BBC Home

Explore the BBC



Accessibility help
Text only
BBC Homepage
BBC Radio
BBC Radio 4 - 92 to 94 FM and 198 Long WaveListen to Digital Radio, Digital TV and OnlineListen on Digital Radio, Digital TV and OnlineListen Live Here

»Radio 4 Home
Programmes
Schedule
Podcasts
Message Board

Contact Us


Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 
New visitors:  Create your membership
Returning members:  Sign in
You are here > Radio 4 message boards > Deleted > Jenni Murray on spanking

Discussion:

Jenni Murray on spanking

Messages  1 - 20 of 198

 
First | < Previous 1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next > | Last
 

Message 1 - posted by suzeemoon (U3669767) , Jul 13, 2008

I was interested to see that Jenni Murray had commented on the Mosley case and our attitudes to diverse sexuality
www.guardian.co.uk/c...
I agree with her comments:
So why with sadomasochism, apparently enjoyed by significant numbers of consenting adults, should any guilt be attached to its practitioners? Perhaps, after Mosley, it won't be long before there's an affectionately received comedy character known as 'the only sadomasochist in the village'. There is little to be gained from a prudish silence about any form of sexual behaviour.

Quoted from this message



And being a Welsh Spanko have made 'the only sadomasochist in the village' comment myself among friends.

Meanwhile BDSM is seen as strange and it may be a while until people like me can feel safe that it is not an issue if you want to teach, nurse or work with vulnerable people. And as for the delightful men I know who are happier to give than receive...

That is why the case is important, absurd as it seems at times. And that is why I am out with a pseudonym in cyber and to friends only in everyday life.


Complain about a message       

Message 2 - posted by artistlily (U11263229) , Jul 13, 2008

suzeemoon, congratulations for having the courage and intelligence to write so well on such a topic.
In Australia, it is a fairly widely held perception of the British upper class that they like to have their bottoms smacked, a throw back from "nanny" etc. This is of course the cliche that haunts politicians, coupled with images of them dressing in black stockings and frilly aprons (and yes, I do mean males).
I have to ask you a question though, and I desperately hope it isnt offensive. Please trust me, it isnt meant to be, ok?
You have been very clear on your sexual tastes and your right to them. I support you wholeheartedly. However, I don't understand the need for public acceptance. Why do you have a problem with this being a covert activity rather than one which is "out there in the public eye"? May I, very very nervously, ask you, do you think maybe there is a touch of another fetish involved here, that of exhibitionism? Please don't be angry if I am wrong, and yet again I am not trying to be unkind, just understand.
I reckon any two consenting adults can do what they like between themselves. I just don't understand the need for "public acceptance".
suzeemoon, I am a rather fat woman. The public have a job accepting my fatness, but I have learned to say "oh well". I can't be bothered to "take them on".
I urge you to enjoy yourself and not worry about others perceptions. Love, lily x

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 3 - posted by suzeemoon (U3669767) , Jul 13, 2008

Lily,

That is a very reasonable question! I know many who are exhibitionistic and I don't think I am among them!

I talk about it (behind a pseudonym) because I think it is important that my kink is 'normalised' so it can't be used against me and others like me.
Imagine a male teacher working at a girls' school being 'outed' by his mischievous ex-girlfriend (for example)as someone who likes spanking women. Or a female psychiatrist who likes being tied up and whatever and has attended a dungeon party.

I don't need public acceptance to make me happy. I am deliriously so that I have a lover who suits me so perfectly (and I'm fat! laugh)

I honestly believe there is a rights issue here (my lover and others with kink disagree) and believe we are vulnerable as long as the gutter press can ruin lives over such cases. Acknowledging that BDSM and spanking are common and no big deal is way this will happen.

Does that make sense?

Always lovely to discuss things with you.

Suzee
xx

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 4 - posted by artistlily (U11263229) , Jul 13, 2008

It makes perfect sense sweetheart. You enjoy yourself. Life's short. Sending you a whopper hug. Lilyxxx

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 5 - posted by U12654725 (U12654725) , Jul 13, 2008

suzeemoon...for what it's worth i think your kink is perfectly harmless and innocent. i'm sure it's one you share with the great majority of feminists..hatchet-faced gimlet-eyed xenas in public, dying for a great sexy man with great sexy mitts to redden their rumps in the privacy of their sex fantasies. and then pour scorn and contempt on those same sexy macho men when back in public again- hypocrisy thy name is feminism.

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 6 - posted by justpeachy (U11179778) , Jul 13, 2008

In a similar vein, re public acceptance, I've often wondered why homosexuals feel the need to "come out".

People may disagree here, but the way I see it homosexuality is very widely accepted now - I just don't see it as a big deal. I'm interested in people for who they are, I really don't mind whether they prefer men or women or both, I just don't consider it any of my business what they're up to between the sheets.

So when someone announces to me that they're gay(when it has never even crossed my mind to consider whether they're heterosexual or otherwise, given that I'm not interested in them in that way), I just don't understand why it's important to them that I'm made aware of their sexuality.....

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 7 - posted by Fe2O3Girl (U2375233) , Jul 14, 2008


justpeachy, maybe gays feel the need to let others know of their orientation because it is about who they love, not about what particular activities happen in the bedroom.

Imagine going through life never mentioning your homelife or partner to your friends, neighbours or colleagues. Light social conversations involving "are you going on holiday this year?" or "doing anything nice this weekend?" would be a minefield.

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 8 - posted by justpeachy (U11179778) , Jul 14, 2008

Fe203Girl

You misunderstand me - I didn't mean they should keep their OH a secret! But why the big announcement? It would be like me arranging a get-together for family and friends to say "folks, I have something to tell you - I'm straight". Get my drift?!

