BBC Home

Explore the BBC


10th February 2010
Accessibility help
Text only

BBC Homepage

Contact Us


Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 
reviews /  editor album review
editor content by: editor
elbow 'leaders of the free world' elbow
leaders of the free world
(v2)
watch 

watch video

listen 

listen to FULL track

real player to access audio and video on collective you need real player.
Coldplay by candlelight.

While Coldplay translated a similarly expansive sound into mega-sales, Elbow can take consolation in critical kudos. Fixed on the pop ley-line that links XTC’s pastoral epic Skylarking to Robert Wyatt’s serene Rock Bottom, their third album nails Guy Garvey’s blend of poignancy and pathos perfectly. Opener Station Approach sets a lusciously understated tone as Leaders Of The Free World unfurls as a bombast-free alternative to stadium rock. A big noise perhaps, but a pleasantly cuddly one, too.


Jim Wirth 01 September 05 rating of 4
Elbow – Leaders of the Free World, out 12 September on V2
 comments
Read members' comments related to this album.
best album of the year? post 15
comment by Natmandu    Dec 31, 2005
I knew it was an Elbow album when the first track did exactly the same trick as the last two albums, and made the hairs on the back of my neck stand up. Beautiful.
complain about this page
best album of the year? post 14
comment by Vikster    Oct 20, 2005
It's definitely up there, I reckon. Absolutely cracking. Guy Garvey sings like an angel and the whole sound is just gorgeous. Better than Coldplay? No contest.
complain about this page
no comparison post 13
comment by clever_rabbit    Sep 13, 2005
y'know Chris Martin claimd that "Grace under pressure" was the direct inspiration for "Fix you"?? i like Elbow best personally, although Coldplay's Warchild song is really quite amazing. really angry like.
complain about this page
coldplay by candlelight? post 12
comment by The Exploding Boy     Sep 9, 2005
I agree. Martin is a musician, not a frikkin' politician!

complain about this page
coldplay by candlelight? post 11
comment by kingofthebees    Sep 8, 2005
I dunno. how easy is it to be "in touch with the public"? We seem to expect it of every sod in the arts, media or politics, but come to think of it, i'm not sure i could constantly make a connection with the "real world" if everything was conspiring to drag me away from it? We make these people stars, then journalists, photographers and indeed the public in general hound them so much they have to either spend all of their time with people in the same boat or are forced into hermitdom.
complain about this page
coldplay by candlelight? post 10
comment by Arnofio    Sep 8, 2005
Too right. Coldplay have to be the most dreary band ever. There simply is no comparison between them & Elbow. Chris Martin has lost touch with the public, which is a seriously bad move.
complain about this page
coldplay by candlelight? post 9
comment by The Exploding Boy     Sep 6, 2005
Wonderful!
complain about this page
coldplay by candlelight? post 8
comment by fingerchimp    Sep 6, 2005
how about the meta tarsals? the eustachian tubes? erethroblastosis and the invitro infections?
complain about this page
coldplay by candlelight? post 7
comment by The Exploding Boy     Sep 6, 2005
I quite like that.

How about 'clavicle'? You know, it has that edge,,,
complain about this page
coldplay by candlelight? post 6
comment by kingofthebees    Sep 6, 2005
if i start a band today we will be called "the bones of the inner ear".
complain about this page

related info
coldplay
www.elbow.co.uk
note: The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.
see also
elbow
interview

on bbc.co.uk/music
archive

collective's dead...
Long live Collective. Read our editor and member features.
radio 1
radio 1


About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy