The origins of BBC local radio
BBC radio can trace its local roots back to the early days of the organisation in the 1920s. Originally the British Broadcasting Company oversaw a network of local, separate stations, which were connected to London by telephone links and 'simultaneous broadcasting' (or networking as it would be called today). These
nine stations were based in London, Manchester, Birmingham, Newcastle, Glasgow, Cardiff, Aberdeen, Bournemouth and Belfast. Each station covered about twenty miles in radius – although the exact distance depended whether one was listening on a valve or crystal set. The focus was very much on showcasing local talent.
However, as the Company became a Corporation these early local stations were gradually replaced by the 'Regional Scheme.' From 1929 onwards, national output from London was complemented by six Regional services for London and the South-East, Birmingham and the Midlands, the North of England, Scotland, Wales and the West of England and Northern Ireland. The only problem was, these regions were defined not by the people, places and characteristics of the geographical areas, but by the physical landscape that determined where the transmitters could be sited.
By the 1950s, local broadcasting as a modern concept became a more viable technical prospect with the development of Very High Frequency (or VHF) which allowed a network of transmitters to cover the country and made small-scale local stations a possibility once more.
The vision of the BBC's local radio dream came from one man, Frank Gillard. He was a former war correspondent, and worked for the BBC in the West Region. During the 1950s he made several visits to America and Canada, and saw first hand the potential benefits of local radio. He summed this up as "aiming to present on the air, and in many different forms and through a multitude of local voices, the running serial story of local life in all its aspects".
Between 1961 and 1962 the BBC carried out a series of 'closed-circuit' (ie not broadcast) trials, to test the possibilities of local broadcasting in sites across the UK. These helped Gillard and others formulate how local radio might work in practice, in terms of staffing, facilities and resources, accommodation, station locations, programmes and schedules etc.
Ironically, it was pirate radio that provided the stimulus for local radio to be given the go-ahead. The Labour Government outlawed the pirates in December 1966, and to offer an alternative, the BBC re-organised the networks into Radios 1, 2, 3 and 4. At the same time, the BBC was granted permission to have a two-year experiment with eight local radio stations in England.
The first BBC stations
Despite being authorised to start local radio, there was no licence fee money to pay for it. The government and the BBC devised a method of alternative funding.
The BBC would pay for setting up the stations but local authorities would be encouraged to meet the running costs. However, they weren't allowed to put up the local rates to raise this money. Not surprisingly, this limited the number of places willing to come forward to host and co-fund a station. Michael Barton (who was appointed the first Station Manager at Radio Sheffield) recalls Frank Gillard 'working the [local authorities] like Jeffrey Archer running a charity auction' in an effort to drum up support. The Sunday Times called the process 'an astonishing three-stage Dutch auction'.
Eight locations were eventually chosen to take part in this experiment: Radio Leicester (which launched on 8 November 1967); Radio Sheffield (15 November 1967); Radio Merseyside (22 November); Radio Nottingham (31 January 1968); Radio Brighton (14 February); Radio Stoke-on-Trent (14 March); Radio Leeds (24 June); Radio Durham (3 July).
So what did these early stations sound like? Each Station Manager had a considerable amount of autonomy with the way they ran their schedules. They all settled on a breakfast news programme with similar programmes at lunchtime and in the early evening. Most stations produced a programme aimed at their female audience in mid-morning and there were also locally-made educational and schools programmes.
The stations were only expected the supply four or five hours a day of their own output: the remainder would come from either Radio Two or Four, or sometimes Radio One.
But the stations soon exceeded expectations, especially with a range of shows aimed at specialist and niche audiences and communities. These ranged from amateur dramatics, to gardening shows, from oral history to teenagers' debates.
Owen Bentley, Programme Assistant at Stoke-on-Trent, recalls a particular minority programme: 'The Esperanto Family Robinson', which involved a local headmaster recording conversations with his family in Esperanto in their front room on an old Ferrograph machine, which Owen then edited down.
Interestingly there was no expectation for the first stations to produce their own news content. Local news agencies provided stories for most of them: Radio Merseyside worked out a deal with the Liverpool News and only Radio Leeds (after battles with BBC management) were allowed to recruit their own reporters.
Although the stations were working hard to connect with their local listeners and encouraging them to get involved, it was difficult to build the audience. This was partly because local radio was only available on VHF in these early years. This meant buying a new radio for most families - although some could listen via their television sets using the relay system provided by Rediffusion and others.
The fragmented schedule, with a wide variety of different programmes, made it hard for listeners to find their favourite shows.
There were other obstacles too. In many locations, the local press were either disdainful or - in Leicester's case - downright hostile, fearing competition in the news market. The Station Manager at Radio Leeds, Phil Sidey, claimed that the only way he got his station's name in the local paper was to buy a greyhound called 'Radio Leeds' and get it into race reports!
As this story suggests, Sidey was a dab hand at getting publicity. He managed to get prominent national press for his station with 'beer gargling' competitions and singing budgerigars. Unfortunately this wasn't always the type of coverage his colleagues wanted and local radio soon earned the sobriquet 'toy town radio'.
But accusations of triviality were laid aside as local radio came into its own when the weather turned bad. Radio Leicester earned plaudits during the floods of July 1968, as did Radios Brighton and Merseyside when heavy snow fell in December 1967 and February 1968 respectively.
Gradually more and more examples emerged of how the stations were responding to the social and community needs of their localities, so that by the time Radio Nottingham had an open day, 3,000 visitors came through their doors.
During 1969. the government and the BBC compiled research into the experiment and it was agreed that the BBC could continue with local radio on a permanent basis and permission was given for the creation of 12 more stations, making 20 in total.
However, the future was far from secure, when a Conservative government was elected the following year, committed to the introduction of independent commercial local radio.
The story today
Having passed its fortieth anniversary, it's apt that there are now 40 stations covering the length and breadth of England. In terms of listeners, local radio's fortunes have varied in recent years. Some stations (such as Radio Lincolnshire, Radio Cornwall and BBC London 94.9) are steadily increasing their audience share and weekly reach. Overall, the audience for BBC local (and regional) radio hovers around 9 million listeners each week, but the last five years has seen it lose over half a million listeners, as it faces competition from commercial radio and new community stations.
The ideology of local radio has similarly undergone many changes in the last forty years, with evening schedules featuring programmes that are shared around a number of stations on a regional basis.
This principle is now being extended, on a pilot basis, to daytime programmes; for example in Radios Leeds, York and Sheffield, where they are broadcasting the same afternoon show. It's argued this will enable stations to target resources more effectively at key times such as breakfast and mid-mornings.
Local radio faces many challenges ahead, including budget constraints with the frozen licence fee, increased competition for local audiences and the need to serve the existing demographic and nurture the next generation of future listeners. Despite new developments, the BBC still stresses that local radio will continue to serve its local communities.
Dr Matthew Linfoot Director of Undergraduate Media, and Course Leader in Radio Production at the University of Westminster.