohan
I have also been a victim of car cloning. i became suspicious when i started to receive speeding tickets from london and areas where i had never been to. i then contacted the police and explained the situation. luckily they had previously stoped a man that was speeding and had the same number plate has me but when the police carried out a check on the owners details mine came up and they didnt match the drivers details. he was arrested.

Connie Thompson
My husband had his car number plate cloned about 9 years ago, we didnt know anything about it until the police turned up at our door and said it had been used in a ram raid. We had to take them down our garage and prove it had not been used that day.

Simon Fulton
Whilst I agree that the company shouldn't have disobeyed the rules, the fact is that if someone is "that way inclined" to use false plates in the first place why would they bother to pay for them? Especially when all they need is a phillips screwdriver and about 2 seconds to take the plates of your car (as has happened in the past). As far as I can see this scheme's only benefit that was introduced by Labour is just a way of getting £50 a year for the registration forms off of anyone that sells No. plates and putting a lot more government bums on seats trying to keep track off all the ever esculating paperwork.

Shakes
This type of crime is virtually impossible to prevent. Are there any tips of preventing cloning? The back of my car was photographed using a camera phone while on the motorway - I am waiting for the fines to arrive.

Dennis John Verity
I have received two notifications from Boroughs in London .One for Congestion charge last year and one for parking in Southwark inJanuary this year . My car has never been in London and I have notified the authorities of this but perhaps my Plates have been cloned.

Keith Power
In Poland they have a simple system of local vehicle licensing offices where a car has to be registered (as we had in the UK before the DVLA existed). A change of ownership must alos be completed at the relevant local office in person. When a car is registered, two numberplates are issued with security halograms. These are issued along with a halogram protected window sticker that it is non-removable. If you lose a number plate (as I did driving through a flooded street) the car has to be re-registered with a new number. Copy numberplates and window stickers are simply NOT PERMITTED. Likewise, if your windescreen needs to be refitted due to cracks/breakage etc, then the original sticker is not reusable and again re-registration and issue of a new number is required. This is a bureaucratic process of course and time consuming if you are unlucky enough to need to re-register but it has almost eradicated previously rampant car-cloning. A version of this system could do the same for the UK maybe?



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy