Reviewer's Rating 2 out of 5   User Rating 2 out of 5
The Punisher (2004)
18Contains strong and sadistic violence

A comicbook action movie with an unpleasant edge, The Punisher stars bland beefcake Thomas Jane as Frank Castle - a cop left for dead by the gun-toting thugs of money-laundering criminal Mr Saint (John Travolta). Angry and out for revenge, Castle transforms himself into black-clad vigilante villain-killer The Punisher and starts blowing people to bits. "This is not vengeance... but punishment," he argues. Um, no, it is vengeance and a pretty nasty one at that.

The directorial debut of Die Hard: With A Vengeance screenwriter Jonathan Hensleigh, The Punisher shows the odd glimmer of wit, but it's largely an unrepentant wallow in bloody violence. There are some enjoyable elements: a bone-crunching battle with a Russian lunk, Castle's geeky surrogate family and X-Men's Rebecca Romijn-Stamos as a token love interest.

"BRAINLESS BRUTALITY"

Not that Frank is very interested in her. He's a grim-faced man's man, who shuns girly emotions in favour of taking enemies apart. To that end, Jane frowns throughout, looking like a petulant male model with bowel problems. He's a damn sight better than Travolta, though, who extends even his low standards with a lifeless, charm-free take on a lifeless, charm-free character. Cartoon villainy is supposed to be fun, but the Pulp Fiction star looks like a haddock sucking a lemon (where's Alan Rickman when you need him?).

There is definitely an audience for this sort of brainless brutality and fans of Arnold Schwarzenegger's high bodycount heroics in movies like Commando will be satisfied. But you worry about the mentality of the people who made this picture. And while The Punisher rarely feels like a punishment, it never feels like a reward.

End Credits

Director: Jonathan Hensleigh

Writer: Jonathan Hensleigh, Michael France

Stars: Thomas Jane, John Travolta, Will Patton, Laura Harring, Rebecca Romijn-Stamos

Genre: Action, Thriller

Length: 123 minutes

Cinema: 24 September 2004

Country: USA

Cinema Search

Where can I see this film?

New Releases