• Skip to main content
  • Text Only version of this page
  • Access keys help

BBC Home

Explore the BBC


12th July 2009
Accessibility help
Text only
film network - short films from new British filmmakerssearch film network

BBC Homepage
Film
film network home
my profile
submit your short
magazine
film making guide
film catalogue
people catalogue
mobile
sitehelp
related links
film network feeds

Contact Us


Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 
New visitors:  Create your membership
Returning members:  Sign in
DramaComedyDocumentaryAnimationExperimentalMusic
What Barry Says
Simon Robson
average rating from 46 members 
       
documentary | 2004 | London | 3 min
Published 25 Nov 04
An uncompromising examination and criticism of US foreign policy, according to Barry from down the pub.
email iconsend to a friend
 

The license to this film has expired and can no longer be viewed on film network

synopsis
Barry is a friend of mine, who to put it mildly, is an astute political thinker. He's also an old hippy and therefore a 'right' lefty. Many times we'd be sat in our local pub and I'd be there, totally captivated by Barry and his knowledge and opinions on his area of speciality: US foreign policy.

Barry always accused me of being a 'fence-sitter'. "Soon there'll be no political middle ground," he'd say. "You'll have to jump one way or another." So i jumped.

This piece is an uncompromising examination and criticism of US foreign policy, in particular 'the project for the new American century'. The film is really there to illustrate Barry's words. The question was always, how do we get other people interested in this stuff? The answer was to create an animation which would give visual form and resonance to Barry's dialogue and grab the audience's attention.

Barry's happy with it, so that's a start.
short fact
This is my first film outside the commercial sphere. For me it was time to do something that didn't involve brands and the like. I've done animation work over the last few years as a freelancer and full-timer for multimedia, installation and broadcast. I could do a client list, but I don't really think that's what this is about.

This is my first film. Enough said.
crew
  • director Simon Robson
  • producer Simon Robson
festivals, awards and screenings include:
  • onedotzero7 2003
  • © 2004 Simon Robson

    comments

    subscribe/unsubscribe to receive email alerts for new comments on this film
    more about email alerts 
    add your comments
    comment by Moderated Comment

    This post has been Removed

    comment by Stephen  Follows
    Click this button if you think
				this comment breaks the house rules
    posted May 1, 2007

    The look and style are great, very well done and thoroughly support the politics of the film.

    Stephen  Follows is Writer / Producer and short film consultant and a member of Film Network's Industry Panel.
    comment by Michael  Hey
    Click this button if you think
				this comment breaks the house rules
    posted Mar 13, 2007

    In your words, your friend Barrie is an "acute political thinker". I'm sure this is true, but to my mind, his analysis, as represented by this excellent film, misses on one key point.

    In the words of Noam Chomsky: "The smart way to keep people passive and obedient is to strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion, but allow very lively debate within that spectrum."

    According to Barry, Sept 11 "was merely the pretext", for war and destruction. This view falls well within the spectrum of acceptable opinion, and actually re-enforces the status quo. A far more simple and logical explanation would be that Sept 11 was engineered and executed by the US Administration in order to generate a pretext for war. Everything we know about Sept 11, 2001 bears out this alternate hypothesis. Unfortunately, this simple truth lies beyond the realm of acceptable opinion.

    Much has come to light since you posted this video. I'd be curious to know if Barry's take on 9/11 has evolved at all since you created this piece.

    comment by Andy  Glynne
    Click this button if you think
				this comment breaks the house rules
    posted Jul 20, 2006

    I am a sucker for using animaton and documentary together. I think the style is fantastic here, and reminds me in some ways of films like "The Corporation" which uses archive and motion graphics to consider the mepthor that the big corporations hold the same qualities of a psycopath. So, a big applause for this film. I would say however, that its exposition could have been thought through a little bit more; films like this with an overt polemic and agenda can often have an alienating effect by perhaps being slightly too bias, and have the danger of being percieved a wee bit of a rant. A subjective vision is one thing, but there is a slight danger here of it being too skewed. But lovely film, anyway!

    comment by Neillalif
    Click this button if you think
				this comment breaks the house rules
    posted Jun 24, 2006

    A concise and current version of the world today led by the domination of the only remaining superpower. Great animation and voice over .

    view all comments 
    add your comments  
    Click ! on a comment that breaks the house rules
    send someone a message
    You can message anyone whose name appears as a link by clicking through to their profile page.
    alert editors
    If you were involved with this film and notice any errors on this page, please email the editors.
    rate this film
    5     
    4     
    3     
    2     
    1     

    see comments on this film 
    add your comments  
    useful links
    • www.onedotzero.com
    • www.knife-party.net
    distributed by
    onedotzero

    onedotzero selection
    This film was selected by onedotzero.

    more shorts with similar themes

    This film is included in the film catalogue under the following themes:

    • Talking Heads
    onedotzero Film Index

    Some of the content on Film Network is generated by members of the public. The views expressed are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those of the BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of any external sites referenced. If you consider this content to be in breach of the house rules please alert our moderators.

    About Film Network
    Film Network is a showcase and community for up-and-coming UK filmmakers
    Find out more  



    About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy