BBC Home

Explore the BBC

Front Page

 
Help!
   Life | The Universe | Everything | Advanced Search
Front Page
Read
Talk
Contribute
Feedback
Who is Online



New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in
This is the Conversation Forum for The Mary Celeste
<< All is revealed
Alone, Alone, All All Alone, Alone on a Wide Wide Sea >>


Already at Start of ConversationNo Older Postings to ShowNo Newer Postings to ShowAlready at End of Conversation
Postings 1-20

Conversation list


Most of the content on h2g2 is created by h2g2's Researchers, who are members of the public. The views expressed are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those of the BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of any external sites referenced. In the event that you consider anything on this page to be in breach of the site's House Rules, please click on the relevant button to alert our Moderation Team.


There is no Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Nov 30, 2000 by Zak T Duck
Post: 1

Aliens winkeye

Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Nov 30, 2000 by MDS
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 2

The Loch Ness Monster...

Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Nov 30, 2000 by Crescent, ACE
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 3

Phileas Fogg, well according to Philip Jose Farmer smiley Until later...
BCNU - Crescent


Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Nov 30, 2000 by PhilFogg (who may think that he is God. But God would never make the mistake of thinking that he is PhilFogg)
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 4

NOW what???

Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Nov 30, 2000 by Xanatic(phenomena phreak)
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 5

Hmm, I heard a plausible theory. The captains daughter fell into the water, and there were sharks. Everybody rushed to this terrasse like thing at the end of the ship, but because of the weight it broke and they all fell into the water. I donīt remember where I heard it, but look it up. I think there were eye-witnesses to the thing. And there are marks of what could be that terrasse thing.

Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Nov 30, 2000 by MDS
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 6

But then what happened to the life-boat ?

MDS


Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Nov 30, 2000 by Mikey the Humming Mouse - A3938628 Learn More About the Edited Guide!
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 7

obviously, the sharks ate the lifeboat, looking for an "after-dinner mint" after their huge meal.

smiley


Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Dec 1, 2000 by Saint Taco-Chako (P.S. of mixed metaphors)
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 8

Rye bread?

So how does everybody go insane at once, and all of them have the same idea?

If only half of them went insane, there should be signs of struggle.

It sounds about as probable as the aliens.


Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Dec 1, 2000 by Ashley
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 9

Contaminated rye bread is also a thoery behind why the people of Salem went bonkers which then lead on to the witch hunts.

Apparently....


Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Dec 1, 2000 by Xanatic(phenomena phreak)
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 10

Yeah, everybody went insane at the same time does seems rather weird. But I donīt see why insanity should take the blame for Salem. That was just humans being human. And thereby I mean being intolerant, ignorant xenophobic murderous bxxxxxxs.

Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Dec 1, 2000 by Ashley
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 11



The rye theory behind Salem is actually well documented. The witch hunts pursued people who were behaivng antisocially (visions, delusions etc). The staple in Salem at this time was a rye crop, which had failed for two years in a row and the store, which was being used, was believed to be contaminated with ergot - a fungus which can lead to a number of medical catastrophes such as vomitting, gangrene and miscarriages.

If we look at the Salem community affected by the witch hunts and the area believed to be contaminated by ergot, the overlap is quite startling.

It's only a thoery, but a plausible one nonetheless.


Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Dec 1, 2000 by Saint Taco-Chako (P.S. of mixed metaphors)
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 12

Ah, yes.

And this would explain all the other witch burnings in America and Europe? And the long, long history of witch executions?

Damn you, Rye bread. Damn you to hell.


Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Jul 20, 2001 by Researcher 170889
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 13

A violently insane person - particularly if it were the captain, might be able to intimidate everyone else to a mad course of action - perhaps the others would think that they could later return after things quieted down - look how often rooms full of victims get shot or harmed because they are cowed by the guy with the gun even though he could not possibly shoot them all if they fought back. So only one person need get 'ryled' up - quite possible...

ReplyClick here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Jul 20, 2001 by Researcher 170889
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 14

Also, it seems I have heard of these humongous squid - and a theory that some ships might have been attacked by these - not sure if it was ever thorized about the Mary celeste - but I can clearly see a drawing of this happening in my mind which was published somewhere. I know the largest squid ever sighted were enormous!

Also - why were 1700 casks of alcohol "in effect" half a load? Wouldn't they be 'in fact' half a load? A foot square (or half-metre square) of some enormously heavy substance that weighed the equal of 1700 casks of alcohol would be 'in effect' half a load....


Reply
Read the first reply to this Posting
Click here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Jul 20, 2001 by Researcher 170889
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 15

And I LOVE the Salem theory that the SANE people murdered the ones who were 'bewitched' by rye ergot! I also find it totally plausible - after all their heirs elected George Bush!

ReplyClick here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingNext Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted Jan 1, 2003 by slupSkipper
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 16

actually, the crew abandoned ship because they had reason to believe that by means of the damaged alcohol cask there was an explosion to happen. Probably, there already was a minor explosion / puffing noise. Then a fresh wind took the brigantine away so the lifeboat couldn't follow. That garantueed a safe distance, in case the boat would indeed explode.

ReplyClick here to register a complaint about this Posting

Previous PostingThere is no Next Posting
Subject: An implausible theory
Posted May 9, 2003 by Gordon, Ringer of Bells, Keeper of Postal Codes and Maps No One Can Re-fold Properly
This is a reply to this Posting.
Post: 17

It's funny that aliens were mentioned. An episode of Doctor Who had the Daleks exterminating the crew.

tea towel


ReplyClick here to register a complaint about this Posting


Most of the content on h2g2 is created by h2g2's Researchers, who are members of the public. The views expressed are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those of the BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of any external sites referenced. In the event that you consider anything on this page to be in breach of the site's House Rules, please click here. For any other comments, please click on the Feedback button above.


About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy