bir x kisisi
lovely :)
ENG Dept
The Mozart
didn't work.
Nice idea -
but confused
execution.
Paul Vortex
Nice qualities.
Gekko.
That really
worked being
in black and
white. The
music and
the 'silent
movie'
approach also
really
worked... and
i liked the
cat being
labelled.
sonia
i really
liked that it
was simply
great
parker
The semiotics
of the
cat???!!
really?!
The cat was
there
becausehe had
a catand it
seemed to be a
way to end
itas much as
things going
on as usual.A
bitunsure..
Cristina
I think it
was great!!
the music was
fab and the
semiotics of
the cat is
well done.
good luck at
uni!
Joe Forrest
Thanks Moi.
I'm going to
explain the
cat that
confuses a few
of you.
By cutting to
the cat at the
end I am
trying to say
that despite
lifes little
tiffs,
arguments or
whatever, life
still goes on,
be it through
the life of a
cat or
something else.
Hope this
means
something.
Moi
I know nothing
of films -but
a little about
life..Joe,
don't cow-tow
to the
people...you'll
be running
around trying
to please
everyone..IMPOS
SIBLE! Stay
oringinal,
it's enough!
BWG
Go more
abstract. J-
LG? This was
more BFG.
Jump cuts?
Conflicting
sound and
pictures? Get
more
interesting.
Jess
A great short
movie i really
liked it
thanks.
Manchester
I dont see the
point in the
cat other than
to break up
the tension
between the
boy and girl.
With simple
films a simple
message should
be easily put
across, it
wasnt't done
that well
here. Have a
look at the
film 'Tickling'
Peter
Visually not
bad, but even
Godard uses
dialogue.
Have you
seen Eloge de
L'Amour? I
haven't made
my mind upm
about it yet.
ana
Wanted to see
more of the
cat!
Joe Forrest
Thanks for
everyone's
comments. I'm
currently
working on a
new One-
Minute movie
and don't
know whether
to make it
more
mainstream
(to get
better
reviews) or
to go
abstract
again (to
further prove
my point!)
Drama King
I think this is
good precisely
because nothing
in particular
happens. It is
like a snapshot
of youth: the way
brothers and
sisters get on
each others
nerves and how
they express
themselves. The
music and black
and white shots
give it the
nostalgic edge it
needs. Good
one.
Benson
Just stick to
watching
films!!!
This one was
totally
utterlly
boring garbage
Cooperman
Maybe
something
interesting
could happen
in your next
film?
joshua kane
i am stunned
by the
blandness.
yep
hmm its
alrite a bit
more
creativity
woudlnt go
amiss.
Taz
A little twee
for my tastes
Ant
great. some
lovely shots
in there and
the
performers
were
obviously
directed in a
competent
manner
manner. nice
work
Steve Richardson
A sweet
glimpse of a
family--in
minature. I
miss my own
sister, and
someday this
guy will miss
his. Good
work.
elfisho
that cat seems
to play no
part in
this...good
music though!