If I work with a fella who's talking to me about what him & his OH, Geoff, did at the weekend, I'm gonna know they're gay anyway. There's no need for them to spell it out for me. That's the point I was making.... smiley

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 9 - posted by sthilda (U3612164) , Jul 14, 2008

justpeachy,its a social evolution-the conversation you describe is only possible because poeple came out in the announcing way. And there is still the issue of presumption,heterosexuality is presumed in all sorts of ways,conversation is predicated on it and when it isnt then we have discussions about 'pc'[not suggesting you are doing that btw]. for exmaple on the archers message board a poster said that a dr who character announced they were gay as evidnece that the wirter always had gay characters comeing out-in fact the line involved them using the term 'she' when referring to their back story and an unseen partner.
So the need for coming out will fade,but society is a long way from that imo.

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 10 - posted by headey (U2401200) , Jul 14, 2008

Forgive me for being frivolous, but I feel duty bound to share one of the gems from Humphrey Littleton's storehouse of remarks from "Clue"

"My nanny used to spank me and it didn't do me any harm. Though it did make me late for this performance."

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 11 - posted by Habook (U3328086) , Jul 14, 2008

Moseley is facing hostility and ridicule because of never to be forgotten family links to Fascism, the SM bit is just a conveniently salacious carrier to keep the story topical.

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 12 - posted by tipsytopsy (U2348087) , Jul 14, 2008

Must admit I find it strange that Moseley is suing on the basis that something that is private is not in the public interest and should be private, when the very act of suing ensures long-drawn out publicity and that anyone who didn't know before certainly will now, not to mention that his family, whom he said he acted to protect, are now suffering even more from a loss of privacy.

We could, I suppose talk about suing to establish a matter of principle and record, but I doubt Moseley and principles make very good bedfellows. Not when you consider that he was quoted in the S Times saying he felt "betrayed" by the woman who had gone public. I guess the irony of him having a hissy fit over being betrayed, while spending 40 years or more betraying his wife completely passed him by.......

I guess people in power live by different rules to mere mortals.....

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 13 - posted by sthilda (U3612164) , Jul 14, 2008

lol, I hadnt seen that ptt.yes irony seems to not be on the agenda there.

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 14 - posted by Fork (U10614516) , Jul 14, 2008

artistlily,
"I just don't understand the need for "public acceptance".

Unfortunately there are people and pressure groups who think that what consenting adults get up to is their concern as well.
news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/...

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 15 - posted by suzeemoon (U3669767) , Jul 14, 2008

suzeemoon...for what it's worth i think your kink is perfectly harmless and innocent. i'm sure it's one you share with the great majority of feminists..hatchet-faced gimlet-eyed xenas in public, dying for a great sexy man with great sexy mitts to redden their rumps in the privacy of their sex fantasies. and then pour scorn and contempt on those same sexy macho men when back in public again- hypocrisy thy name is feminism.

Quoted from this message



It was fear of such stupid comments and (worse!) the thinking behind them that kept me in the closet for so long. Being an erotic masochist, submissive and/or spankee does not mean one wishes to have less rights in everyday life or one is attracted to people who are domineering in their everyday behaviour.

I do not wish to be ruled by a macho man nor have macho men rule the world - That is just unfair.

I have an erotic fantasy and an alternative sexlife - That's all. I am absolutely feminist and absolutely a spankee.

I believe there is no more contradiction than if I were a male High Court Judge who liked getting caned or a male Cabinet Minister who liked sometimes being an adult baby.

I don't think I am a hypocrite and that's why I am having this conversation.

As too whether I am a hatchet-faced gimlet-eyed xena - Others will have to judge, but I suspect I'm too old, fat, relaxed and easily amused to qualify...

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 16 - posted by sthilda (U3612164) , Jul 14, 2008

plus suzee, I think xena would be pretty open abut being a spankee,dont you?

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 17 - posted by suzeemoon (U3669767) , Jul 14, 2008

Forgive me for being frivolous, but I feel duty bound to share one of the gems from Humphrey Littleton's storehouse of remarks from "Clue"

"My nanny used to spank me and it didn't do me any harm. Though it did make me late for this performance."

Quoted from this message



No forgiveness ever needed for quoting the great and sadly-missed Humph! And yes - one of my favourite lines too! laugh

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 18 - posted by suzeemoon (U3669767) , Jul 14, 2008

plus suzee, I think xena would be pretty open abut being a spankee,dont you?

Quoted from this message



And who would dare to refuse her?!winkeye
I think I once heard/read that Katherine the Great enjoyed being whipped... yikeslaugh

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 19 - posted by sthilda (U3612164) , Jul 14, 2008

well suzee, if you refused xena I think you would only do it once,kind of highlights the complexity huh?

This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       

Message 20 - posted by suzeemoon (U3669767) , Jul 14, 2008

I think it is rather hard to feel much empathy with Mosley, but I think he does actually have a point. There are many with such 'desires' who feel it unfair or unacceptable to act out stuff with their loved ones and so 'play away' from home. I'm not defending or judging - just saying it happens as with other sexual outlets/behaviours.

The NotW did blow his privacy and cause exposure to his innocent family. Of course he is prolonging the agony, by the case, but if he'd slunk away they'd have got away with it. If he wins, they may think twice before doing same to somebody else.

Of course he betrayed his wife, but most of us I suspect, feel let down by a 'betrayal' no matter how unworthy of loyalty we may be.



This is a reply to this message

Complain about a message       
First | < Previous 1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next > | Last
Getting Involved help: How to reply to messagesThis link opens in a new popup window
Complain help: Alert us about a messageThis link opens in a new popup window
Online Safety help: Are you being safe online?This link opens in a new popup window

Messages  1 - 20 of 198

 



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy