BBC Home

Explore the BBC


18th December 2014
Accessibility help
Text only

BBC Homepage

Contact Us


Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 
this conversation is related to a page called
talk
all related conversations
page 2 of 2
 first post |  previous 12 next  | latest post 
I Am Legend - starring Will Smith? post 21
comment by Chrispy    Feb 14, 2007
I'm going with Syd on this one! After reading this thread, I found the book and have started reading it and am really getting into it! Its reminiscent of an early Stephen King/Dean Koontz, and as DK is my favourite author of the gothic horror/Sci-Fi genre, I'd have to say reading something that pre-dates his work by a decades, yet still reads as fresh as any of todays efforts is great in my book (punzzzzz)

The main issue is, I would never have had the opportunity to read this book if it werent for the thread (thanks to the OP) and would probably be reading it, after its re-released (with Will Smith on the front cover) upon the films release, and would be comparing it to the film, and not as the stand-alone piece of literary genious it is. The thread would not exist without the film, and although i'm sure this thread has only changed the lives of about 3/4 people tops, I'm glad its come about so I have had the opportunity to discover the novel and enjoy it.

But after reading what I've read, yes, a film with Will Smith in it will suck (more punzzzzz). I'll wait for DVD to watch it i think (pirate most prob!)
complain about this page
I Am Legend - starring Will Smith? post 22
comment by Chief_Anderson    Feb 24, 2007
Sorry Syd, I haven't been on for a while. I reread my comment about I Am Legend and I think it looks really bitchy - sorry if that's how it came across, it wasn't meant to.

It's certainly good that the interest in the film has meant you found the original. It's funny sometimes what prompts us to get into something or to give something a go.
complain about this page
I Am Legend - starring Will Smith? post 23
comment by Quikky    Jan 1, 2008
Just watched the movie and remembered this article. I've never read the novel so I've no idea how much the film parallels it - I imagine pretty vaguely - but in fairness, it wasn't bad at all. It had a decent atypical Holywood ending, which was unexpected, and Smudger did pretty well throughout, despite the regularly hokey dialogue.

It could certainly have been better - deeper, darker and scarier - but with a movie this expensive, concessions obviously have to be made in order to maximise profits on the largest possible target demographic. If anything, the 15-rating sweet spot was the one thing that held the movie back from being highly likeable.

An American 28 Days Later it wasn't, but to be honest, the quality of sleep I had after that particular film means I'm pretty content that it's not.
complain about this page
I Am Legend - starring Will Smith? post 24
comment by Syd    Jan 2, 2008
http://www.bbc.co.uk/films/2007/12/24/i_am_legend_...

This is quite a fair review I think.

I had very low expectation when I saw it.

Turned out not to be so bad.

Nothing like the book of course, but not to bad at all.
complain about this page
I Am Legend - starring Will Smith? post 25
comment by rowan    Jan 3, 2008
I tend to agree with that review too - the ending's rubbish.
complain about this page
I Am Legend - starring Will Smith? post 26
comment by Syd    Jan 3, 2008
Yeah the ending was most disappointing.
complain about this page
I Am Legend - starring Will Smith? post 27
comment by Captain Neville - ScouseBuster    Jan 3, 2008
I didn't think much of it.
complain about this page
I Am Legend - starring Will Smith? post 28
comment by Crimson_Blade    Jan 4, 2008
I thought it was quite good people have been slaggin off the vampires but they must have spent a bomb on making the city look empty I thought it was good.

The ending felt a bit rushed and there wasnt a massive amount of action but I thought Will Smith was good in and it was a good film, not amazing but I dont feel like I wasted my money
complain about this page
I Am Legend - starring Will Smith? post 29
comment by DataPunk    Jan 7, 2008
Agreed there.

I think fans of the Transformers movie ( voted one of the best film of 2007 in one of the numerous London free paper !!!) will like this. Sure the first 30 minutes are tense, and the shots of apocalyptic NY are great but this has been done before. I thought the film did not give viewers anything new or added anything different to the genre. But then, that was probably expecting a little too much of a movie starring Will-Fesh-Garenteed Audience With Your Target Market-Prince of Bel-Air. Did anyone found that peuso-moral-philosophical bable on Bob Marley going to this gig after being shot and "standing up for his right" a little weird and obessive ?! Makes me want to eat flesh...
complain about this page
I Am Legend - starring Will Smith? post 30
comment by Claudefather    Jan 14, 2008
Oh You mean "I Am Fail - starring Will Smith?"

only joking (a bit)

I thought it was gonna be good but i ended up not thinking much of it....yes it's ok but nothing special

complain about this page
I Am Legend - starring Will Smith? post 31
comment by tunchie    Jan 14, 2008
well not to worry as apparently he's concentrating on his music next year
complain about this page
I Am Legend - starring Will Smith? post 32
comment by Crimson_Blade    Jan 16, 2008
He's in a film called Hancock about an alcoholic superhero, ive seen the trailer it looks hilarious
complain about this page
I Am Legend - SPOILERS INCLUDED post 33
comment by sirbobwallett    Jan 28, 2008
I finally saw this movie and must say it was quite good, until the ___SPOILERS___

other 2 people appeared. I thought they were going to be the sabatours similar to what the book had (a lady sent to get close to Neville)








complain about this page
I Am Legend - SPOILERS INCLUDED post 34
comment by Dan aka o Sabotage o    Feb 25, 2008
This thread also inspired me to read the book. After the film I was very curious to read the origianl ending.

All in all I think they did a pretty good job in translating it to the big screen. A straight transition from book to film wouldnt of really worked in my view.
-SPOILER-

Having the dog from the very start in the film was a better idea (giving him a companion) and the idea with the manaquins shows how you would try to live with solidarity and try to (maybe) stay sane. Also prefered the film with the zombies been infection as a result of a vaccine for cancer (if I remember correctly). Rather than the typical garlic, mirrors, crosses etc etc.

at the end of the day, the only thing that was slightly dissapointing was the ending. But really all in all a very good interpretation of a classic book.
complain about this page
I Am Legend - SPOILERS INCLUDED post 35
comment by Quikky    Mar 10, 2008
For those who didn't like the movie's ending, how about this alternate version:

http://io9.com/365403/the-i-am-legend-you-didnt-ge...
complain about this page
page 2 of 2
 first post |  previous 12 next  | latest post 
all related conversations
archive

collective's dead...
Long live Collective. Read our editor and member features.
front row
front row


About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy