BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

28 October 2014

BBC Homepage

»[an error occurred while processing this directive] 

Contact Us

Bigger Picture

15 Citizen Verdict (2003)
Reviewed by Jamie Russell
updated 10th September 2003

reviewer's rating
two star


Philippe Martinez

Philippe Martinez
Tony Clarke
Kristina Hamilton
Frank Rehwaldt

Armand Assante
Jerry Springer
Roy Scheider
Justine Mitchell

98 minutes

Georgia Films

12th September 2003



User Comments & Reviews
» Read other users' reviews
» Write your own review

"Watch, vote and execute... all in the name of justice," reads the tagline of this thriller about a reality TV show that lets the viewing public play the jury in a real life murder trial. Chances are that if the makers of this tosh were in the dock themselves, whole auditoriums of disgruntled cinemagoers would vote to pull the switch and watch 'em fry.

The set-up of this not-as-clever-as-it-thinks-it-is satire is a dumbed-down disaster: take one accused murderer, put him in the dock on TV, and let the viewing public decide whether he's guilty or innocent.

Preparing to save the first victim, ahem, defendant is defence attorney Sam Patterson (Armand Assante). His counterpart is sharp-dressing prosecutor Jessica Landers (Justine Mitchell), who hopes to convince the audience that the man in the dock is guilty enough to die for his crimes.

With a $19.99 pay-per-view execution ready to go live, it's easy to guess what the verdict has to be.

What follows is yet another hackneyed warning about the dangers of Reality TV. It comes complete with a pantomime villain (Springer's cigar-chomping svengali), and concluding pledge of allegiance to the Star Spangled Banner - just so that no one takes the digs at America's legal system too seriously.

When Springer's not chomping cigars or scenery, Roy Scheider has a wheel-on role on as a state governor - a performance bad enough to suggest that someone needs to take better care of his medication.

Meanwhile Armand Assante proves to be a leading man who's labouring under the misapprehension that he's been hired as a character actor, growling his way through the risible script like the Rocky Balboa of defence attorneys: "You hang in there, you hear me!"

If this had been released five years ago, it might've seemed vaguely topical. Still no less ridiculous, though.

Bigger Picture

Bigger Picture

Bigger Picture

Find out more about "Citizen Verdict" at
Movie Review Query Engine
The Internet Movie Database
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites

 Where can I see this film? Here! 

About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy